Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 12;15(8):e0237353. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0237353

Table 3. Mean percent escape response and percent mortality of An. dirus (TMMU) exposed to TFT in ER assays.

% Concentration ER assay Percent escape response Percent knockdown and mortality in treatments***
Control Treatment % KD 30 min exposure % Mortality 24 h
N %Esc.* N %Esc.**,(§) Esc. NEsc. Esc. NEsc.
0.00409 (LC50) Noncontact 60 8.33a 60 80.00a 75.51a 18.18a 14.29a 63.64a
Contact 60 10.00a 60 74.08a (0) 78.26a 100.0b 32.61a 50.00a
0.00489 (LC75) Noncontact 62 12.90a 60 46.42a 93.75a 96.43a 40.63a 89.29a
Contact 61 9.84a 60 59.33a (10.00) 73.68a 100.0a 31.58a 90.91a
0.00754 (LC99) Noncontact 60 8.33a 62 85.93a 40.74a 100.0a 3.70a 37.50a
Contact 62 4.84a 62 64.52b (0) 65.00a 100.0a 2.50a 50.00a
0.01508 (DC) Noncontact 60 15.00a 60 49.02a 94.12a 100.0a 50.00a 100.0a
Contact 62 9.68a 58 54.19a (1.95) 100.0a 100.0a 55.88a 95.83a

ER, excito-repellency; Esc, escaped mosquitoes; NEsc, non-escaped mosquitoes; KD, knockdown; LC, lethal concentration; DC, discrinimating concentration.

*Percent escape in control group showed no significantly difference (P > 0.05) between noncontact and contact tests at the same concentration.

**Percent escape adjusted with paired controls using Abbott’s formula. Different letter indicates significant differences (P < 0.05) between noncontact and contact tests in treatment group at the same concentration.

***Different letter indicates significant differences (P < 0.05) between control, noncontact and contact tests at the same concentration and same response group (Esc. or NEsc.).

§Percent contact escape adjusted with paired noncontact escape response using modified Henderson-Tilton’s formula.

†Due to TFT vaporization during drying period, the actual percent concentration at the time of testing is less than initial paper treatment percent indicated.

30-min KD and 24-hr mortality not observed in controls.