Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Sep 16.
Published in final edited form as: Ophthalmic Plast Reconstr Surg. 2020 Sep-Oct;36(5):444–450. doi: 10.1097/IOP.0000000000001585

TABLE 3.

Review of previous studies of PD-L1 or PD-L2 expression in adenoid cystic carcinoma

Author, year citation Tumors studied Positive PD-L1 expression (no. positive/total) Positive PD-L2 expression (no. positive/total) CD8 expression
Mosconi et al. (2019)12 36 ACCs Greater than 1% expression by IHC: Greater than 10% expression by IHC: Intratumoral:
−10 parotid Low: 19/36
−9 sublingual ACC tumor PD-L1: 0/36 ACC tumor PD-L2: 36/36 High: 17/36
−5 submandibular ACC stroma PD-L1; 0/36 ACC stroma PD-L1; 29/36 Intrastromal:
−4 palate Low: 22/36
−4 tongue High: 14/36
−4 jugal mucosa (primary and recurrences)
Nakano et al. (2019)13 11 ACCs (out of 30 head and neck salivary gland tumors) Greater than 1% expression by IHC: Positive by in situ hybridization ACC:
Low: 11/11
ACC tumor PD-L1: 0/11 ACC tumor PD-L2: 5/11 High: 0/11
Non-ACC tumor PD-L1: 11/19 Non-ACC tumor PD-L2: 6/17 Non-ACC: Low: 9/19 High: 10/19
Sridliaran et al. (2016)14 28 ACCs (from 21 patients) (mixture of primary and metastatic tumors to the lung—primary site unspecified; 7 patients had both primary and metastatic tumor sample) Greater than 5% expression by IHC: Greater than 10% expression by IHC: High: 42%
ACC tumor PD-L1: 0/28 ACC tumor PD-L2:
−9/15 of primary
−8/11 of metastatic
Mukaigawa et al. (2016)15 53 ACCs (out of 219 salivary gland tumors of oral cavity ) Greater than 5% expression by IHC: Not studied Unspecified
ACC tumor PD-L1: 1/53
ACC TIMC PD-L1 : 0/53
Tapias et al. (2019)16 14 ACCs (out of 23 primary tracheal tumors) Greater than 1% expression by IHC: ACC tumor: 0/14 Not studied Low: 14/14
High: 0/14
Harada et al. (2018)17 25 ACCs (out of 47 malignant salivary gland tumors) Greater than 5% expression by IHC: PD-L1 tumor: 11/25 ACC Not studied Unspecified

ACC, adenoid cystic carcinomas; IHC, immunohistochemistry; PD-L, programmed cell death ligand; TIMC, tumor-infiltrating mononuclear cell.