Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 23;2020:9074618. doi: 10.1155/2020/9074618

Table 3.

Summary of the quality and risk of bias assessment.

Included studies Risk of bias assessment Quality assessment∗∗ (total score)
Reporting External validity Internal Validity - Bias Internal validity - confusion and selection bias
Al Agili et al. (2004) [74] graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg 16
Damiance (2016) [83] graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i008.jpg 15
Schultz et al. (2001) [72] graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i008.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg 15
Pradhan et al. (2009) [78] graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg 15
Koneru and Sigal (2009) [76] graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg 14
Nelson et al. (2011) [77] graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg 14
Edwards et al. (2002) [73] graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i008.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg 12
Milnes et al. (1995) [71] graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg 12
De Jongh et al. (2008) [75] graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i008.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg 12
Rocha et al. (2015) [5] graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg 11
Cardoso et al. (2011) [80] graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i008.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg 10
Dantas Cardoso et al. (2015) [82] graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg 10
Burtner et al. (1990) [70] graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i008.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg 9
Paulo et al. (2017) [84] graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i008.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg 9
Bindal et al. (2015) [81] graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i008.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg 8
Aragão et al. (2011) [79] graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i001.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg graphic file with name IJD2020-9074618.tab3.i016.jpg 8

Inline graphic, low risk; Inline graphic, unclear risk; Inline graphic, high risk. Adapted from Cochrane Collaboration. ∗∗Adapted from Downs and Black, scores from zero to 17 (higher scores indicate higher quality).