Trial ID | Date trial author contacted | Date trial author replied | Date trial author was asked for additional information (short summary) | Date trial author provided data (short summary) |
Madjd 2017 | 31 July 2018; 10 January 2019 |
No answer | NA | NA |
IRCT2015091513612N6 | 3 August 2018 | No answer | NA | NA |
Ensor 2015 | 17 June 2019 | No answer | NA | NA |
Barriocanal 2008 | 1 August 2018 | No answer | NA | NA |
Maki 2008 | 3 August 2018 | No answer | NA | NA |
EUCTR2006‐002395‐18‐DK | 30 July 2018 | 31 July 2018 | NA | 31 July 2018: the author informed us "that the study have never been executed" |
Grotz 2003 | 3 August 2018 | No answer | NA | NA |
Colagiuri 1989 | 3 August 2018 | No answer | NA | NA |
Cooper 1988 | 3 August 2018 | No answer | NA | NA |
Chantelau 1985 | 3 August 2018 | 3 August 2018 | 10 August 2018 Questions regarding method and outcomes reported |
11 August 2018: authors clarified methodological issues (participants were recruited until N = 10 was achieved; randomisation of what to start with (sucrose versus cyclamate) was done openly by flipping a coin; body weight was measured independently by personnel unrelated to the study; there were no dropouts); raw data are no longer available. They wrote that "separate statistical analysis – although not reported ‐ for sucrose first versus cyclamate first was done, but did not reveal any significant difference". |
Nehrling 1985 | No email address available | NA | NA | NA |
Stern 1976 | No email address available | NA | NA | NA |
NA: not applicable. |