Country |
Policy/Time period |
Motivation |
Setting of budget |
Physician incentives |
Physician disincentives |
Theoretical effects |
Taiwan |
Drug reimbursement rate reduction, starting in 2000 |
Reducing prescription costs |
|
Physicians earn a share of the revenue that hospitals gain from selling medicines |
Reducing reimbursement rate reduces physicians' tendency to overprescribe |
Fincianal incentives from drug sales affect physician prescribing. Removing this incentive will help to rationalise physician prescribing |
Taiwan |
National Health Insurance Drug Budget Programme, starting in 2002 |
Reducing prescription costs |
Global budget based on an individual expenditure cap |
|
Maximum expenditure cap |
|
UK |
Pay for performance (quality and outcome framework), starting in 2004 |
improving quality of care |
NHS committed 1.8 GBP for funding the programme |
Up to 25% increase in physician income (maximum of 31,000 GBP) |
|
Direct financial incentives may result in improved quality of care, including prescribing |
Sweden |
Fixed pharmaceutical budget, 2000 to 2003 |
Controlling prescription drug costs |
Previous year budget and demographic characteristics of patients |
Remaining pharmaceutical budget was given to the health centre and can be used as bonus payment |
Health centre had to repay any extra pharmaceutical expenditures |
Making the health centres 'residual claimants' (i.e. responsible for deficits or surpluses) will directly affect the physicians prescribing. This may happen via reducing the number of prescriptions, reducing DDD per prescription or selecting cheaper alternative pharmaceuticals |
Netherlands |
Behaviour‐independent financial incentive, 2000 to 2002 |
Controlling prescription drug costs |
|
On‐off bonus payment by the insurance company (paid before‐hand, irrespective of physician performance) |
The decision to follow the regional formulary was made democratically in the presence of physician representatives and opinion leaders |
Ownership of the decision via participation in development of the formulary and the decision to adopt the formulary via the insurance organisation is likely to improve physician performance towards the target behaviour |
Germany |
Collective drug budget "spending caps"
(Health Care Reform Act),
1993 to 2002
(formally abolished in 2001) |
Controlling prescription drug costs |
Based on previous regional spending. From 1998: regional net budget =
gross budget minus co‐payments and rebates from industry
nationally set in 1993, then regionally
Negotiated between physician associations and statutory health insurances |
None (savings will not be available to physicians) |
Regional physician associations are responsible for overspending (maximum 5% of total budget). Can decline to pay for excess spending and can request it from individual practice |
Reduction in drugs with disputed effect, savings can facilitate use of more expensive drugs, improve quality of prescribing or increase referrals to save (drug budget is independent of other care) |
Ireland |
IDTSS (Indicative Drug Target Savings Scheme),
starting in 1993 |
Controlling prescription drug costs |
Individual practice budget based on previous spending and national average
Negotiated by local medical advisor and practice |
Savings were divided between GP and health authority |
None |
Decrease in prescribed drug volume and cost per item; improvement in quality of prescribing |
UK |
Fund‐holding
in Great Britain and Scotland:
April/1991 to 1997
(announced in 1990)
in Wales and Northern Ireland 1993 to 1997 |
Controlling prescription drug costs |
Based on previous spending of practice adjusted for patient mix and spending of comparators
Negotiated by local health authority and practice |
Savings can be invested by each fund‐holder to improve services in other budgets, or in the year following the year's drug budget |
Responsible for overspending up to a limit of 5000£. Overspending can be covered by other budgets |
Decrease in prescribed drug volume and cost per item; improvement in quality of prescribing. Referrals are postponed, as these are also part of a budget |