Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 7;11:768. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2020.00768

Table 3.

Risk of bias assessment.

Selection Bias (sequence generation) Selection Bias (allocation concealment) Performance Bias (blinding of subjects) Detection Bias (blinding of outcome assessment) Attrition Bias (handling of incomplete outcome data) Reporting Bias (selective reporting)
Assanangkornchai et al. (101) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g004.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg key
Babor et al. (79) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g004.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg Low risk of bias
Kalichman et al. (95) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg Unclear risk of bias
Kalichman et al. (96) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g004.jpg High risk of bias
L’Engle et al. (102) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg
Mertens et al. (97) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg
Nadkarni et al. (89) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg
Noknoy et al. (105) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg
Omeje et al. (87) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g004.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g004.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg
Pal et al. (100) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg
Papas et al. (112) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g004.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg
Peltzer et al. (93) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg
Pengpid et al. (103) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg
Pengpid et al. (104) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g004.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g004.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg
Rendall-Mkosi et al. (94) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g004.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g004.jpg
Segatto et al. (88) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg
Sheikh et al. (90) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g004.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg
Shin et al. (92) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g004.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg
Sorsdahl et al. (98) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg
Wandera et al. (99) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg
Witte et al. (91) graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g002.jpg graphic file with name fpsyt-11-00768-g003.jpg