Skip to main content
. 2020 May 25;2020(5):CD012885. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012885.pub2
Trial ID Date trial author contacted Date trial author replied Date trial author was asked for additional information
(short summary) Date trial author provided data
(short summary)
Madjd 2017 31 July 2018;
10 January 2019
No answer NA NA
IRCT2015091513612N6 3 August 2018 No answer NA NA
Ensor 2015 17 June 2019 No answer NA NA
Barriocanal 2008 1 August 2018 No answer NA NA
Maki 2008 3 August 2018 No answer NA NA
EUCTR2006‐002395‐18‐DK 30 July 2018 31 July 2018 NA 31 July 2018: the author informed us "that the study have never been executed"
Grotz 2003 3 August 2018 No answer NA NA
Colagiuri 1989 3 August 2018 No answer NA NA
Cooper 1988 3 August 2018 No answer NA NA
Chantelau 1985 3 August 2018 3 August 2018 10 August 2018
Questions regarding method and outcomes reported
11 August 2018: authors clarified methodological issues (participants were recruited until N = 10 was achieved; randomisation of what to start with (sucrose versus cyclamate) was done openly by flipping a coin; body weight was measured independently by personnel unrelated to the study; there were no dropouts); raw data are no longer available. They wrote that "separate statistical analysis – although not reported ‐ for sucrose first versus cyclamate first was done, but did not reveal any significant difference".
Nehrling 1985 No email address available NA NA NA
Stern 1976 No email address available NA NA NA
NA: not applicable.