Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 22;106(3):536–553. doi: 10.1016/j.jhin.2020.08.016

Table II.

Microwave and heat intervention parameters and N95 filtering facepiece respirators for which post-decontamination performance outcomes (aerosol penetration and airflow resistance) were evaluated

First author, year Powera/Temperature Time Cycles Moisture Pressure N95 models Performance outcomes Summary of resultsb
Microwave
Bergman, 2010
750 W/ft3
120 s
3
MGS
Room
3M 8000c
3M 8210c
Moldex 2201c
KC PFR95-174c
3M 1860c
3M 1870c
Aerosol penetration
Airflow resistance
%P<3 for all models
AR <15 mmH2O for all models

Fisher, 2011 750 W/ft3 90 s 1 or 3 MGS, steam bag Xd Room Cardinal Health
3M 8210
Moldex 2200
KC PFR95
3M 1860
3M 1870
Aerosol penetration %P<5 for all models/conditions

3
MGS, steam bag Yd

Lore, 2012
1250 We
120 s
1
MGS
Room
3M 1860
3M 1870
Aerosol penetration
%P<2 for all models

Viscusi, 2007 750 W/ft3 120 s 1 Dry Room 3M 8000c Aerosol penetration %P<2 for all conditions

240 s

Viscusi, 2009
750 W/ft3
120 s
1
Dry
Room
3M 8000c
3M 8210c
Moldex 2200c
KC PFR95-270c
3M 1860c
3M 1870c
Aerosol penetration
Airflow resistance
%P<2 for all models
AR ≤9 mmH2O for all models (3M 1870 not measured due to melting)

Heat Bergman, 2010
60°C
30 min
3
MHI (80% RH)
Room
3M 8000c
3M 8210c
Moldex 2201c
KC PFR95-174c
3M 1860c
3M 1870c
Aerosol penetration
Airflow resistance
%P<3 for all models
AR ≤15 mmH2O for all models
Lin, 2017 149–164°C
3 min
1
Dry
Room
3M 8210 Aerosol penetration
Airflow resistance
%P<3 for all conditions
AR <11 mmH2O for all conditions

121°C
15 min
1
Steam (autoclave)
1.06 kg/cm2

Lore, 2012
65°C
20 min
1
MHI (RH unspecified)
Room
3M 1860
3M 1870
Aerosol penetration
%P<2 for all models

Viscusi, 2007 80°C 60 min 1 Dry Room 3M 8000c Aerosol penetration 80°C: %P<1
160°C: mask not measured due to melting

160°C

121°C 15 min 1 Steam (autoclave) 1.05 kg/cm2 Autoclave: %P>18 for both conditions

30 min

Viscusi, 2009 80°C 60 min 1 Dry Room 3M 8000c
3M 8210c
Moldex 2200c
KC PFR95-270c
3M 1860c
3M 1870c
Aerosol penetration 80–100°C: %P ≤ 2 for all models
110120°C: %P<5 for all models except KC PFR95-270 at 110°C (%P=5.4)f
90°C
100°C
110°C
120°C

%P, percentage aerosol penetration; AR, airflow resistance; KC, Kimberly–Clark; MGS, microwave-generated steam; MHI, moist heat incubation; RH, relative humidity.

a

If both manufacturer-rated and experimentally-determined microwave power were provided, the experimental value is reported here.

b

Greater-/less-than values are reported to the nearest whole number. Outcome successes are defined as aerosol penetration <5% and airflow resistance <25 mmH2O.

c

Mask models were anonymized in article. Model names were obtained by e-mail from R. Shaffer in April 2020.

d

Steam Bag X = Medela Quick Clean™ MICRO-STEAM™ BAGS; Steam Bag Y = Munchkin® Steam Guard™ Bags.

e

Power units per volume not specified.

f

Data for the KC PFR95-270 at 110oC was obtained from only one replicate instead of three due to melting of the other two.