Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2021 Sep 1.
Published in final edited form as: Chemosphere. 2020 Apr 30;255:126907. doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.126907

Table 1.

Statistic of model performance in simulating surface concentrations of gaseous and particle species.

obs sima N MB NMB Δsimb
(μg/m3) (μg/m3) (pairs) (μg/m3) (%) (μg/m3) (%)
Gas NO2 CN-AQI 31.8 9.3 17466 −22.5 −71.9 −0.12 −1.3%
EU-AIRBASE 22.8 5.2 2976 −17.6 −77.2 −0.20 −3.8%
EU-EMEP 1.6 3.7 502 2 118.5 −0.21 −5.8%
US-AQS 8.5 3.2 407 −5.3 −62.7 −0.03 −1.0%
SO2 CN-AQI 26.1 10.5 17491 −15.6 −62.0 −0.0039 −0.04%
EU-AIRBASE 4.9 1.3 1664 −3.6 −73.7 −0.0004 −0.03%
EU-EMEP 0.3 1 494 0.7 213.5 0.0005 0.05%
US-AQS 1.2 0.3 430 −0.9 −71.9 −6.00E-05 −0.02%
O3 CN-AQI 55.9 74.2 17443 18.3 39.8 5.09 6.80%
EU-AIRBASE 54 63.8 2047 9.8 18.2 8.15 12.80%
EU-EMEP 70.4 63.3 704 −7.1 −9.1 8.48 13.40%
Particles PM2.5 CN-AQI 52.1 37.4 17420 −14.8 −29.4 0.24 0.70%
NO3− EU-EMEP 0.4 2.3 261 2 579.6 0.17 7.70%
US-IMPROVE 0.3 0.6 1800 0.2 43.5 0.03 5.60%
SO42− EU-EMEP 0.5 1 254 0.5 108.2 −0.0030 −0.3%
US-IMPROVE 0.8 0.6 1800 −0.2 −22.2 −0.0011 −0.2%
NH4+ EU-EMEP 0.5 1.1 266 0.5 92.4 0.04 3.80%
a.

sim – the simulated concentrations in Sim-base, annual mean.

b.

Δsim – represent the impacts of STE, derived from the differences in between Sim-Base and Sim-noSTE.