Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 28;2020(7):CD011504. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011504.pub2
Study ID References to other relevant studies Correspondence required (yes or no, and why) Further study information requested Correspondence received (from whom, what, when) Information used in review
Neufeld 2013 Abstract, requested full text MV emailed author on 10 April 2018 Received email from Lynnette Neufeld <lneufeld@gainhealth.org> on 12 April 2018, who provided 2 full texts. Screened 2 full texts provided
Shamah‐Levy 2015 Abstract, requested full text MV emailed author on 10 April 2018 Received email from Elsa Berenice Gaona Pineda <berenicegp.insp@gmail.com> on 10 April 2018 with full text Screened 1 full text provided
Wood Abstract, requested full text MRC library requested dissertation requested on 12 April 2018 No response None
Kusuma 2016 Method of randomisation of village clusters not clear, data from nutrition and food security intervention comparisons required, treatment regimen of control group unclear AS emailed author about outcomes on 6 February 2018 (follow‐up on 13 February 2018 and 13 March 2018). Authors only nutrition outcomes is whether mothers took supplements therefore review excluded on the basis of no relevant outcomes No response from dkusuma@mail.harvard.edu None
Murshed E Jahan 2011 Baseline data MV emailed author on 22 March 2018 No response from 'k.jahan@cgiar.org'; d.pemsl@cgiar.org None
Skoufias 2013 Additional outcome data, requested study report MV emailed author on 8 June 2018 Received email from Emmanuel skoufias <eskoufias@worldbank.org on 8 June 2018 Need to screen 1 full text in Spanish
Asadullah 2015 nrs LTFU unclear and nrs of participants do not match between tables in paper; unclear units of measurement and measure of central tendency; data duplicated for two outcomes SD emailed author Mohammad N. Asadullah about nrs LTFU and participant numbers on 31 July 18; AB emailed author on two additional email addresses on 7 February 2019 to follow‐up SD queries and additional issues identified in outcome extraction. AB followed up on 18 February 19. Author responded on 6 March 19 from m.niaz@um.edu.my and endeavoured to provide further information None yet
Asfaw 2014 Mean monthly food consumption expenditure exceeds mean total monthly household consumption expenditure (defined as including all household expenses) AB emailed author Patrick Ward on 28 January 19 to determine whether mean household food consumption expenditure is not included in mean total monthly household expenditure and, if not the case, why this sub‐category exceeds the category total. AB followed up on 18 February 19. Author responded on 19 February 19 from patrick.ward@opml.co.uk and endeavoured to provide further information, requested from Aly Visram (co‐author; aly.visram@opml.co.uk) on 28 February 2019 None yet
Weinhardt 2017 yes. Information re clarification of outcome malnutrition in paper and what it means exactly SD emailed Weinhardt and Alice Yan about clarification of table 3 malnutrition outcome and whether there are separate results for stunting and wasting No response
Darrouzet‐Nardi 2016 yes. Information re correct data for HAZ in table 4 of Miller 2014 SD emailed both Darrouzet‐Nardi and Miller on 25 September 2019 re this issue No response
Seidenfeld 2013 Daidone 2014 yes. Effect measure and narrative description of result on food security scale discrepant. SD emailed 14 October 2019 Response on 18 December 2019, responding to query. Correct effect direction confirmed and used in the review
Nkonya 2019 Yes. AB emailed 1 April 2020 to clarify study design eligibility. Yes Study excluded
Hidrobo 2014 Yes MV emailed 29 April 2020. Request for number of participants analysed per group No response
Osei 2017 Yes MV emailed 30 April 2020. Request for number of participants analysed per group No response
Beegle 2017 Yes MV emailed 30 April 2020. Request for number of participants analysed per group Yes. Provided required information. Enabled meta‐analysis to be carried out