Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 31;224(1):35–53.e3. doi: 10.1016/j.ajog.2020.07.049

Supplemental Table.

Modified Newcastle-Ottawa scale for assessing quality of cohort or case series studies

Author Year Representativeness of exposed cohort Exposure assessment Outcome assessment Adequacy of length of time before follow-up Adequacy of follow-up of cohorts Methodological quality
Breslin, et al76 April 2020 High
Breslin, et al77 May 2020 High
Cao, et al59 April 2020 Low
Chen, et al10 February 2020 Moderate
Ferrazzi, et al78 April 2020 High
Hu, et al60 April 2020 Moderate
Khan, et al38 April 2020 Moderate
Liu, et al40 March 2020 Low
Nie, et al63 March 2020 Moderate
Penfield, et al79 May 2020 High
Patane, et al30 May 2020 High
Pierce-Williams, et al80 May 2020 Moderate
Qiancheng, et al64 April 2020 High
Yan, et al11 April 2020 Moderate
Yang, et al65 April 2020 High
Yin, et al66 April 2020 Moderate
Yu, et al56 March 2020 High
Zeng, et al26 March 2020 Low
Zeng, et al67 March 2020 High
Zhu, et al9 Feb 2020 Low
Lokken, et al81 May 2020 Low
London, et al82 May 2020 Moderate
Mulvey, et al83 April 2020 Low
Baergen, et al84 May 2020 Moderate
Buonsenso, et al49 May 2020 Moderate
Chen, et al68 April 2020 Low
Chen, et al69 March 2020 Moderate
Govind, et al86 May 2020 Moderate
Knight, et al12 May 2020 High
Liao, et al70 April 2020 High
Liu, et al71 May 2020 High
Pereira, et al87 May 2020 Moderate
Qadri, et al89 May 2020 Moderate
Wu, et al72 May 2020 High
Wu, et al73 April 2020 Low
Yang, et al74 April 2020 Low
Yang, et al75 May 2020 Moderate
Shanes, et al88 May 2020 Low
Vintzileos, et al90 April
2020
Moderate
Questions:
  • 1.
    Did the patients represent the whole cases of the medical center? Cases included represented the general population of COVID-19 pregnant women.
  • 2.
    Was the diagnosis correctly made? COVID-19 was diagnosed by viral PCR.
  • 3.
    Was the outcome correctly ascertained? Clear description of adequate methodology of testing for COVID-19 in fetus or neonate was provided.
  • 4.
    Was follow-up long enough for outcomes to occur? Adequate follow-up time was reported.
  • 5.
    Were all important data cited in the report? Testing was repeated at least 2 times on 2 separate occasions.
  • Methodological quality: high=5 stars, moderate=4 stars, low=3 or fewer stars.

Kotlyar. Vertical transmission of COVID-19: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2021.