Table 2.
Study (Year) | Participants | Diet (g/kg/day) | Duration of Follow Up | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|
Rosman (1984) [35,36]. | 247 CKD 3–5 pts | 0.90–0.95 vs. 0.70–0.80 vs. unrestricted | 4 yrs | Significant CKD slowing in LPD in male pts. |
Ihle (1989) [37] | 72 CKD 4–5 pts | LPD (0.6) vs. higher DPI (0.8) | 18 mo | Loss of GFR in control vs. LPD (p < 0.05). Wt loss |
Lindenau (1990) [38] | 40 CKD 5 pts | LPD vs. sVLPD (0.4) w KA | 12 mo | Decreased phos. with sVLPD and improved bone health |
Williams (1991) [39] | 95 CKD 4–5 | LPD (0.7) vs. 1.02–1.14 | 18 mo | No differences, minor Wt loss |
Locatelli (1991) [40] | 456 CKD 3–4 | 0.78 vs. 0.9 | 2 yrs | Trend for difference in renal outcomes (p = 0.059). |
MDRD Klahr (1994) [41] | 585 CKD 3–4 | 1.3 vs. 0.6 | 27 mo | No difference in GFR decline at 3 years. |
Montes-Delgado (1998) [42] | 33 CKD 3–5 | LPD vs. sLPD | 6 mo | Slower eGFR decline with supplements |
Malvy (1999) [43] | 50 CKD 4–5 | sVLPD (0.3) KA vs. LPD (0.65) | 3 yrs | Decreased SUN lean body mass and fat in sVLPD |
Teplan (2001) [44] | 105 CKD 3b–4 | LPD w vs. w/o KA | 3 yrs | Slower CKD progression |
Prakash (2004) [45] | 34 CKD 3b–4 | 0.6 vs. 0.3 w KA | 9 mo | Faster decline in LPD |
Brunori (2007) [46] | 56 > 70 yrs old CKD 5 | sVLPD (0.30) w KA vs. dialysis | 27 mo | Similar survival but more hospitalizations in dialysis |
Mircescu (2007) [47] | 53 CKD 4–5 | sVLPD (0.3) vegan w KA vs. LPD | 48 wks | Less dialysis initiation in sVLDP |
Cianciaruso (2008) [48] | 423 CKD 4–5 | 0.55 vs. 0.80 | 18 mo | Reduced urinary urea, Na, phos |
Di Iorio (2009) [49] | 32 CKD w proteinuria | VLPD vs. LPD | 6 mo | 58% greater reduction in proteinuria |
Jiang (2009 and 2011) [50,51]. | 60 PD w RKF | LPD vs. sLPD w KA vs. HPD | 12 mo | RKF decreased in the LPD and HPD. |
Garneata (2016) [52] | 207 CKD 4–5 | LPD (0.6) vs. sVLPD w KA | 15 mo | Less dialysis initiation |
Abbreviations: Pts.: patients, yrs: years, mo: months, Et: weight, phos.: phosphorus, sVLPD: supplemented very low protein diet.