Table 2.
Element | Initial prototype | Problem | Functional prototype | Output |
MISa forceps | The shaft of the forceps is black | Difficulties in the detection of the forceps by the LMCb | The shaft of the forceps is white | Notable improvement in detection of the forceps by the LMC |
Support devices | No support devices | Fulcrum effect not reproduced | Design of support devices | Reproduction of fulcrum effect |
Mounting pad | No mounting pad | The hardware pieces (LMC and support devices) are independent, and there is no standard arrangement | Standardized integration of the pieces in the mounting pad | Physical stability of the model |
Position of the LMC | Completely horizontal, 90 degree with regard to the screen | Difficulties in the detection of the forceps by the LMC | A forward 45-degree angle was applied with regard to the screen | Interference between the forceps when detected by the LMC was eliminated |
First prototype of the 3D virtual environment (Figure 6) | Tests on the interaction between the forceps and the objects in the virtual environment | Difficulty for interaction between the forceps and the objects in the environment | Trial and error tests on interaction by modifying LMC and instrumental variables | Complete interaction achieved |
Second prototype of the 3D virtual environment (Figure 7) | Functional environment in the 6 tasks | Quadrangular shapes in the environment | Circular shapes in the good enough environment (Figure 8) | An abstract 3D virtual environment with circular shapes |
Good enough environment (Figure 8) | SQLc database engine not integrated into the simulation software | A software program should be installed in addition to the simulation program | Redesign of the model and data capture and storage | Feedback and metrics complete and integrated into the SQLite Integration of the SQL database engine into the simulation software |
aMIS: minimally invasive surgery.
bLMC: Leap Motion Controller.
cSQL: Structured Query Language.