Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 28;11:747. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2020.00747

Table 1.

Main results of the studies included in the literature review.

References, country of origin Characteristics of the sample Tests used Results
Koene, (17), The Netherlands 35 children
Inclusion criteria for MD: mutation in a mitochondrial (17) or in a nuclear (13) gene.
5 children with suspected depression were analyzed
Age range: 2–18 years old, mean: 8.7 years old
Depression diagnosis (DSM-IV criteria) or HDRS for children older than 14 years old and/or Zung depression scale
Holmes and Rahe Social Readjustment Rating Scale (Life Stress Event Scale)
Major depression (n=5; 14.3%)
Psychotic symptoms (n=1; 2.9%)
Life stress event score: increased susceptibility (>50%) in 3 patients.
Verity, (18), UK 2,493 children with PIND
112 (4, 5) children with MD
Inclusion criteria for MD diagnosis: 112 suspected MD in the group of patients with PIND by a group of experts. Lactate levels increased in the blood and or CSF (n=87); muscle biopsy (n=75) and measures of mitochondrial respiratory chain enzymes: in 31 of these the result was diagnostic; DNA studies (n=50) yielded a specific diagnosis in 35; brain MRI (n=78)
Age range: birth–14 years 7 months; median: 12 months
15 Leigh syndrome, 5 MELAS, 24 nonspecific, 68 other
No tests used
Data were obtained from medical clinical observations
Developmental delay (n=43; 38.4%)
Cognitive decline (n=1; 0.9%)
Psychiatric symptoms:
Autistic spectrum (n=3; 2.7%)
Behavioral difficulties (n=1; 0.9%)
Morava, (19), The Netherlands 18 children who exhibit no developmental delays (individuals with IQ<70 were excluded)
Inclusion criteria for MD:
A clinical and biochemical diagnosis of OXPHOS disease for more than 1 year; muscle disease with developmental delay and variable systemic involvement.
Control group:
18 children with inborn errors of metabolism
19 children with Sotos syndrome (a Mendelian disorder with non-progressive ID)
WISC (version not provided)
CBCL
-Anxious/depressed (1–18 years old),
- Withdrawn/depressed (only in CBCL 6–18 years old)
- Affective disorders (6–18 years old)/affective problems (1–5 years old).
Comparison to American norms (sub-scale score of <65 is normal, 65–69 scores are borderline, and scores of >70 indicate a clinical problem)
Depressive behavior (n=7; 38.9%)
CBCL, in the MD group:
Compared to norms:
Higher rate of withdrawn and depressive behavior (p = 0.0001)
Higher levels of depressive behavior (p = 0.017)
Compared to inborn errors of metabolism group:
Anxious, depressive behavior in MD disorder: ns
Withdrawn depressed behavior increased (p = 0.002) in the MD group
Anxious depressive behavior: ns
Compared to Sotos syndrome group:
Withdrawn depressive behavior significantly higher in patients diagnosed with MD
Anxious depressive behavior: ns
Schreiber, (20), USA 14 children were included
Inclusion criteria for MD: selection via a website then parental questionnaire about how the MD was diagnosed (i.e. mutations identified or strongly suspected through muscle biopsy and/or blood test, in addition to clinical symptoms). Unspecified MD (n=5)
Age range of children: not provided
7 male and 7 female adolescents/young adults. 5 of the subjects were between the ages of 19 and 21
BASC-2, for ages 12 to 21 years old
BRIEF for older children/adolescents aged 13 to 18 years old or adult report for patients older than 18 years
Attitude to school associated with depression (p < 0.001), anxiety (P < 0.01), and internalizing problems (P < 0.01).
Students mothers rated somatization more than a standard deviation above the mean (self-report: mean ¼ 62.21, SE ¼ 3.32; parent report: mean ¼ 78.86, SE ¼ 2.97).
BRIEF results were not analyzed because of the age heterogeneity in the cohort
Eom, (21), South Korea 70 children
Age at diagnosis: mean: 1.78 ± 2.52 years old
Inclusion criteria for MD:
biochemical enzyme assay of muscle tissues
and modified mitochondrial
diseases criteria (MDC)
Inclusion criteria for nonspecific MD: no classical clinical symptoms, biochemical results, or mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) deletions/duplications/point mutations that conform to known and established mitochondrial syndromes.
16 Leigh syndrome, 3 MELAS, 51 nonspecific
BSID-II
WPPSI (Korean version)
WISC-III (Korean version)
Children’s adaptive
Function: Social Maturity Scale (Korean version); Parent responses for 99-item CBCL (Korean version) for children 1.5–5 years of age or 118-item CBCL for children and adolescents 6–18 years of age
Parental assessment (PSI; BDI for mothers)
Development (n=41): mental development = 52.9 ± 11.3 (=significant level of delay); psychomotor development = 52.1 ± 10.5 (=significant level of delay)
IQ (n=15): FSIQ = 64.6 ± 21.8 (=mild levels of intellectual disability); VIQ=70.5 ± 19.2 (=mild levels of intellectual disability); PIQ = 58.6 ± 16.9 (=mild to moderate levels of impairment)
Daily living function (n=54); social quotient = 50.2 ± 31.3 (significant impairments in adaptive function)
Behavioral difficulties (n=28): CBCL = 62.9 ± 17.1; 43% above the cutoff; internalizing problems = 32%; externalizing problems = 25%; withdrawn = 46%; somatization = 11%; anxiety/depression = 29%; social problems 55%; cognitive problems = 20%; attention problems = 41%; delinquent behavior = 0%; aggressive behavior = 15%; emotional response = 31%; sleep problems = 38%; other problems = 20%
PSI (n=32) = 88.6 ± 9.4; 75% above the cutoff
BDI (n=26) = 14.6 ± 9.1; 65% above the cutoff
Eom, (22), South Korea 53 children
Inclusion criteria for MD: biochemical enzyme assay of muscle tissue samples and meeting the modified MDC
11 Leigh syndrome, 2 MELAS, 40 nonspecific
Age at diagnosis: mean: 3.12 ± 2.49 years old; lead time to diagnosis: 1.09 ± 1.15 years old (range, 0.6–1.46 years old)
KICDT
DQ = (developmental age/chronological age) × 100]
First visit prior to diagnosis, second visit prior to diagnosis, one-time diagnostic evaluation, and six post-diagnostic developmental evaluations
Pre-diagnosis evaluation (n=18): DQ = 60.4 ± 34.4
Diagnosis (n=37): DQ = 31.9 ± 25.8
Post-diagnosis (1 year after) (n=19): DQ = 27.8 ± 23.3
Shurtleff, (23), USA 49 children
Age range: 61–250 months old
Inclusion criteria for MD: biochemical testing, muscle biopsy with electron transport chain enzyme assay, and/or gene sequencing of mtDNA or nuclear genes involved in mitochondrial disease. When available, molecular genetic testing that confirmed pathological variants in either nuclear or mtDNA-encoded genes were obtained from Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments (CLIA) approved laboratories. All patients met clinical criteria of modified Walker criteria for diagnosing mitochondrial disease
WPPSI-III: 2½ to 7 years old
WISC-III or -IV: 6 to 16 years old
WAIS-III or -IV: 16 years of age and older
FSIQ, VIQ, PIQ
WMI or FFD
PSI
Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, 2nd Edition
WISC-III or –IV (n=40) Vineland (n=9) = 85 [interquartile range (IQR): 50, 102]
Group without seizures: FSIQ=100 (IQR: 86, 109), PIQ =100 (IQR 94, 112)
Group with seizures: FSIQ = 67 (IQR: 49.5, 89), PIQ = 63 (IQR 54, 84)
Statistical and clinical difference (Δ=33; 95% CI: 9, 52).
Adaptive function measure = 43 (IQR: 37, 50) (patients with intractable epilepsy only)

Acronyms used: BASC, Self-report and parent report Behavior Assessment for Children; BDI, Beck Depression Inventory; BRIEF, Behavior Rating Inventory of Executive Function self-report and parent report; BSID, Bayley Scales of Infant Development; CBCL, Child Behavior Check List; CSF, cerebrospinal fluid; DQ, developmental quotient; FFD, Freedom From Distractibility Index; IQ, intelligence quotient; FSIQ, Full Score Intelligence Quotient; HDRS, Hamilton Depression Rating Scale; ID, intellectual disability; KICDT, Korean Infant and Child Development Test; MD, mitochondrial disorders; MDC, Mitochondrial Disease Criteria; MELAS, mitochodrial encephalopathy and lactate acidosis syndrome; OXPHOS, disorders of oxidative phosphorylation; PIQ, performance intelligence; PIND, progressive intellectual and neurologic deterioration; PSI, Processing Speed Index; VIQ, verbal intelligence; WAIS, Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale; WISC, Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children; WMI, Working Memory Index; WPPSI, Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence.