Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 18;37(10):4107–4131. doi: 10.1007/s12325-020-01460-5

Table 2.

GRADE evidence profile

Outcome Certainty assessment No. of patients Effect Certainty
Study ID Study design Risk of bias Inconsistency Indirectness Imprecision Other considerations Intervention Comparator Relative (95% CI) Absolute (95% CI)
Mortality Chen et al. [21] RCT Serious Not serious Not serious Very serious None 0/15 0/15 Very low
Failure of virologic clearance Chen et al. [21] RCT Serious Not serious Serious Very serious None 2/15 1/15 RR 2.0 (0.2–20) Very low
Clinical improvement Zhaowei Chen et al. [18] RCT Serious Not serious Serious Serious None 25/31 17/31 RR 1.47 (1.02–2.11) Very low
Virologic cure Gautret et al. [17] Prospective cohort Very serious Serious Not serious Serious None 70% 12.5% RR 16.33 (2.8–95.26) Very low
Virologic cure Molina et al. [22] Single-arm study Very serious Serious Serious Serious None 2/11 Very low
Mortality Molina et al. [22] Single-arm study Very serious Serious Serious Serious None 1/11 Very low
QT interval Chorin et al. [20] Single-arm study Very serious Serious Serious Serious None 11% Very low
Mortality Million et al. [19] Single-arm, retrospective, cohort study Very serious Serious Serious Not serious None 8/1061 Very low
Virologic cure Million et al. [19] Single-arm, retrospective, cohort study Very serious Serious Serious Not serious None 973/1061 Very low
Mortality Magognoli et al. [23] Retrospective, propensity-score-matched cohort Very serious Not serious Not serious Not serious None 51/210 18/158 RR 2.49 (1.39–4.47) Very low
Rates of ventilation Magognoli et al. [23] Retrospective, propensity-score-matched cohort Very serious Not serious Serious Not serious None 21/210 22/158 RR 0.69 (0.36–1.29) Very low
Virologic cure Tang et al. [24] Randomized controlled study Very serious Serious Serious Not serious None 64/75 61/75 RR 1.33 (0.56–3.16) Very low
Clinical cure Holshue et al. [28] Case report Very serious Not serious Not serious Very serious None 1/1 Very low
Extubation of mechanical ventilation Grein et al. [29] Single-arm, prospective cohort 17/30 Very low
Mortality Grein et al. [29] Single-arm, prospective cohort Very serious Serious Serious Serious None 7/61 Very low
Body temperature Wang et al. [36] Prospective cohort Very serious Serious Serious Serious None 2.06 ± 0.28 5.29 ± 0.70 Very low
Mortality Lu et al. [37] Retrospective cohort Very serious Serious Serious Serious None 12/31 5/31 RR 3.2 (0.98–10.89) Very low
Body temperature normalization Shen et al. [38] Case series Not serious Not serious Very serious Not serious None 4/5 Very low
Virologic cure Shen et al. [38] Case series Not serious Not serious Very serious Not serious 5/5 Very low
Clinical cure Duan et al. [39] Case series Not serious Not serious Very serious Not serious 10/10 Very low
Absorption of pulmonary lesions Duan et al. [39] Case series Not serious Not serious Very serious Not serious 10/10 Very low
Virologic cure Young et al. [40] Case series Not serious Not serious Very serious Not serious 2/2/ Very low
Virologic cure Zhu et al. [44] RCT Serious Not serious Not serious Not serious 16/16 19/34 RR 26.23 (1.45–472.69) Very low
Virologic cure Li et al. [45] RCT Serious Not serious Serious Serious 25/69 7/17 RR 0.81 (0.27–2.39) Very low
Days to normalization of body temperature Ye et al. [43] Prospective cohort Very serious Not serious Serious Not serious 4.8 ± 1.94 7.3 ± 1.53 Very low
Body temperature normalization Xu et al. [41] Prospective cohort Very serious Not serious Serious Not serious 20/20 Very low
Virologic cure Luna et al. [42] Case report Very serious Very serious Not serious Not serious 1/1 Very low

RR relative risk