Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 15;2020(7):CD004945. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004945.pub5
Study Reason for exclusion
Alcalay 1996 PROM at term
Amano 1999 Alternate allocation trial
Ascher‐Walsh 2000 Compared 2 forms of IOL
Bell 1993 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Berghella 1996 Membrane stripping to decrease the need for formal IOL
Boulvain 1998 Membrane stripping to decrease the need for formal IOL
Buttino 1990 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Cardozo 1986 Alternate allocation trial
Conway 2000 Trial of active versus expectant management in women with oligohydramnios
CTRI/2018/09/015719 High‐risk pregnancy (women with previous caesarean) included in this trial
Damania 1992 Trial of cervical ripening (2 methods) not IOL
Dare 2002 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
De Aquino 2003 Compares 2 forms of IOL
Doany 1997 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Dunn 1989 Intervention not a policy to induce labour compared with expectant management
El‐Torkey 1992 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Elliott 1984 Trial of nipple stimulation as a method of cervical ripening. No commitment to delivery within a given time or protocol
Evans 1983 Compares 2 forms of IOL
Frass 2011 Trial where all women were judged to be at risk (severe pre‐eclampsia)
Garry 2000 Alternate allocation trial
Giacalone 1998 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Gregson 2015 Assessing effectiveness of acupuncture for IOL (role of acupuncture not established)
Hage 1993 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Heden 1991 Alternate allocation trial
Hernandez‐Castro 2008 Not a RCT
Imsuwan 1999 This is a RCT evaluating the effectiveness of weekly membrane sweeping in labour initiation for women at 41 completed weeks. It is not evaluating a policy of stopping the pregnancy at 41 weeks
Ingemarsson 1987 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Iqbal 2004 Alternate allocation trial
Jenssen 1977 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Kadar 1990 Trial of nipple stimulation as a method of cervical ripening. No commitment to delivery within a given time or protocol
Katz 1983 Alternate allocation trial
Kipikasa 2005 Comparing alternate methods for IOL
Klopper 1969 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Knox 1979 Quasi‐randomised (last digit of hospital number)
Lee 1997 Compares 2 forms of IOL
Lemancewicz 1999 Compares 2 forms of IOL
Lien 1998 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Lyons 2001 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Magann 1998 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Magann 1999 Compares 2 forms of IOL
Mancuso 1998 Compares 2 forms of IOL
Meydanli 2003 Compares 2 forms of IOL
Misra 1994 Compares 2 forms of IOL
Müller 1995 Compares 2 forms of IOL
Neri 2014 Assessing effectiveness of acupressure for IOL (role of acupuressure not established)
Newman 1997 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Nicholson 2008 Trial where all women were judged to be at risk
Ohel 1996 Alternate allocation
PACTR201805002872322 Not low risk pregnancies
Papageorgiou 1992 Compared 2 forms of IOL
Paul 1988 Protocol for RCT only ‐ no results
Rayburn 1988 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Rayburn 1999 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Rijnders 2011 Compared 2 alternative management strategies for IOL
Roberts 1986 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Satin 1991 Compared 2 forms of IOL
Sawai 1991 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Sawai 1994 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Stenlund 1999 Mifepristone versus placebo for IOL, but all women given PGE2 if necessary after 48 hours
Su 1996 Both groups induced within 2 days with alternative methods
Surbek 1997 Compared 2 forms of IOL
Suzuki 1999 Immediate IOL versus expectant management in twin pregnancies
Williams 1990 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Wing 2000 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Wong 2002 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL
Ziaei 2003 Trial of cervical ripening not IOL

IOL: induction of labour
PGE2: prostaglandin E2
PROM: premature rupture of membranes
RCT: randomised controlled trial