Skip to main content
. 2020 Jun 27;94(8):2899–2923. doi: 10.1007/s00204-020-02784-5

Table 2.

Key hallmarks of NGTxC and representative international standardized tests, that can address these hallmarks

Block Key hallmarks /characteristics (Mechanism/ mode of action) IATA modules Readiness level/currently used in hazard assessmenta Selected examples of representative standardized (or commonly used) assays
1a Receptor binding and activation also as part of hormone-mediated processes MIE
Testing for receptor binding A: Adopted as OECD, EU and US EPA TG

Oestrogen Receptor (ER) Binding Assay OECD TG 493

US EPA 890.1250

Testing for receptor agonism/antagonism A: Adopted as OECD, EU and US EPA TG

Oestrogen receptor (ER) transactivation assays

OECD TG 455

US EPA 890.1300

A: Adopted as OECD TG Androgen receptor transactivation assay OECD TG 458
B: Undergoing ISO validation 2019-current Aryl hydrocarbon receptor (AhR) transactivation assay, US EPA METHOD 4435 (2008); JIS K 0463 (2009)(Aarts et al. 1995; Garrison et al. 1996; Han et al. 2004)
Alteration of hormone synthesis A: Adopted as OECD and US EPA TG

Steroidogenesis H295R Assay OECD TG 456

US EPA 890.1550

A: Adopted as US EPA OCSPP HTGb Aromatase US EPA 890.1200
1b CYP P450 induction MIE B: On OECD TGP workplan: validated, draft OECD TG under consideration HepRG® CYP induction test method (Bernasconi et al. 2019)
2 Cell proliferation

(Sustained) proliferation,

mitogenic signalling

No in vitro TGs, no in vitro assays on the OECD TGP workplan

Repeated Dose 90-Day Oral Toxicity Study in Rodents

OECD TG 408, US EPA 870.3100

A: Adopted as OECD and US EPA TG In vivo
Test methods currently used to contribute to regulatory WoE assessment

Cell proliferation in vivo (Ki-67) (Jouinot and Bertherat 2018) (Wood et al. 2015)

Hepatic DNA synthesis and cell proliferation (US FDA 2018; Wood et al. 2015)

Bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) assays in vivo

3 Cell transformation Change in morphology A: Adopted as OECD and US EPA TG

TG 408 US EPA 870.3100

90 day in vivo histopathological features

A: ICH guideline ICH S6 PART 1(ICH 2011a, b; Wang et al. 2010)
B: Validated assays not adopted as OECD TG; OECD GD (OECD 2015, 2017b) Bhas 42 Cell Transformation Assay (OECD 2017b)
Syrian Hamster Embryo (SHE) Cell Transformation Assay(OECD 2015)
BALB/c 3T3 Transformation Assay
4 Gap junction intercellular communication

Change in morphology,

mitogenic signalling

No TGs, no assays

on the OECD TGP workplan

5 Indicators of oxidative stress Inflammation, immune response, Cell injury B: Assays in (pre) validation and on the OECD TGP workplan Reactive Oxygen Species (ROS) generation assay (phototoxicity)
Toxtracker (Hendriks et al. 2012, 2016)
C: Test methods currently used to contribute to regulatory WoE assessment HepG2 peroxide formation
Malondialdehyde (MDA)—Thiobarbituric Acid Reactive Substances (TBARs) ex vivo assays
in vivo assays, ICH (ICH 2005a, b)
6

Immunosuppression/

evasion

Immune response A: ICH S8 (ICH 2005a, b) and OECD TGs (TG 443) NK cell/Host resistance and others
A: ICH S8(ICH 2005a, b) TDAR- immunosuppression tier 1 screening

A: TG 443(OECD 2018c)

US EPA, OPPTSc 870.7800 Immunotoxicity. (1996)

US EPA, OCSPP Test Guideline No. 870. 7800). (2013)

7 Gene expression and cell signalling pathways Inflammation, immune response, mitogenic signalling B: Assays in (pre) validation and on the OECD TGP workplan Toxtracker (Henriks et al. 2012, 2016)
8 Increased resistance to apoptotic cell death Cell injury A: OECD TG 408

Histopathology from TG 408 90 days studies

(standard picnotic nuclei)

Histopathology from single or repeated dose studies (eg TG 408 90 day studies):

Use of special stains on ex vivo Tissue slices

Hematoxilin/Eosin staining Fluoro-jade staining

Caspase 3/7 activation in vivo
DNA fragmentation
9 Pathogenic angiogenesis and neoangiogenesis Change in morphology No TGs, no assays on the OECD TGP workplan
10 Genetic Instability (Disturbed DNA repair, quick establishment of mutations = “mutator phenotype”) Change in morphology Cell injury No TGs, no assays on the OECD TGP workplan
11 Cellular senescence/ telomerase Change in morphology, Cell injury No TGs, no assays on the OECD TGP workplan
12 Metastasis (migration, intra- and extravasation), survival outside of original tissue Tumour No TGs, no assays on the OECD TGP workplan
13 Epigenetic mechanisms and associated genetic instability All No TGs, no assays on the OECD TGP workplan (Greally and Jacobs 2013) reviews how TGs could be augmented

aTG readiness levels A, B, C are described in the methodology section

bOCSPP HTG: US EPA Office of Chemical Safety and Pollution Prevention Harmonized Test Guidelines

cOPPTS: US EPA Office of Prevention, Pesticides and Toxic Substances