Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 28;2020(7):CD011504. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011504.pub2

3. Summary of included studies.

Intervention category Intervention type Studies and study designs
Improve buying power Unconditional cash transfers 18 RCTs: Ahmed 2019a; Ahmed 2019b; Asfaw 2014; Baird 2013a; Brugh 2018; Daidone 2014; Fenn 2015; Fernald 2011; Gangopadhyay 2015; Haushofer 2013; Hjelm 2017; Hoddinott 2013; Merttens 2013; Miller 2011; Pellerano 2014; Schwab 2013; Skoufias 2013; Tonguet Papucci 2015
3 prospective controlled studies: Aguero 2006; Breisinger 2018; Renzaho 2017
Conditional cash transfers 9 RCTs: Baird 2013a; Evans 2014; Gertler 2000 (PROGRESA); Hidrobo 2014c; Kandpal 2016; Kurdi 2019; Kusuma 2017a; Macours 2012; Maluccio 2005
5 prospective controlled studies: Andersen 2015; Ferre 2014; Huerta 2006 (PROGRESA); Leroy 2008 (PROGRESA); Lopez Arana 2016
Income generationd 6 RCTs: Beegle 2017; Darrouzet Nardi 2016; Marquis 2018; Olney 2016; Osei 2017; Verbowski 2018
11 prospective controlled studies: Alaofe 2016; Alaofe 2019; Asadullah 2015; Doocy 2017; Jodlowski 2016; Kangmennaang 2017; Katz 2001; Kennedy 1989; Murshed E Jahan 2011; Porter 2016e; Weinhardt 2017
Food prices Food vouchers 4 RCTs: Fenn 2015b; Hidrobo 2014c; Jensen 2011; Ponce 2017
0 prospective controlled studies
Food rebates/subsidies 1 RCT: Chen 2019
3 prospective controlled study: Andaleeb 2016; Chakrabarti 2018; Sturm 2013
Infrastructure changes 0 identified
Social environment Village savings and loans 1 RCT: Kusuma 2017b
1 prospective controlled study: Brunie 2014

aBaird 2013 assesses both conditional and unconditional cash transfers.
bFenn 2015 assesses both unconditional cash transfers and food vouchers.
cHidrobo 2014 assesses both conditional cash transfers and food vouchers.
dThis includes different interventions that aimed to generate income of participants (e.g. integrated agricultural programmes, community development programmes).
ePorter 2016 assessed a public works (80%) (cash/food‐for‐work) or unconditional cash transfer government programme (20%). Results were reported for the entire population, not disaggregated according to intervention received.

RCT: randomised controlled trial.