Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 1;20(15):4301. doi: 10.3390/s20154301

Table 1.

Advantages and disadvantages of the comparison methods.

Methods Advantages Disadvantages
3D-FCN Simple implementation Incorrect determination of non-nodule tissue outside lung as nodule
MRCNN Simple implementation, multi-resolution model is good for small-size nodule detection Incorrect determination of non-nodule tissue outside lung as nodule
3D-UNET Lung parenchyma regions are first detected, lower over-estimation rate Near-edge regions are easily lost, confusion of small tissues as nodules
PRN-HSN Lung parenchyma regions are first detected, lower over-estimation rate Near-edge regions are easily lost, small-size nodule within weakened, low-resolution region cannot be recognized
DCNN Simple implementation Small-size nodules on the edges of parenchyma region are easily omitted
CLAHE-SVM Nodules within low-contrast regions can be detected with the contrast-enhancement pre-processing Small-size tissues are easily over-estimated as nodules
Mask-RCNN Small-size nodules can be detected accurately, nodule detection and segmentation are achieved simultaneously Heavy computational cost, unstable performance on nodule detection
proposed Pulmonary nodules can be detected accurately with low over-estimation of non-nodule tissues Nodules within low-contrast, vague regions cannot be detected