Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 20;2020(7):CD013684. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013684

Kanekar 2010.

Methods Study design: RCT
Study grouping: parallel group
Unit of randomisation: individuals
Power (power & sample size calculation, level of power achieved): A sample size of 25 students in each group was reached considering an alpha of 0.05, power of 0.70 and estimated effect size of 0.70; study accounted for attrition of 5 participants and hence the sample size was increased to 30 per group; some of the limitations of the study: small sample size (considerable dropout of 21)
Imputation of missing data: no imputation of missing data reported; unclear how many participants dropped out of the intervention and how many did not complete the questionnaires; probably available‐case analysis (only participants for whom outcomes were obtained) and per‐protocol analysis (only participants who completed allocated intervention)
Participants Country: USA
Setting: large research‐1 university in Ohio
Age: mean = 24.67 (SD = 2.68); range = 21 ‐ 33 years
Sample size (randomised): 60
Sex: 5 women, 34 men
Comorbidity (mean (SD) of respective measures in indicated, if available) at baseline: No‐one in the study population ever had mental illness and the group was mentally healthy
Population description: international students of Asian Indian origin enrolled full‐time at large Research‐I university in Ohio
Inclusion criteria: 1) student had to be an Indian citizen by birth; 2) student must have lived for at least 15 years in India immediately prior to entering the USA
Exclusion criteria: not specified
Attrition (withdrawals and exclusions): high dropout rate (n = 21 dropouts)
Reasons for missing data: not specified; reasons can be conjectured to be time commitment to the study, participant interest in the study, length of survey instrument
Interventions Intervention: internet‐based intervention to enhance social support, hardiness, and acculturation (n = 30)
  • delivery: web‐based instruction; online instruction delivered through BlackboardTM; reminder e‐mails sent once a week to encourage participants to complete the online modules and attempt the activities

  • providers: self‐guided intervention

  • duration of treatment period and timing: 3 sessions over 2 months

  • description:

    • focused on social support, hardiness and acculturation

    • SESSION 1: social support; discusses types of social support, benefits of social support, relationship between social support and mental health; activities for participants to identify and build social support around them

    • SESSION 2: hardiness; discusses benefits of hardiness, activities to increase commitment, control and challenge

    • SESSION 3: acculturation; discusses different components of acculturation; benefits of acculturation; ways one could increase acculturation in the American culture

  • compliance: not specified

  • integrity of delivery: not specified

  • economic information cash incentive

  • theoretical basis: no theoretical foundation specified; multimodal


Control: attention control (general health awareness and wellness intervention; n = 30)
  • delivery: web‐based instruction; online instruction delivered through BlackboardTM; reminder e‐mails sent once a week to encourage participants to complete the online modules and attempt the activities

  • providers: self‐guided intervention

  • duration of treatment period and timing: 3 sessions over 2 months

  • description:

    • focused on general health awareness and wellness

    • SESSION 1: wellness and eating; information on identifying dietary habits, ways for maintaining regular weight and response of body to variety of foods

    • SESSION 2: wellness and physical activity; information on motivation for physical activity, easy steps for physical activity, ways to maintain regular physical activity

    • SESSION 3: wellness and thinking; ways to maintain positive attitude, increasing will power, and developing opportunities for creative expression

  • compliance: not specified

  • integrity of delivery: not specified

  • economic information: cash incentive

  • theoretical basis: not specified

Outcomes Outcomes collected and reported:
  • mental health ‐ Kessler Psychological Distress Scale‐K‐10

  • social support ‐ ISEL

  • social support, belonging ‐ ISEL

  • social support, appraisal ‐ ISEL

  • social support, tangible support ‐ ISEL

  • acculturation ‐ American International Relations Scale

  • acculturation, language usage ‐ American International Relations Scale

  • acculturation, perceived prejudice ‐ American International Relations Scale

  • acculturation, acculturation ‐ American International Relations Scale

  • hardiness ‐ hardiness scale

  • hardiness, challenge ‐ hardiness scale

  • hardiness, commitment ‐ hardiness scale

  • hardiness, control ‐ hardiness scale


Time points measured and reported: 1) pre‐intervention; 2) post‐intervention
Adverse events: not specified
Notes Contact with authors: We contacted the authors about the inclusion of healthcare students in the sample. We received the response from the authors that "health‐related international students were not specifically targeted by the study and there could have been some health professionals in the sample; the sample was composed of international students from diverse departments across the university campus" (Kanekar 2019 [pers comm]).
Study start/end date: not specified
Funding source: not specified
Declaration of interest: not specified
Ethical approval needed/obtained for study: IRB approval at the University of Ohio (June 2007)
Comments by study authors: not relevant
Miscellaneous outcomes by the review authors: according to authors, there could have been some health professionals in the final sample, but unclear how many and which participants
Correspondence: Prof. Manoj Sharma, PhD; Health Promotion and Education, University of Cincinnati, P.O. Box 210068 Cincinnati, OH 45221‐0068; manoj.sharma@uc.edu; manoj.sharma@jsums.edu