Table 2.
Authors & Year | Type of the Study | Main Aim | Population of Nulliparous LNG-IUS Users | Type of LNG-IUS | Observation/ Follow-Up Time |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Pakarinen et al. 1996 [41] | Randomized prospective | To compare the efficacy, safety and acceptability of LNG-IUS situated in the cervical canal or uterine cavity |
N = 145 69 LNG-IUS intracervical 76 LNG-IUS intrauterine |
20 µg/24 h | 1 year |
Suhonen et al. 2004 [45] |
Randomized prospective | To compare the safety and acceptability of LNG-IUS and OCs in young nulliparous women | N = 94 Median age: 21; Range: 18–25 | Mirena 20 µg/24 h; Total content: 52 mg Size: 32 × 32 mm |
1 year |
Wildemeersch et al. 2005 [51] | Open prospective noncomparative | To evaluate the ease of insertion, contraceptive performance and the safety of LNG-IUS Femilis |
N = 92 Mean age: 29 Range: 16–50 |
Femilis Slim 20 µg/24 h Total content: 40 mg Size: 30 × 24 mm |
1 year |
Römer et al. 2009 [42] | Cross-sectional | To identify the characteristics and experiences of women using LNG-IUS | ~ 694 8% of 8680-whole study group |
Mirena 20 µg/24 h Total content: 52 mg Size: 32 × 32 mm |
20% used IUS < 1 year, 16% 1–2 years; 15% 2–3 years; 14% 3–4 years; 13% 4–5 years; 18% > 5 years; 3% no data |
Wildemeersch et al. 2009 UPDATE ON: Wildemeersch et al. 2005 [50] |
Open prospectivenoncomparative | To provide an update on the performance of LNG-IUS Femilis in parous and nulliparous women |
N = 112 Mean age: 29 Range: 17–48 |
Femilis20 µg/24 hTotal content: 60 mgSize: 30 × 28 mm | 5 years |
Bahamondes et al. 2011 [32] | Retrospectivecohort | To evaluate the ease of insertion and clinical performance of LNG-IUS in nulligravidas for up to 1 year after insertion |
N = 158 Mean age: 30 |
Mirena 20 µg/24 h Total content: 52 mg Size: 32 × 32 mm |
1 year |
Marions et al. 2011 [39] | Non-interventional cohort | To gain knowledge about the insertion and the use of LNG-IUS in nulliparous women | N = 224Median age: 20 | Mirena 20 µg/24 h Total content: 52 mg Size: 32 × 32 mm |
Follow-ups: 1st 2–5 weeks (N = 137) 2nd 12–26 weeks (N = 197) 3rd 30–124 weeks (optional) (N = 134) |
Armitage et al. 2013 [31] | Observational prospective | To follow 100 women attending for fitting LNG-IUS at a single urban general practice serving students |
N = 97 Age range: 18–38 |
Mirena 20 µg/24 h Total content: 52 mg Size: 32 × 32 mm |
1 year |
Madden et al. 2014 [38] | Secondary analysis of Contraceptive CHOICE Project [53] | To investigate if young age and nulliparity were associated with the expulsion of LNG or Cu-IUS | N = 1690 | 20 µg/24 h | 1 year |
Savasi et al. 2014 [43] | Retrospective | To assess complication rates with the use of LNG-IUS in adolescents with developmental disabilities | N = 54 | Mirena 20 µg/24 h Total content: 52 mg Size: 32 × 32 mm |
Follow-up after the insertion of IUD ranged from 0 to 51 months (15 months on average) |
Zhao et al. 2014 [52] | Prospective | To analyze experiences and the levels of satisfaction with Mirena among Chinese women | N = 77 | Mirena 20 µg/24 h Total content: 52 mg Size: 32 × 32 mm |
Follow ups: 1st 3–4 months 2nd 1 year |
Abraham et al. 2015 [30] | Secondary analysis of Contraceptive CHOICE Project [53] | To assess the relationship among young age, nulliparity and the continuation of LARC methods | N = 1456 | Not specified | Follow ups: 1st 1 year 2nd 2 years |
Kaislasuo et al. 2015 [37] | Prospective cohort |
To assess if small uterine cavity size was associated with bleeding problems or pain in nulligravid women using IUD | N = 111 | Mirena 20 µg/24 h Total content: 52 mg Size: 32 × 32 mm |
1 year |
Gemzell-Danielsson et al. 2015 [35] | Randomized prospective |
To evaluate if the outcomes of LNG-IUS were affected by parity, age or BMI |
N = 1130 Age range: 18–35 |
49%-LNG-IUS 8 µg/24 h Total content: 13.5 mg 51%-LNG-IUS 13 µg/24 h Total content: 19.5 mg Both size: 28 × 30 mm |
3 years |
Eisenberg et al. 2015 [34] | Partially randomized prospective |
To assess 3-year data on the efficacy and safety of 52 mg LNG-IUS |
N = 1011 at enrollment Mean age: 25 Range: 16–45 |
Liletta 20 µg/24 h Total content: 52 mg Size: 32 × 32 mm |
3 years |
Mejia et al. 2016 [40] | Secondary analysis of Contraceptive CHOICE Project [53] | To evaluate the effect of baseline bleeding patterns on the rates of amenorrhea during the use of 52 mg LNG-IUS | N = 515 | Total content: 52 mg | 1 year |
Hall et al. 2016 [36] | Observational | To follow college students who chose IUD and assess the insertion, use, continuation, and satisfaction |
N = 88 Aged 18–30 |
Mirena 20 µg/24 h Total content: 52 mg Size: 32 × 32 mm |
1 year |
Wildemeersch et al. 2017 [49] | Observational prospective | To report on the contraceptive performance of LNG-IUS after 5 years of use |
N = 117 Mean age: 27 Range: 15–47 |
Femilis 20 µg/24 h Total content: 60 mg Size: 30 × 28 mm |
5 years (N = 114) |
Darney et al. 2018 [33] | Prospective cohort | To evaluate amenorrhea rates and predictors during the 1st year of LNG-IUS use | N = 822 | Liletta 20 µg/24 h Total content: 52 mg Size: 32 × 32 mm |
1 year |
Schreiber et al. 2018 [44] | Prospective | To evaluate bleeding patterns for Liletta using the WHO Belsey definitions | N = 982 | Liletta 20 µg/24 h Total content: 52 mg Size: 32 × 32 mm |
First 90 days (N = 982) Second 90 days (N = 949) Last 90 days of year 1 (N = 866) Last 90 days of year 2 (N = 711) Last 90 days of year 3 (N = 568) |
Vaitsiakhovich et al. 2018 [48] | Cross design analysis of randomized and observational data |
To evaluate the discontinuation rate of LNG-IUS in real-life setting | N = 50 | Mirena 20 µg/24 h Total content: 52 mg Size: 32 × 32 mm |
2 years |
Teal et al. 2019 UPDATE ON: Eisenberg et al. 2015 [46] |
Partially randomizedprospective | To re-assess the efficacy and safety of 52 mg LNG-IUS after 5 years of use (the continuation of Eisenberg et al. 2015) |
N = 1011 Mean age: 25 Range: 16–45 |
Liletta 20 µg/24 h Total content: 52 mg Size: 32 × 32 mm |
5 years (N = 986) |
Teunissen et al. 2019 [47] | Retrospective cohort | To investigate differences in continuation rates between the contraceptive and therapeutic use of LNG-IUS | N = 379 | Total content: 52 mg | Minimum 5 years |
Abbreviations: BMI: body mass index; Cu-IUS: Copper-releasing intrauterine system; IUS: intrauterine system; LNG-IUS: levonorgestrel releasing intrauterine system; OC: oral contraceptives; WHO: World Health Organization; LARC: long-acting reversible contraception; IUD: intrauterine devices.