Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 10;2020(7):CD013600. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013600.pub2

Li 2020.

Study characteristics
Methods
  • Trial design: RCT

  • Type of publication: journal publication 

  • Setting: hospital

  • Recruitment dates: 14 February 2020‐1 April 2020

  • Country: China

  • Language: English

  • Number of centres: 7

  • Trial registration number: ChiCTR2000029757

  • Date of registration: NR

Participants
  • Age: median 70 years, IQR 62‐78 years 

  • Gender: 60 male (58.3%), 43 female (41.7%)

  • Ethnicity: NR

  • Number of participants (recruited/allocated/evaluated): 103 (52 CP, 51 standard treatment)

  • Severity of disease: severe or life‐threatening 

  • Co‐morbidities: hypertension, cardiovascular disease, cerebrovascular disease, diabetes, liver disease, cancer, kidney disease

  • Inclusion criteria:

    • signed informed consent

    • aged at least 18 years 

    • COVID‐19 diagnosis based on PCR testing

    • positive PCR result within 72 h prior to randomisation

    • pneumonia confirmed by chest imaging

    • clinical symptoms meeting the definitions of severe or life‐threatening COVID‐19

    • acceptance of random group assignment

    • hospital admission

    • willingness to participate in all necessary research studies and be able to complete the study follow‐up

    • no participation in other clinical trials, such as antiviral trials, during the study period

  • Exclusion criteria: 

    • pregnancy or lactation

    • immunoglobulin allergy

    • IgA deficiency

    • pre‐existing comorbidity that could increase the risk of thrombosis

    • life expectancy < 24 h

    • disseminated intravascular coagulation

    • severe septic shock

    • PaO2/FIO2 of < 100

    • severe congestive heart failure

    •  detection of high titre of S protein–RBD‐specific IgG antibody (≥ 1:640)

    • other contraindications as determined by the patient’s physicians

    • participation in any antiviral clinical trials for COVID‐19 within 30 days prior to enrolment

  • Previous treatments (e.g. experimental drug therapies, oxygen therapy, ventilation): antivirals, antibiotics, steroids, human Ig, Chinese herbal medicines, interferon

Interventions
  • CP therapy or hyperimmune immunoglobulin therapy: CP therapy

  • Details of CP:

    • Type of plasma: plasmapheresis

    • Volume: 4‐13 mL/kg of recipient body weight, median 200 mL, IQR 200‐300 mL

    • Number of doses: 1 (96%) or more

    • Antibody test and antibody‐titre: only the plasma units with an S‐RBD–specific IgG titre of at least 1:640 were used correlating to serum neutralisation titre of 1:80 

    • Pathogen inactivated or not: NR

    • RT‐PCR tested: NR

  • Details of donors:

    • Gender: both, 18‐55 years suitable for blood donation 

    • HLA and HNA antibody‐negative: NR

    • Severity of disease: NR

    • Timing from recovery from disease: discharged from hospital > 2 weeks

    • RT‐PCR tested: lab‐confirmed COVID‐19 diagnosis, 2 negative PCR results from nasopharyngeal swabs at least 24 h apart prior to hospital discharge

  • Treatment details, including time of plasma therapy (e.g. early stage of disease): severe to life‐threatening

  • For studies including a control group: comparator (type): standard therapy

  • Concomitant therapy: antivirals, antibiotics, steroids, human Ig, Chinese herbal medicines, interferon

  • Duration of follow‐up: 28 days 

  • Treatment cross‐overs: none

  • Compliance with assigned treatment: 1 participant in control arm received CP, 1 participant in CP arm discontinued study

Outcomes
  • Primary study outcome(s): clinical improvement within 28 days (patient discharged alive or reduction of 2 points on a 6‐point disease severity scale)

  • Primary review outcomes

    • All‐cause mortality at hospital discharge: reported

    • Time to death: reported

  • Secondary review outcomes

    • Number of participants with grade 3 and grade 4 AEs, including potential relationship between intervention and adverse reaction (e.g. TRALI, transfusion‐transmitted infection, TACO, TAD, acute transfusion reactions): reported

    • Number of participants with SAEs: reported

    • Improvement of clinical symptoms, assessed through need for respiratory support at up to 7 days; 8‐15 days; 16‐30 days: reported

    • 30‐day and 90‐day mortality: reported

    • Admission on the ICU: NR

    • Length of stay on the ICU: NR

    • Time to discharge from hospital: reported

    • QoL: NR

  • Additional study outcomes: rate of viral PCR to negative at up to 72 h

Notes
  • Sponsor/funding: this work was supported by the Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences Innovation Fund for Medical Sciences (CIFMS) grants 2020‐I2M‐CoV19‐006, 2016‐I2M‐3‐024 (Dr Z. Liu), and 2017‐I2M‐1‐009 (Dr L. Li) and the Nonprofit Central Research Institute Fund of Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences grant 2018PT32016 (Dr Z. Liu)

  • COIs: Dr Liu reports holding a pending patent on COVID‐19 testing. Dr Wu reports consulting for Verax Medical and Grifols, receiving royalties from UptoDate and AABB, and being a volunteer visiting professor and receiving travel support for giving medical education from the Chinese Institute of Blood Transfusion. No other disclosures were reported.

  • Other: nil