Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 17;10:13880. doi: 10.1038/s41598-020-70796-3

Table 2.

Comparison of the results of the present study with earlier literature.

References Carbon source Synthesis method Particle size Application Cytotoxicity
Li et. al.111 Ginger juice Hydrothermal 8.2 ± 0.6 nm Treatment of liver cancer

Cell Type: HepG2, human hepatocellular carcinoma cell line; MCF-10A, normal mammary epithelial cell line; FL83B, normal liver cell line; A549, human lung cancer cell line; MDA-MB-231, human breast cancer cell line

Dose-dependent cytotoxicity, higher selectivity inhibition towards HepG2 cells

Effective on HepG2 cell cycle (increase in SubG1 phase), did not cause significant differences in cell cycles for the other four non-cancerous cell lines

Kyung Yung et. al.47 Citric Acid and β-alanine Microwave pyrolysis 2–3 nm Cell nucleus Targeting

Cell Type: HeLa Cells

No significant cytotoxicity, nuclear localization, Nucleus targeting, and imaging ability shown in vivo

No genotoxicity evaluation

Havrdova et al.49 Candle soot Oxidative acid treatment 4–7 nm Cell nucleus Targeting and labeling

Cell Type: NIH/3T3, Standard mouse fibroblasts

CD-Pri: low cytotoxicity, stimulated proliferation, evoked oxidative stress and induced abnormalities in the cell cycle (G2/M arrest), no entrance to the nucleus

CD-PEG: low cytotoxicity, did not disrupt cellular morphology, toxic dose occurred at very high IC50 value and oxidative stress increased similarly like in the control. Did not cause any significant changes in the proportion of the cell cycle phases

CD-PEI: cytotoxic, entering into the cell nucleus and inducing the largest changes in the G0/G1 phase of the cell cycle and also induced G2/M arrest

Periasamy et. al.108 Commercial CDs -  < 50 nm Cell cytotoxicity

Cell Type: hMSCs, human mesenchymal stem cells

CNPs moderately reduce cell viability and cause chromatin condensation and DNA fragmentation, disrupt the expression of cell death genes

Cell cycle progression of hMSCs was arrested slightly, the number of cells in G0/G1 increased at low concentrations of CNP exposure, cell cycle was arrested in the sub-G0/G1 phase in a dose-dependent manner

Kumawat et al.50 Grape seed extract Microwave 50–60 nm Nucleus Imaging, and Photoluminescent Sensing

Cell Type: L929, HT-1080, MIA PaCa-2, HeLa, and MG-63 cells

The tendency to self-localize themselves into cell nucleus regardless of cell-type. No cytotoxicity and act as an enhancer in cell proliferation in L929 confirmed by in vitro wound scratch assay and cell cycle analysis. Enhanced the number of L929 cells in S-phase

Kalytchuk et. al.110 Citric acid and L-cysteine Hydrothermal 3–6.5 nm In vitro and in vivo luminescence lifetime thermometry

Cell Type: NIH/3T3, Standard mouse, fibroblasts; HeLa, human cervical cancer cells

Low cytotoxicity, No significant effect on the cell cycle of HeLa cells, Dose-dependent G0/G1 arrest slightly on NIH/3T3 cells

Liu et al.92 Young Bearly Leaves Hydrothermal 1.9 and 2.7 nm (in EtoH) Cell nucleus Targeting and antiviral activity

Cell Type: PK-15 and HeLa cells

No significant cytotoxicity,  the neutral charged CDs (b-CDs) were localized in the cytoplasm and showed anti-viral activity, while the negatively charged ones (c-CDs) distributed through the whole cell and nuclear localization was also observed. Nucleus targeting and imaging ability of CDs have been shown in vitro

No genotoxicity evaluation

Hill et al.100 Glucosamine-HCl and m-phenylenediamine Microwave 2.42 ± 0.55 nm LED-activated nucleus targeting and photothermal therapy

Cell Type: HDF and HeLa cells

Less cytotoxicity on HDF than HeLa cells, nuclear localization in HeLa cell line,

Nucleus targeting and imaging ability have been shown in vitro. CDs-based or LED induced cell death of cancer cells were not found to be associated with ROS production

No genotoxicity evaluation

Zhang et al.112 Citric acid (CA), and propylene diamine (PDA) Hydrothermal 5 nm Cell nucleus labeling, cell-cycle imaging

Cell Type: HeLa-229 and HCerEPic

No significant cytotoxicity on both cell lines. Permeability of cancer cells to CDs is higher than that of normal cells. N-CQDs were located in the nucleus with no fluorescence on the cytoplasm The majority of labeled HeLa cells were observed in interphase

Present study Nerium oleander Thermal 2.05 ± 0.22 nm Anti-cancer therapy

Cell Type: MCF-7, human breast cancer cells, HDFa, human primer dermal fibroblast cells

Dose-dependent cytotoxicity on MCF-7 cells, no cytotoxic effects on HDFa cells

Genotoxicity, Clastogenicity and G0/G1 arrest on MCF-7 cells