Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2021 Oct 10.
Published in final edited form as: Cancer Lett. 2020 Jun 20;490:124–142. doi: 10.1016/j.canlet.2020.05.030

Table II:

Advantages and challenges of three-dimensional (3D) tumor models.

Techniques Graphical Representation Advantages Challenges Research Stage Ref
Liquid Overlay Culture and Hanging Drop graphic file with name nihms-1616461-t0001.jpg
  • Simple to use

  • Uniform spheroid formation

  • Co-culture feasibility

  • Control cell size

  • Transparent

  • Inexpensive

  • High reproducibility

  • Ease of harvesting

  • Long term culture

  • Limited flexibility

  • Lack reproducibility

  • Lack cell-matrix interaction

  • Heterogeneous cell lineage spheroids

  • Low throughput

  • Spheroid handling and transfer critical

  • Basic Research

  • Drug Discovery

  • Personalized Medicine

[210, 220, 221]
Hydrogel graphic file with name nihms-1616461-t0002.jpg
  • Inexpensive

  • Uniform sized microtumors

  • Co-culture feasibility

  • High reproducibility

  • Customizable microtumor size

  • Cell-ECM interactions

  • Gel Composition

  • Gel-to-gel variations and structural changes

  • Non-Transparent

  • Gelling Mechanism

  • Handling microtumors

  • Isolation of specific microtumors

  • Low throughput

  • Basic Research

  • Drug Discovery

[222226]
Bioreactors graphic file with name nihms-1616461-t0003.jpg
  • Simple to culture

  • High-throughput production

  • Easily accessible spheroids

  • Motion of culture assist nutrient transport

  • Specialized equipment required

  • Cell Number/size cannot be controlled

  • Cells exposed to shear force

  • Basic Research

  • Tissue Engineering

  • Cell Expansion

[161163, 227233]
Scaffolds graphic file with name nihms-1616461-t0004.jpg
  • Medium cost

  • Co-culture feasibility

  • Customizable

  • Scaffold-to scaffold variation

  • Not transparent

  • Difficulty in cell removal

  • Basic Research

  • Drug Screening

  • Cell Expansion

  • Drug Discovery

[157, 234237]
Microtitre plate graphic file with name nihms-1616461-t0005.jpg
  • Controlled spheroid size

  • Cell growth and assays in same well

  • HTS/HCS compatible

  • Limited work on ECMs

  • Basic Research

  • Tissue Engineering

  • Anticancer Drug Screening

[132]
Microfluidics graphic file with name nihms-1616461-t0006.jpg
  • Chemical gradients

  • Cell localization studies

  • Transparent

  • Co-culture feasibility

  • Fluid control

  • Environment control

  • Require expertise

  • High microfabrication cost

  • Basic Research

  • Tissue Engineering

[238240]
3D Bioprinting graphic file with name nihms-1616461-t0007.jpg
  • Chemical and physical gradients

  • Co-culture feasibility

  • Customized architecture

  • High-throughput production

  • Expensive 3D bioprinting machine required

  • Challenges of cell/material used

  • Cancer Pathology

  • Anticancer Drug Screening

  • Cancer Treatment

  • Tissue Engineering

[165, 168, 169, 241]

Extracellular matrix (ECM), High-throughput setting (HTS), High content screening (HCS).