Table 1.
References, country of origin | Characteristics of the sample | Tests used | Results |
---|---|---|---|
Koene, (17), The Netherlands | 35 children Inclusion criteria for MD: mutation in a mitochondrial (17) or in a nuclear (13) gene. 5 children with suspected depression were analyzed Age range: 2–18 years old, mean: 8.7 years old |
Depression diagnosis (DSM-IV criteria) or HDRS for children older than 14 years old and/or Zung depression scale Holmes and Rahe Social Readjustment Rating Scale (Life Stress Event Scale) |
Major depression (n=5; 14.3%) Psychotic symptoms (n=1; 2.9%) Life stress event score: increased susceptibility (>50%) in 3 patients. |
Verity, (18), UK | 2,493 children with PIND 112 (4, 5) children with MD Inclusion criteria for MD diagnosis: 112 suspected MD in the group of patients with PIND by a group of experts. Lactate levels increased in the blood and or CSF (n=87); muscle biopsy (n=75) and measures of mitochondrial respiratory chain enzymes: in 31 of these the result was diagnostic; DNA studies (n=50) yielded a specific diagnosis in 35; brain MRI (n=78) Age range: birth–14 years 7 months; median: 12 months 15 Leigh syndrome, 5 MELAS, 24 nonspecific, 68 other |
No tests used Data were obtained from medical clinical observations |
Developmental delay (n=43; 38.4%) Cognitive decline (n=1; 0.9%) Psychiatric symptoms: Autistic spectrum (n=3; 2.7%) Behavioral difficulties (n=1; 0.9%) |
Morava, (19), The Netherlands | 18 children who exhibit no developmental delays (individuals with IQ<70 were excluded) Inclusion criteria for MD: A clinical and biochemical diagnosis of OXPHOS disease for more than 1 year; muscle disease with developmental delay and variable systemic involvement. Control group: 18 children with inborn errors of metabolism 19 children with Sotos syndrome (a Mendelian disorder with non-progressive ID) |
WISC (version not provided) CBCL -Anxious/depressed (1–18 years old), - Withdrawn/depressed (only in CBCL 6–18 years old) - Affective disorders (6–18 years old)/affective problems (1–5 years old). Comparison to American norms (sub-scale score of <65 is normal, 65–69 scores are borderline, and scores of >70 indicate a clinical problem) |
Depressive behavior (n=7; 38.9%) CBCL, in the MD group: Compared to norms: Higher rate of withdrawn and depressive behavior (p = 0.0001) Higher levels of depressive behavior (p = 0.017) Compared to inborn errors of metabolism group: Anxious, depressive behavior in MD disorder: ns Withdrawn depressed behavior increased (p = 0.002) in the MD group Anxious depressive behavior: ns Compared to Sotos syndrome group: Withdrawn depressive behavior significantly higher in patients diagnosed with MD Anxious depressive behavior: ns |
Schreiber, (20), USA | 14 children were included Inclusion criteria for MD: selection via a website then parental questionnaire about how the MD was diagnosed (i.e. mutations identified or strongly suspected through muscle biopsy and/or blood test, in addition to clinical symptoms). Unspecified MD (n=5) Age range of children: not provided 7 male and 7 female adolescents/young adults. 5 of the subjects were between the ages of 19 and 21 |
BASC-2, for ages 12 to 21 years old BRIEF for older children/adolescents aged 13 to 18 years old or adult report for patients older than 18 years |
Attitude to school associated with depression (p < 0.001), anxiety (P < 0.01), and internalizing problems (P < 0.01). Students mothers rated somatization more than a standard deviation above the mean (self-report: mean ¼ 62.21, SE ¼ 3.32; parent report: mean ¼ 78.86, SE ¼ 2.97). BRIEF results were not analyzed because of the age heterogeneity in the cohort |
Eom, (21), South Korea | 70 children Age at diagnosis: mean: 1.78 ± 2.52 years old Inclusion criteria for MD: biochemical enzyme assay of muscle tissues and modified mitochondrial diseases criteria (MDC) Inclusion criteria for nonspecific MD: no classical clinical symptoms, biochemical results, or mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) deletions/duplications/point mutations that conform to known and established mitochondrial syndromes. 16 Leigh syndrome, 3 MELAS, 51 nonspecific |
BSID-II WPPSI (Korean version) WISC-III (Korean version) Children’s adaptive Function: Social Maturity Scale (Korean version); Parent responses for 99-item CBCL (Korean version) for children 1.5–5 years of age or 118-item CBCL for children and adolescents 6–18 years of age Parental assessment (PSI; BDI for mothers) |
Development (n=41): mental development = 52.9 ± 11.3 (=significant level of delay); psychomotor development = 52.1 ± 10.5 (=significant level of delay) IQ (n=15): FSIQ = 64.6 ± 21.8 (=mild levels of intellectual disability); VIQ=70.5 ± 19.2 (=mild levels of intellectual disability); PIQ = 58.6 ± 16.9 (=mild to moderate levels of impairment) Daily living function (n=54); social quotient = 50.2 ± 31.3 (significant impairments in adaptive function) Behavioral difficulties (n=28): CBCL = 62.9 ± 17.1; 43% above the cutoff; internalizing problems = 32%; externalizing problems = 25%; withdrawn = 46%; somatization = 11%; anxiety/depression = 29%; social problems 55%; cognitive problems = 20%; attention problems = 41%; delinquent behavior = 0%; aggressive behavior = 15%; emotional response = 31%; sleep problems = 38%; other problems = 20% PSI (n=32) = 88.6 ± 9.4; 75% above the cutoff BDI (n=26) = 14.6 ± 9.1; 65% above the cutoff |
Eom, (22), South Korea | 53 children Inclusion criteria for MD: biochemical enzyme assay of muscle tissue samples and meeting the modified MDC 11 Leigh syndrome, 2 MELAS, 40 nonspecific Age at diagnosis: mean: 3.12 ± 2.49 years old; lead time to diagnosis: 1.09 ± 1.15 years old (range, 0.6–1.46 years old) |
KICDT DQ = (developmental age/chronological age) × 100] First visit prior to diagnosis, second visit prior to diagnosis, one-time diagnostic evaluation, and six post-diagnostic developmental evaluations |
Pre-diagnosis evaluation (n=18): DQ = 60.4 ± 34.4 Diagnosis (n=37): DQ = 31.9 ± 25.8 Post-diagnosis (1 year after) (n=19): DQ = 27.8 ± 23.3 |
Shurtleff, (23), USA | 49 children Age range: 61–250 months old Inclusion criteria for MD: biochemical testing, muscle biopsy with electron transport chain enzyme assay, and/or gene sequencing of mtDNA or nuclear genes involved in mitochondrial disease. When available, molecular genetic testing that confirmed pathological variants in either nuclear or mtDNA-encoded genes were obtained from Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments (CLIA) approved laboratories. All patients met clinical criteria of modified Walker criteria for diagnosing mitochondrial disease |
WPPSI-III: 2½ to 7 years old WISC-III or -IV: 6 to 16 years old WAIS-III or -IV: 16 years of age and older FSIQ, VIQ, PIQ WMI or FFD PSI Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, 2nd Edition |
WISC-III or –IV (n=40) Vineland (n=9) = 85 [interquartile range (IQR): 50, 102] Group without seizures: FSIQ=100 (IQR: 86, 109), PIQ =100 (IQR 94, 112) Group with seizures: FSIQ = 67 (IQR: 49.5, 89), PIQ = 63 (IQR 54, 84) Statistical and clinical difference (Δ=33; 95% CI: 9, 52). Adaptive function measure = 43 (IQR: 37, 50) (patients with intractable epilepsy only) |
Acronyms used: BASC, Self-report and parent report Behavior Assessment for Children; BDI, Beck Depression Inventory; BRIEF, Behavior Rating Inventory of Executive Function self-report and parent report; BSID, Bayley Scales of Infant Development; CBCL, Child Behavior Check List; CSF, cerebrospinal fluid; DQ, developmental quotient; FFD, Freedom From Distractibility Index; IQ, intelligence quotient; FSIQ, Full Score Intelligence Quotient; HDRS, Hamilton Depression Rating Scale; ID, intellectual disability; KICDT, Korean Infant and Child Development Test; MD, mitochondrial disorders; MDC, Mitochondrial Disease Criteria; MELAS, mitochodrial encephalopathy and lactate acidosis syndrome; OXPHOS, disorders of oxidative phosphorylation; PIQ, performance intelligence; PIND, progressive intellectual and neurologic deterioration; PSI, Processing Speed Index; VIQ, verbal intelligence; WAIS, Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale; WISC, Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children; WMI, Working Memory Index; WPPSI, Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence.