Table 5.
Study Details | UPF Exposure | Outcomes | Results | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Publication Author(s) Year |
Study Type (Year) Setting | Population (Number) |
Extraction Level | Relative exposure [UPF Reference Year] |
Data Collection Method | Health Outcome (Study Definition) | Data Collection Method | Key Findings |
Gastrointestinal Disease | ||||||||
Schnabel 2018 [85] |
Cross-sectional (2013) France |
Age ≥ 18 years (mean 50.4) (n = 33,343) |
Individual | UPF % total grams (quartiles) [NOVA.2018] [30] | 3 × 24-h records | Functional gastrointestinal disorders (Rome III criteria) | Self-report * | UPF contributed to 16% of total food intake by weight; 33.0% by total E intake. Individuals in the highest quartile of UPF intake had significantly higher risk of IBS (OR = 1.25; 95% CI 1.12; 1.39) and FDy (OR = 1.25; CI 95% 1.05; 1.47) but not FDy alone, compared with those in the lowest quartile. |
Vasseur 2020 [88] | Prospective cohort (2016) 2.3 years mean follow-up France | Adults ≥ 18 years (mean 43.3) (n = 105,832) |
Individual | UPF % total grams (tertiles) [NOVA.2018] [30] |
3 × 24 h records | Inflammatory bowel disease | Self-report ** | UPF contributed 17% food intake by weight in grams. No significant association was found with UPF consumption and IBD (p = 0.03). |
Depression | ||||||||
Adjibade 2019 [89] | Prospective Cohort (2012), 5.4 years mean follow-up France | Adults age 18–86 years (n= 26,730) |
Individual | UPF % total grams (quartiles) [NOVA.2018] [30] | 3 × 24 h records | Depression (CES-D scale) | Self-report * | UPF contributed 5% by weight in grams and 32% E intake. Individuals in the highest quartile of UPF intake had significantly higher risk of developing depressive symptoms (HR = 1.30; 95% CI 1.15–1.47) than those in the lowest quartile. Each 10% increase in UPF consumption was HR of 1.21 (95% CI, 1.15–1.27). |
Gomez-Donoso, 2019 [90] | Prospective cohort (2016), 10.3 years median follow-up Spain |
Adults (mean 36.7 years) (n = 14,907) |
Individual | UPF energy adjusted kcal/day (quartiles) [NOVA.2016] [22] | 136–item FFQ | Depression | Self-report ** | Individuals in highest quartile UPF had significantly higher risk of depression (HR = 1.33; 95% CI 1.07–1.64); p trend = 0.004), than individuals in lowest quartile of consumption, after confounder adjustment. |
Frailty | ||||||||
Sandoval-Insausti 2019 [93] |
Prospective Cohort (2008–2010), 3.5 years median follow-up Spain |
Adults ≥ 60 years (N = 1822) | Individual | UPF intake % total E (quartiles) [NOVA2018] [30] |
Validated interview computerized diet history | Frailty (Fried’s criteria) | Trained personnel | UPF contributed mean of 19.3% total E intake. Individuals in the highest quartile of UPF intake had higher risk of frailty (OR = 3.67; 95% CI 2.00, 6.76) than those in the lowest quartile of intake. |
Asthma (children and adolescents) | ||||||||
Melo et al. 2018 [80] |
Cross-sectional (2012) Brazil | Grade 9 students (n = 109,104) |
Individual | UPF score, intake per week (quintiles) [NOVA 2018] [30] | 6-UPF sub-categories FFQ | Asthma, wheezing in past 12 months | Self-report * | Individuals in the highest quintile of the UPF intake score had higher odds of having asthma (OR = 1.27; 95% CI 1.15, 1.41) or wheezing (OR = 1.42; 95% CI 1.35 to 1.50), than those in the lowest quintile. |
Azeredo 2020 [82] |
Prospective Cohort (2004–2010) Brazil | Children mean age 6.8 years baseline; 11.0 years at follow-up (n = 2190) | Individual | UPF % total E intake (quintiles) [NOVA.2018] [30] | 55 (age 6) and 88 items (age 11) FFQ. | Wheezing, whistling or asthma in past 12 months | Self-report * | UPF contribution to total E intake was 42.3% at 6 years, and 33.7% at 11 years. Consumption of UPF at age 6 was not significantly associated with wheeze, asthma or severe asthma at age 11. |
Results are presented for adjusted associations for potential confounders and statistically significant associations. NOVA refers to the food classification system [21] or earlier versions, as referenced; food means foods and beverages; * self-report from questionnaire on condition, medical history, symptoms, medication use, and/or diagnosis by medical practitioner; ** questionnaire plus validation on sample laboratory test or interview; UPF: ultra-process food (includes food and beverages); E: energy in calories or kilojoules; OR: odds ratio; CI: confidence interval; IBS: irritable bowel syndrome; FDy: functional dyspepsia; IBD: inflammatory bowel disease; CES-D scale: Centre for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale; HR: hazards ratio; FFQ: food frequency questionnaire; HR: hazards ratio.