Table 1.
Human Relevant Myocyte Models for In Vitro Studies
Construct | Composition and Description | Advantages | Disadvantages |
---|---|---|---|
Single hiPSC-CMs | May be micropatterned to form rectangles resembling adult myocytes | Amenable to electrophysiological studies using patch-clamp approaches | No intercalated disk or gap junctions No syncytium function Shape does not equal maturation Single-cell isolation from sheets may cause injury |
2D layers | Cardiomyocytes grown in plates or wells in culture Thin film/layers or sheet constructs possible |
Ease of preparation Amenable to HTS for electrophysiological, Ca flux, syncytial functions, measures of impulse propagation, fibrillation arrhythmias Cells can be matured by media, patterning extracellular matrix manipulation |
Lacks influence of other cardiac cell types and 3D environment of native tissue Variable morphology and sarcomere alignment elicit strain patterns different from native myocytes |
2D cocultures | hiPSC-CMs mixed with fibroblasts, vascular cells, mesenchymal stem cells, native adult cardiomyocytes | Mimics heterogeneous cellular composition of native heart Study cell-cell interactions, integrate hiPSC- CMs with noncontractile cells Promotion of hiPSC-CM maturation |
Optimum proportions of cell types uncertain Proliferative cells may affect preparation stability and reproducibility Nonmyocyte-to-myocyte coupling may differ from normal tissues |
3D organoids | hiPSCs cocultured with fibroblasts/endothelial cells with self-assembly | Mimic 3D cardiac environment Heterogeneous cell types may resemble native heart composition |
Spatial arrangements of elements uncertain Difficult to assess electrophysiology and contractility effects with multielectrode arrays and force measures |
Engineered human tissues | hiPSC-CMs with/without fibroblasts, endothelial cells | Ability to directly measure contractile force, transmembrane potentials Pacing controls rate More natural alignment of cells/sarcomeres Enhanced myocyte maturation |
Initial high myocyte requirements and costs being reduced by miniaturization Lack of vasculature for thicker preparations may create diffusion barrier, anoxic core Low to moderate throughput |
3D macroscopic constructs | Ventricular pouches Potential mini-ventricles | Direct pressure measurements possible May promote myocyte maturation | Technically demanding, high cell quantities needed Limited to a few laboratories; low throughput; cost prohibitive |
A summary of different hiPSC-CM–derived models used to evaluate various cardiotoxicities. Models have been arranged in order of increasing complexity. In general, the protocols and composition of more complex structures increase the level of phenotypic maturity while challenging reproducibility and assay throughput.
2D indicates 2-dimensional; 3D, 3-dimensional; hiPSC, human induced pluripotent stem cell; hiPSC-CM, human induced pluripotent stem cell–derived cardiomyocyte; and HTS, high-throughput screening.