Skip to main content
. 2020 Jun 29;12(7):1729. doi: 10.3390/cancers12071729

Table 1.

Clinical presentation: resectable.

Guideline/Year International/National (State) Main Option Alternative
NCCN 2020 [3] International
  • Surgery + Adjuvant Therapy

  • “Adjuvant Therapy“ includes

  • Clinical Trial (preferred option);

  • CT Alone;

  • CT → RTCT ± CT

  • Preferred CT Regimens: FOLFIRINOX or mFOLFIRINOX;

  • Alternative Adjuvant CT Regimens: Gemcitabine + albumin-bound paclitaxel

  • Neoadjuvant Therapy for High Risk

(includes imaging findings, very highly elevated CA 19-9, large primary tumors, large regional lymph nodes, excessive weight loss, and extreme pain)
ESMO 2015 [21,41] International
  • Surgery + Adjuvant CT

  • CT Regimens: i) gemcitabine or ii) 5-FU folinic acid

  • Note: No RTCT should be given except in clinical trials

-
PDQ® 2020 [32] International
  • Surgery + Adjuvant CT (6 mos)

  • Preferred CT Regimens: FOLFIRINOX

  • Alternative Adjuvant CT Regimens: “Gemcitabine”

  • Alternative Adjuvant CT Regimens: “5Fu”

  • Alternative Adjuvant CT Regimens: “S1 in Asia”

  • Surgery + Adjuvant CT ± RTCT (“controversial”)

  • Neoadjuvant CT ± RT (“under evaluation”)

ASCO Khoarana 2019 [29] International
  • Surgery (“recommended”) + 6-mth adjuvant CT (for: good PS; non extrapancreatic disease; no radiographic interface between primary tumor and mesenteric vasculature; Ca19.9 suggestive of potentially curable disease)

  • Preferred Adjuvant CT Regimens: mFOLFIRINOX

  • 6 mos of Neoadjuvant Therapy + Surgery (selected cases)

  • Alternative Adjuvant CT Regimens: doublet therapy with gemcitabine and capecitabine or monotherapy with gemcitabine alone or fluorouracil plus folinic acid alone

  • Adjuvant RTCT after 4–6 mos of adjuvant CT (for R1 and/or N+ patients who have not received Neoadjuvant Therapy

  • Neoadjuvant Therapy (for good PS; non extrapancreatic disease; no radiographic interface between primary tumor and mesenteric vasculature; and Ca19.9 suggestive of potentially curable disease)

ASTRO 2019
[31]
International
  • Adjuvant CT alone following R0 resection for pN0

  • Adjuvant RTCT following R0 resection for pN+ should be discussed

  • Surgery + Adjuvant RTCT for high-risk (R1-R2; pN+) patients is conditionally recommended (4–6 mos after CT)

  • Surgery + Adjuvant SBRT: only in clinical Trials

  • Neoadjuvant therapy is conditionally recommended

Hidalgo 2017 [33] National (Spain)
  • Surgery + Adjuvant CT (for patients R0/R1; PT1-4/N0-1M0; ECOG PS 0–1; and proper nutritional status)

  • “Adjuvant RT” (for R+ and/or N+ patients who did not received preoperatively)

  • Neoadjuvant Therapy only in Clinical Trials

Neuzillet 2018 [34] National (French)
  • Surgery + Adjuvant CT (6 mos; “for all patients”)

  • Preferred Adjuvant CT Regimens: mFOLFIRINOX

  • Alternative Adjuvant CT Regimens: Gemcitabine

  • Alternative Adjuvant CT Regimens: 5-Fu

  • Alternative Adjuvant CT Regimens: Gemcitabine+Capecitabine

  • Adjuvant RTCT is not recommended even in the case of R1 resection (only clinical trials)

  • Neoadjuvant therapy in Clinical trials

O’Reilly 2018 [35] National
(UK)
  • Surgery + Adjuvant CT

  • Preferred Adjuvant CT Regimens: gemcitabine plus capecitabine

  • Alternative Adjuvant CT Regimens: Gemcitabine

  • Unable to make recommendations about adjuvant RTCT

  • Neoadjuvant therapy only in clinical trials

Seufferlein 2014 -
(S3 Guideline) [36]
National (German)
  • Surgery + Adjuvant CT (6 mos; also for R0/R1 resection)

  • Preferred Adjuvant CT Regimens: gemcitabine or 5-fluorouracil (5-FU)

  • Adjuvant RTCT only in randomized controlled trials

  • “Neoadjuvant RT, RTCT or CT only in randomized controlled trials

Yamaguchi 2017 [37] National (Japan)
  • Surgery + Adjuvant CT

  • Preferred Adjuvant CT Regimens: “S-1 monotherapy”

  • Alternative Adjuvant CT Regimens: gemcitabine hydrochloride monotherapy

  • Adjuvant RTCT is not recommended

  • IORT is not recommended

  • Neoadjuvant therapy (“CT or RTCT”) only in clinical trials

AIOM 2019 [39] National (Italian)
  • Surgery + Adjuvant CT; (also for R0/R1 resection)

  • Preferred Adjuvant CT Regimens: “FOLFIRINOX”

  • Alternative Adjuvant CT Regimens: “Gemcitabine+Capecitabine”; for R0/R1 resection

  • Alternative Adjuvant CT Regimens: “Gemcitabine” for 6 mos; for R0/R1 resection

  • Alternative Adjuvant CT Regimens: “5FU/Leucovorin” for 6 mos; for R0/R1 resection

  • Surgery + Adjuvant CT (“Capecitabine” for 6 mos → RTCT; for selected patients)

  • Neoadjuvant CT→Surgery →Postoperative CT (3+3 mos)

Hyde 2019 [38] National (Eastern Canada)
Consensus Conference
  • Surgery + Adjuvant CT (6 mos; “for all stages”)

  • Preferred Adjuvant CT Regimens: “mFOLFIRINOX”

  • Alternative Adjuvant CT Regimens: “Gemcitabine-Capecitabine” (6 mos; “for all stages”)

  • Alternative Adjuvant CT Regimens: “Gemcitabine” (6 mos; “for all stages”)

  • Neoadjuvant CT (under investigation; to be considered)

  • Neoadjuvant RT (under investigation; to be considered)

  • “Superiority of preoperative RTCT over preoperative CT has not been unequivocally demonstrated”

  • “RT could be considered in high-risk disease”

Legend: CT: Chemotherapy; RTCT: Radiochemotherapy; RT: Radiotherapy; SBRT: sterotactic RT; IORT: Intraoperative RT; BRT: Brachitherapy; GTV: Gross Tumor Volume; CTV: Clinical Target Volume; GEM: Gemcitabine; 5-Fu: 5_Fluoruracil; Lnf: lymph-nodes; mo: months; R0: Microsopically negative resection; R1: Microsopically positive resection; pN+: pathologically positive nodal status; M0: absence of distant metastases; ➢ Primary indication; • Details reported; ○ Alternatives (if present) for the same priority level/detail indicated.