Skip to main content
. 2009 Apr 15;2009(2):CD006712. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD006712.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Andolsek 1977 Pain related to the abortion was not reported.
Bonazzi 1987 Unclear range of gestational age (mean 9.8 with SD of 1.6), unclear if vacuum curettage. The author could not be successsfully contacted.
Bonazzi 1994 Unclear range of gestational age (mean 9.8 with SD of 1.4), unclear if vacuum curettage. The author could not be successsfully contacted.
Cade 1993 Randomization by hospital medical records number does not qualify as randomization. Unclear if procedure was suction curettage versus sharp D&C
Ciri 1986 Pain related to the abortion was not reported.
Coad 1986 Pain is not measured with the procedure, but only as side effect of the anesthesia administration
Corli 1984 Amount of pain is measured in a dichotomous fashion only with clamping of the cervix and at what amount of cervical dilation; not with the procedure itself. The range of the gestational age is unclear, however, given that vacuum curettage was performed we assume it was first trimester. The author could not successfully be contacted to clarify questions.
Crawford 1984 Pain is not an outcome measured
Edelist 1987 Pain with or after the procedure is not measured, but only pain as side effect of the anesthesia administration (meantioned in the discussion). Unclear if vacuum or sharp curettage. Author could not successfully be contacted to clarify questions.
Enlund 1996 Outcome of number of days of sick leave depending on anesthetic used leads to follow up of several days, which is beyond the scope of our review.
Eriksson 1995 Pain with or after the procedure is not measured, but only pain as side effect of the anesthesia administration and postoperative analgesia requirements. Unclear if vacuum or sharp curettage
Erkola 1990 The outcome studied is the treatment of anesthesia side effects. Unclear if the procedure was a dilation and curettage or a vacuum aspiration.
Hamar 1989 Pain related to the abortion was not reported.
Jakobbson 1990 Randomization by date of birth.
Kallela 1994 Pain related to the abortion was not reported. Only assessed need for postoperative analgesics and pain with injection of anesthetic. Author could not successfully be contacted to clarify questions.
Lichtenberg 2003 Pain related to the abortion was not reported.
Lowenstein 2006 Randomization by day of treatment.
Matambo 1999 only letter to editor.
Miller 1996 Not adequately allocated
Nielsen 1975 Not adequately randomized
Parkash 1979 Not randomized.
Peters 1978 Unclear if randomized. Author could not successfully be contacted.
Rawling 2001 Gestational age up to 14.5 weeks.
Sanders 1984 Pain related to the abortion was not reported.
Schoeffler 1987 Pain related to the abortion was not reported.
Verma 1985 Pain related to the abortion was not reported.
West 1985 Pain related to the abortion was not reported.
Wiebe 2005 Gestational age up to 16 weeks as per e‐mail clarification with the author.
Willdeck‐Lund 1975 Not randomized. Tried to contact the author, but he passed away.