Table 1.
Authors | Design | Samples | Methods | ACE2 & TMPRSS2 expression | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Vaarala | Mixed | Human | TMPRSS2 | Salivary glands | 1. TMPRSS2 is expressed in human salivary gland tissues |
2001 [10] | Study | Mouse | RNAseq | TMPRSS2 (human):+ | |
Hamming | Human | Human | ACE2 | Oral, Nasal, Nasopharyngeal Epithelium & endothelium | 1. ACE2 was found in endothelial (arteries & veins) and epithelial cells of nasal, rhinopharyngeal and oral mucosa. Precisely, the epithelium expression concerned the basal layer cells |
2004 [11] | Study | IHC | ACE2 human:+ (all mucosa) | ||
Jia | Human | Human | ACE2 | Tracheal Epithelium & endothelium | 1. ACE2 was more expressed on the apical than the basolateral surface of polarized airway epithelia |
2005 [12] | Study | IHC & biotinylation | ACE2 (human):+ | ||
Liu | Experimenal | Monkey | ACE2 | Naso- Oro- Hypopharyngeal & Tracheal Epithelium | 1. ACE2 is expressed in salivary gland ducts of the pharyngeal glands |
2011 [13] | Study | IHC | ACE2 Monkey:+ | 2. ACE2 was expressed in epithelial cells (lamina propria, respiratory tract) | |
Virion in Saliva:+ | 3. Virus was found in saliva of infected monkeys | ||||
Bilinska | Animal | Mouse | ACE2 & TMPRSS2 | Olfactory Epithelium | 1. ACE2 & TMPRSS2 are expressed in sustentacular cells of the olfactory epithelium but not/much less in most olfactory receptor neurons |
2020 [14] | Study | RNAseq, RT-PCR, | ACE2: sustentacular cells | ||
In situ hybridization, | TMPRSS2: sustentacular cells | 2. Expression of the entry proteins increases in animals of old age | |||
WB & IHC | |||||
Brann | Mixed | Mouse | ACE2 & TMPRSS2 | Olfactory Epithelium | 1. In human, ACE2 & TMPRSS2 were not identified in purified olfactory neurons |
2020 [15] | Study | Human | RNAseq | ACE2 & TMPRSS2 Mouse: non-neuronal cells | |
ACE2 & TMPRSS2 Human: glial and neuronal stem cells | 2. ACE2 was identified in glial cells & olfactory stem cells | ||||
Butowt | Mixed | Mouse | ACE2 & TMPRSS2 | Olfactory Epithelium | 1. Nasal epithelial cells have lower levels of ACE2 & TMPRSS2 compared with epithelial cells of the lower respiratory tract |
2020 [16] | Study | Human | RNAseq | ACE2 Mouse & Human: non neuronal cells | |
TMPRSS2 Mouse & Human: neuronal & non-neuronal cells | 2. ACE2 has non-neuronal expression in olfactory epithelium | ||||
Respiratory Epithelium | 3. The expression of ACE2 & TMPRSS2 (mouse) were increased in elderly mouse | ||||
ACE2 & TMPRSS2 Human:+ (Lower Airway > Nasal) | |||||
Cao | Human | Human | ACE2 gene | No localization provided | 1.15 unique expression quantitative trait loci variants were found for ACE2 |
2020 [17] | Study | Genetic Analyzis | 2. The genotypes of ACE2 gene polymorphism may be characterized by higher expression levels of ACE2 in East Asian population | ||
3. There would be different susceptibility or response to SARS-CoV2 in different populations | |||||
Chen | Human | Human | ACE2 | Salivary glands | 1. ACE2 is expressed in human granular cells of salivary glands |
2020 [18] | Study | RNAseq | ACE2 human:+ | ||
Hikmet | Human | Human | ACE2 | Nasopharyngeal Epithelium | 1. There was no ACE2 expression in nasopharyngeal cells |
2020 [19] | Study | IHC | ACE2 (human): no expression in nasopharynx | ||
Lee | Human | Human | ACE2 | Tracheal, Nasal & Sinusal Epithelium | 1. ACE2 is expressed in ciliated epithelial cells (cilia organelle) |
2020 [20] | Study | IHC | ACE2 (human):+ | 2.There was no ACE2 expression in the non-ciliated goblet cells | |
3. ACE2 expression is influenced by patient demographics, clinical characteristics, co-morbidities, or medication use. The use of ACE inhibitor drugs did not increase ACE2 protein expression | |||||
Li | Human | Human | ACE2 | Thyroid | 1. ACE2 is expressed by thyroid cells |
Hikmet | Human | Human | ACE2 | Nasopharyngeal Epithelium | 1. There was no ACE2 expression in nasopharyngeal cells |
2020 [19] | Study | IHC | ACE2 (human): no expression in nasopharynx | ||
2020 [21] | Study | RNAseq | ACE2 human:+ | ||
Sungnak | Human | Human | ACE2 & TMPRSS2 | Airway & Nasal epithelium | 1. ACE2 was expressed in airway epithelial cells |
2020 [22] | Study | RNAseq | ACE2 human:+ | 2. ACE2 is more expressed in nasal epithelial cells compared with other respiratory cells (goblet & ciliated cells) | |
TMPRSS2 (human): subset of ACE2 cells | |||||
3. TMPRSS2 is only expressed in a subset of ACE2 + cells | |||||
Xu | Human | Human | ACE2 & TMPRSS2 | Oral Epithelium | 1. ACE2 is expressed in the oral cavity epithelial cells |
2020 [23] | Study | RNAseq | ACE2 human:+ | 2. ACE2 expression was higher in tongue than buccal and gingival tissues | |
Oral T cells, B cells & fibroblasts | |||||
ACE2 human:+ | |||||
Xu | Human | Human | ACE2 | Minor salivary glands | 1. ACE2 is expressed in minor salivary glands |
2020 [24] | Study | RNAseq | ACE2 human:+ | ||
Wu | Human | Human | ACE2 | Nasal & Oral Epithelium | 1. ACE is expressed in nasal epithelial cells |
2020 [25] | Study | RNAseq | ACE2 (human):+ | 2. The was a higher virus concentration in the nasal-swab comparing with throat-swab, which is attributed to ACE2-expression in nasal epithelial cells | |
Ziegler | Mixed | Human | ACE2 & TMPRSS2 | Sinusal & Nasal goblet epithelial cells | 1. ACE2 & TMPRSS2 are co-expressed in nasal goblet secretory cells |
2020 [26] | Study | Monkey | RNAseq | ACE2 & TMPRSS2 Human:+ |
ACE2 Angiotensin Converting Enzyme-2, IHC Immunohistochemistry, RT-PCR reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction, SARS-CoV-2 severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus-2, TMPRSS2 transmembrane protease serine-2, WB Western Blotting