Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 23;6(7):e04448. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2020.e04448
Data no. Clause Mood type Speech function realization Technique Strategy of persuasion reflected Function in Parapgraph
Clause 01 In his famous mu'allaqah poem, the Jahili poet ‘Amr Ibn Kulthum said, “And we had many glorious and long days, we defied the king therein, lest we obey.” Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 02 The word he used for “we obey” is “nadin,” from the well-known but oft-misunderstood root word “din.” Declarative Statement of opinion presenting the meaning/the characteristic of something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 03 Usually translated as “religion,” and indeed it is that, one of the basic meanings of din is obedience, and is especially used – as in the above verse of poetry – in reference to the authority and rule of a king. Declarative Statement of opinion presenting the meaning/the characteristic of something Nature of situation Main information
Clause 04 Allah said in the story of Yusuf, “Thus We plotted for Yusuf. He would not take his brother by the din of the king” (Yusuf 76), meaning, “by the rule and authority of the king,” or as at-Tabari commented, “Yusuf would not take his brother by the rule, judgment, or obedience of the king of Egypt.” Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 05 He then mentioned the various statements of the Salaf suggesting that “din” in this ayah means sultan (authority), qada (judgment), and hukm (rule), ending his commentary by saying, “And the basis of din is obedience.” Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 06 As for our King – the King of mankind, the King of the Day of Recompense, the True King – then we have entered into His din and must obey His rule wholeheartedly, Declarative Indirect directive presenting the obligation of someone to do something Assertion Supporting information
Clause 07 and He said, “And fight them until there is no fitnah and the din is for Allah. But if they cease, then there is no aggression except against the tyrants” (Al-Baqarah 193). Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 08 So the command of Allah– to which obedience is due as a religious duty – is to fight until there is no fitnah, i.e. evident shirk in the obedience of Allah, and until no manifest authority is given to any rule except to that of the True King. Declarative Indirect directive (necessity) presenting the obligation of someone to do something Duty Main information
Clause 09 His saying, “if they cease,” means that if they submit or surrender, then they are to be left alone. Declarative Statement of opinion presenting the meaning/the characteristic of something Nature of situation Supporting information
Clause 10 This can either be in the form of repentance to Allah and abiding by His worship alone or by the paying of jizyah while remaining upon subjugated kufr, just as Allah said, regarding the command of killing the mushrikin in general, “Then if they repent, establish the prayer, and pay the zakah, then leave them alone” (At-Tawbah 5), and He said that the People of the Book – those who “do not adhere to the true din” – should specifically be fought “until they pay the jizyah willingly, while they are humiliated” (At-Tawbah 29). Declarative Statement of opinion presenting the meaning/the characteristic of something Nature of situation Supporting information
Clause 11 And “there is no aggression except against the tyrants” means those who did not submit nor surrender, either through repentance or dhimmah, the covenant of jizyah. Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation Supporting information
Clause 12 Thus, anyone who is neither a Muslim nor a dhimmi kafir (while still a tyrant against himself, deserving both hatred and humiliation) is a hostile tyrant deserving aggression. Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation Main information
Clause 13 This is because shirk itself is dhulm (tyranny), as Allah said, “And when Luqman said to his son, admonishing him, ‘O my son, do not commit shirk with Allah. Verily shirk is a great tyranny’” (Luqman 13). Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation Supporting information
Clause 14 And although the people of dhimmah are mushrikin from the People of the Book, their shirk is subjugated and humiliated under the Shari'ah of Allah enforced upon them. Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation Supporting information
Clause 15 So the duty to fight the tyrants – the mushrikin – is clear and established. Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Duty Main information
Clause 16 But Allah did not only command the “fighting” of disbelievers, as if to say He only wants us to conduct frontline operations against them. Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Duty Supporting information
Clause 17 Rather, He has also ordered that they be slain wherever they may be – on or off the battlefield. Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Duty Supporting information
Clause 18 He said, “So when the sacred months have passed, then kill the mushrikin wherever you find them and take them, surround them, and wait for them at every outpost” (At-Tawbah 5). Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 19 All of this becomes all the more apparent for those who have realized that the blood of a kafir is cheap, filthy, and permissible to shed. Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation/disclaimer Supporting information
Clause 20 Islam is the religion of sound principles providing the perfect foundations upon which the solid structures of justice and glory are built. Declarative Statement of opinion presenting the meaning/the characteristic of something Nature of situation Supporting information
Clause 21 One of these great principles is that all people must be fought until they accept Islam or come under a shar'i covenant. Declarative Indirect directive presenting the obligation of someone to do something Nature of situation/duty Main information
Clause 22 This principle establishes the prohibition of shedding Muslim and covenant-bound kafir blood as well as the permissibility of shedding the blood of all other kuffar. Declarative Indirect directive Presenting prohibition of doing something Nature of situation Supporting information
Clause 23 The Prophet said, “I have been ordered to fight mankind until they say that there is no god except Allah and that I am the Messenger of Allah, and they establish the prayer and pay the zakah. Whoever does so, then his blood and wealth are safe from me except for a law- ful reason” (Reported by al-Bukhari and Muslim from Ibn ‘Umar), and he said, addressing the Muslims, “For verily your blood, wealth, and honor are haram to each other” (Reported by al-Bukhari and Muslim from Abu Bakrah). Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 24 And regarding the dhimmi – the one who has a covenant with the Muslims –the Prophet said, “Whoever kills a person of covenant shall not smell the fragrance of Jannah, which can be found for a distance of forty years” (Reported by al-Bukhari and Muslim from ‘Abdullah Ibn ‘Amr). Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical empirical/duty Main information
Clause 25 These narrations offer an explanation of the ayah, “And do not kill a soul which Allah has forbidden except for a lawful reason” (Al-An'am 151), about which at-Tabari said, “The soul which Allah has forbidden is the soul of a believer or a person of covenant, and His saying, ‘except for a lawful reason,’ means that which permits such a soul to be killed, as in capital punishment for murder, or stoning an adulterer to death, or killing someone for apostasy.” Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Duty Supporting information
Clause 26 As for all others – meaning all disbelievers who have no covenant – then their blood has not been given the sanctity of prohibition, but remains under the command to fight mankind, so their blood remains halal. Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation/duty Main information
Clause 27 Shedding the blood of a non-dhimmi kafir is not sinful, but is rather rewarded with Jannah. Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation/expertise (positive) Supporting information
Clause 28 Allah's Messenger said, “A kafir and his killer will never be gathered together in the Fire” (Reported by Muslim from Abu Hurayrah). Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 29 Furthermore, his words, “I have been ordered to fight mankind,” leave no room for debate, as mankind includes every person in the world, Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation Supporting information
Clause 30 and the only ones excluded from this order to fight are those who submit or surrender to the rule of Islam, as was previously mentioned. Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation Supporting information
Clause 31 This alone befits a messenger who was sent to all people, as Allah β said, “Say, ‘O mankind, verily I am the Messenger of Allah sent to all of you’” (Al-A'raf 158), Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation Supporting information
Clause 32 and the Prophet said, “Other prophets were sent to their people alone, but I was sent to all of mankind” (Reported by al-Bukhari from Jabir Ibn ‘Abdillah). Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 33 Lest someone think this is a strange, new opinion, it should be known that this is the stance of the Sahabah and the greatest scholars of the Ummah. Declarative Indirect request Giving suggestion Suggestion.nature of situation Main information
Clause 34 This is reflected in the words of ‘Umar Ibn al-Khattab who, during the life of the Prophet and without objection, said to Abu Jandal, encouraging him to kill his father Suhayl Ibn ‘Amr, “Be patient, Abu Jandal, for they are merely mushrikin, and their blood is nothing but (like) the blood of a dog” (Reported by Ahmad from al-Miswar Ibn Makhramah). Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Logical empirical/duty Supporting information
Clause 35 Indeed, ‘Umar was correct, as the mushrikin are entirely impure, as Allah said, “O you who believe! The mushrikin are nothing but impure” (At-Tawbah 28). Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation Supporting information
Clause 36 This is also understood from the words of Anas Ibn Malik, who was asked, “O Abu Hamzah! What makes a slave's (i.e. a person's) blood and wealth haram?” Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation Supporting information
Clause 37 He replied, “Whoever testifies that there is no god but Allah, faces our qiblah, prays our prayer, and eats what we slaughter, then he is a Muslim. He gets what a Muslim gets and is bound by what a Muslim is bound” (Reported by al-Bukhari from Maymum Ibn Siyah). Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 38 Ash-Shafi'i said, “And the kafir's blood is not spared until he becomes a Muslim” (Al-Umm). Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 39 In further explanation, he said, “Allah spared blood and restricted the taking of wealth, except for a lawful reason, through belief in Allah and in His Messenger or through a covenant given by the believers, based on the rule of Allah and His Messenger, to the People of the Book. Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 40 And He allowed shedding the blood of mature men who refrain from belief and who do not have a covenant. Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Duty Supporting information
Clause 41 Allah said, ‘So when the sacred months have passed, then kill the mushrikin wherever you find them and take them, surround them, and wait for them at every out- post’ (At-Tawbah 5)” (Al-Umm). Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 42 Mentioning the exception of killing women and children, he also said, “And the reason for the prohibition of shedding Muslim blood being different from the prohibition of shedding the kafir child's and kafir woman's blood is that they are not to be killed due to specific revelation restricting this killing [while the initial ruling allows shedding kafir blood in general]. Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 43 And our opinion regarding this – and Allah knows best – is that the restriction exists so that they can become slaves, which is more beneficial than killing them, and killing them does not harm the enemy; so making them slaves is more optimal than killing them” (Al-Umm). Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation Main information
Clause 44 Al-Khattabi said, “The kafir's blood is permissible because he has not yet uttered the word of tawhid; but if he were to say it, then his blood is spared and becomes prohibited” (A'lam al-Hadith). Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 45 Ibn Hazm, after mentioning the prohibition of targeting women and children, said, “And it is permissible to kill anyone – other than those we mentioned above – of the mushrikin, both the combatant and non-combatant, the businessman and employee, the elderly man – whether or not he be a person of influence – the farmer, the bishop or priest or monk, the blind or crippled – no one is given exception” (Al-Muhalla). Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 46 Ibn Qudamah mentioned the harbi (the kafir who is not under a covenant) and said, “Shedding his blood is permissible without exception, just like swine” (Al-Mughni). Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 47 He also said, “The kuffar asliyyin [those kuffar who are not murtaddin] shall have no protection in their own lands” (Al-Mughni). Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 48 Ibn Rushd said, “And the principle is that what makes wealth permissible to take is kufr, and that which protects it is Islam, just as the Prophet γ said, ‘Then if they said that, they have protected their blood and their wealth from me’” (Bidayat al-Mujtahid). Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 49 While specifically mentioning wealth, his words clearly point to the permissibility of bloodshed as is also in the evidence he quoted. Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation Main information
Clause 50 Al-Qurtubi, said, “If a Muslim meets a kafir who has no covenant, it is permissible for him to kill him.” Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 51 Abu Hanifah said, regarding a kafir who is killed, “There is no retaliation (against the killer) and the diyah (blood money) is not to be paid, because the blood of the kafir is permissible (to shed) unless it is established that he has a covenant or is under dhimmah” (Al-Hawi al-Kabir). Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 52 Like-wise, the famous Hanafi scholar al-Kashani said, “The principle is that it is permissible to kill anyone from amongst the people who are at war (with the Muslims), whether they fight or do not fight. Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 53 But it is not permissible to kill anyone who is not from the people who are at war [meaning those with a valid covenant], unless they fight or offer strategic support, obedience, instigation, or otherwise. Declarative Indirect directive Presenting prohibition of doing something Assertion Main information
Clause 54 So the priest and wandering ascetic who mix with the people are to be killed, as are those who have fits of insanity, and the deaf and mute, and the one with a severed hand or foot, even if they did not fight. Declarative Indirect directive presenting the obligation of someone to do something Assertion Supporting information
Clause 55 This is because they are from the same people who are at war [with the Muslims]” (Badai’ as-Sanai’). Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation Supporting information
Clause 56 None of this should be surprising to any Muslim who has studied his religion, as this matter of a kafir's blood being halal to shed is something upon which scholars have recorded consensus. Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation Main information
Clause 57 At-Tabari said, “They [the scholars of Islam] have agreed that even if a mushrik were to wear the bark of all the trees of the Haram [in Makkah] around his neck and on his arms, that would not grant him safety from being killed unless the Muslims gave him a covenant of dhimmah or security.” Declarative Statement of fact telling about someone saying something Logical-empirical Supporting information
Clause 58 Muslims currently living in Dar al-Kufr must be reminded that the blood of the disbelievers is halal, and killing them is a form of worship to Allah, the Lord, King, and God of mankind. Declarative Indirect directive presenting the obligation of someone to do something Assertion Main information
Clause 59 This includes the businessman riding to work in a taxicab, the young adults (post-pubescent “children”) engaged in sports activities in the park, and the old man waiting in line to buy a sandwich. Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation Supporting information
Clause 60 Indeed, even the blood of the kafir street vendor selling flowers to those passing by is halal to shed Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation/assertion Supporting information
Clause 61 – and striking terror into the hearts of all disbelievers is a Muslim's duty. Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Assertion/Duty Supporting information
Clause 62 There is no shar'i requirement to target soldiers and policemen nor judges and politicians, Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation Supporting information
Clause 63 but all kuffar who are not under the covenant of dhimmah are fair game. Declarative Statement of opinion giving an evaluative opinion of something Nature of situation/assertion Supporting information
Clause 64 How can the disbelievers ever dream of safety and security while Muslims suffer anywhere in the world and while the rule of Allah is mockingly replaced by manmade monstrosities of democracy? Interrogative Indirect directive asking “How can someone do something, while something is in certain situation?” Moral appeal Main information