Skip to main content
. 2020 Mar 9;18(3):e05991. doi: 10.2903/j.efsa.2020.5991

Table 29.

Occurrence data on short‐chain chlorinated paraffins (SCCPs), medium‐chain chlorinated paraffins (MCCPs) and long‐chain chlorinated paraffins (LCCPs) in food reported in the open literature

Reference Country Number of samples Year Analytical method Compounds
SCCPs MCCPs LCCPs
Lahaniatis et al. (2000) Fish samples consumed in Europe, fish oil and cod liver oil from Europe and America

Fish (n = 8): sprat, redfish, salmon, herring, mackerel, halibut, sardine and trout

Fish oil (n = 4)

Cod liver oil (n = 4)

n.r. GC‐ECNI‐MS

μg/kg fat

Fish: 88–237

Fish oil: 44–284

Cod liver oil: 57–385

μg/kg fat

Fish: 29–99

Fish oil: 63–191

Cod liver oil: 105–248

Parera et al. (2013)

Spain

(Ebro River delta)

Fish (1 kg of muscle meat for each species): sardine, eel, flounder, conger, gilthead sea bream

Shellfish (1 kg of muscle meat for each species): mussel, carpet shell, murex

2012 GC‐ion trap‐MS

μg/kg ww

Fish: 33.2–141

Conger: 141

Seabream: 60.5

Flounder: 33.2

Sardine: 104

Eel: 80.4

Shellfish: 3.1–34.6

Mussel: 12.0

Carpet shell: 3.1

Murex: 34.6

Krätschmer et al. (2019) Germany Fish (n = 133): farmed salmon (n = 122), wild salmon (n = 11) 2014–2017 GC‐Orbitrap‐MS

μg/kg ww

Mean (range):

14 (0.97–170)

μg/kg ww

Mean (range):

19 (1.1–79)

Labadie et al. (2019)

France

(Rhone River basin)

Fish (n = 22): common barbel 2009, 2011 GC‐ECNI‐TOF‐MS

μg/kg ww

0.3–10.6 

μg/kg fat

63–1,492

μg/kg ww

1.3–72.7 

μg/kg fat

99–11,300

Yuan et al. (2017) Sweden Food market basket study: 13 food categories, up to 31 items per category 2015 Direct injection APCI‐qTOF‐MS

μg/kg ww

Cereals: < 1.1

Pastries: < 1.8

Meat: < 1.0

Fish: 4.6

Dairy (fluent): < 2.0

Dairy (solids): < 2.0

Eggs: < 1.3

Fat/oils: < 5.7

Vegetables: < 0.57

Fruit: 0.49

Potatoes: < 0.75

Sugar/sweets: < 0.90

Beverages: < 0.51

μg/kg ww

Cereals: < 1.1

Pastries: 4.3

Meat: < 1.0

Fish: 5.1

Dairy (fluent): < 2.0

Dairy (solids): < 2.1

Eggs: < 1.4

Fats/oils: 14.5

Vegetables: < 0.58

Fruit: 0.90

Potatoes: 0.98

Sugar/sweets: 6.3

Beverages: < 0.52

μg/kg ww

Cereals: < 0.04

Pastries: < 0.07

Meat: < 0.04

Fish: < 0.08

Dairy (fluent): < 0.08

Dairy (solids): < 0.08

Eggs: < 0.05

Fat/oils: < 0.22

Vegetables: < 0.02

Fruit: 0.14

Potatoes: 0.12

Sugar/sweets: 0.54

Beverages: < 0.02

Krätschmer et al. (2019a, see Documentation provided to EFSA) Germany Raw food samples (n = 49): meat and offal (n = 17), eggs (n = 5), milk and dairy (n = 6), fish (n = 13), fats and oils (n = 8) 2018–2019 GC‐ECNI‐Orbitrap‐HRMS

Total CPs

μg/kg ww

Meat and offal: 1.4–12

Eggs: 14–23

Milk and dairy: 0.5–17

Fish: 1.8–360

Fats and oils: 15–800

Krätschmer et al. (2019a, see Documentation provided to EFSA) Germany

Full meals (n = 10): meat‐based (n = 8), vegetarian (n = 2)

Total diet samples (n = 5): light diet (n = 3), full diet (n = 2)

2018–2019 GC‐ECNI‐Orbitrap‐HRMS

μg/kg ww

Full means:

Meat‐based: 1.8–8.9

Vegetarian: 1.2–1.9

Total diet samples:

Light diet: 1.0–2.1

Full diet: 4.0–4.7

μg/kg ww

Full meals:

Meat‐based: 1.0–7.8

Vegetarian: 0.6–2.0

Total diet samples:

Light diet: 0.4–1.1

Full diet: 4.3–4.8

n.a.
Sprengel et al. (2019) Germany (available from the German online market) Oil‐based supplements (n = 25): vitamin E supplements (n = 14), marine oil supplements (n = 7), other oil supplements (n = 4) n.r. GC‐ECNI‐MS

μg/kg fat

mean (min–max)

3,810 (< LOD–61,100)

μg/kg fat

mean (min–max)

15,200 (< LOD–151,000)

n.a.
Yuan et al. (2012) China (Bohai Sea) Molluscs (91 composite samples): bivalves (9 species), gastropods (2 species) 2009 GC‐ECNI‐MS

μg/kg dw

Molluscs: overall range: 64.9−5,510

Median (min, max)

Bivalves: 1,150–2,910 (64.9–5,510)

Gastropods: 506–640 (135–1,660)

n.a. n.a.
Iino et al. (2005) Japan Market basket study (11 food categories: grain crops, seeds/potatoes, sugar, fats, vegetables, fruit, fish, shellfish, meat, eggs, milk) 2003 GC‐ECNI‐HRMS

μg/kg ww

Mean (SD)

Grain crops: 2.5 (3.1)

Seeds/potatoes: 1.4 (2.0)

Sugar/sweets/snacks/seasoning/beverages: 2.4 (3.0)

Fats: 140 (150)

Legumes/vegetables: 1.7 (2.3)

Fruit: 1.5 (1.9)

Fish: 16 (17) [or 170 μg/kg fat]

Shellfish: 18 (19) [or 2,500 μg/kg fat]

Meat: 7.0 (6.6)

Eggs: 2.0 (2.7)

Milk: 0.75 (1.6)

n.a. n.a.
Harada et al. (2011)

China

Korea

Japan

24 h food composite samples (a total of 200 24 h duplicate samples) 1990s, 2007–2009 GC‐ECNI‐HRMS

μg/kga

Samples China: < LOD–28.0

Year 1990s: < 0.20–0.60

Year 2009: 8.5–28.0

Samples Japan: < LOD–1.10

Year 1990s: < 50–760

Year 2009: < 50–1.100

Samples Seoul: < 0.050–0.056

Year 2009: 1 sample with trace levels

Year 1990s: all < LOD

n.a. n.a.
Huang et al. (2018) China Meat and meat products (n = 20): pork, mutton, beef, chicken, duck, rabbit, pork liver, swine blood 2011 GC×GC‐ECNI‐TOF‐MS

μg/kg ww

Mean (SD): 129 (4.1)

μg/kg ww

Mean (SD): 5.7 (0.59)

Wang et al. (2019b) China

Cereals (n = 19 pooled samples, consisting of 1,710 individual samples)

Legumes (n = 19 pooled samples, consisting of 1,710 individual samples)

2011 GC×GC‐TOF‐MS

μg/kg ww

Cereals: 343

Legumes: 328

μg/kg ww

Cereals: 213

Legumes: 184

Zeng et al. (2016)

China

(collection site close to an e‐waste recycling area or far)

Home‐produced eggs

Chicken eggs (n = 17)

Goose eggs (n = 23)

2013 GC‐ECNI‐MS

μg/kg fat

mean, range

Chicken eggs:

Close to e‐waste site:

3,400 (2,300–5,500)

Far from e‐waste site:

4,000 (2,600–6,800)

Goose eggs

Close to e‐waste site:

60,000 (< LOD–150,000)

Far from e‐waste site:

4,600 (< LOD–11,000)

Zeng et al. (2018) China (collection area used to be an e‐waste site) Home‐produced eggs (n = 68): year 2013 (n = 38), year 2016 (n = 30) 2013, 2016 GC‐ECNI‐MS

μg/kg fat

Median:

2013: 926

2016: 1,490

Overall range:

477–111,000

μg/kg fat

Median:

2013: 1,030

2016: 999

Overall range:

125–91,100

Cao et al. (2015) China

Cooking oil (n = 49)

Fried confectionary products (n = 20)

Raw seeds (n = 13)

2010, 2012 GC‐ECNI‐HRMS

μg/kga

Cooking oil:

(detected in 48 samples):

< 9–7,500

Fried confectionary products:

(detected in all samples):

11–1,000

Raw seeds:

(detected in 11 samples):

< 2–68

Sun et al. (2017) China (collection site e‐waste contaminated area)

Fish and invertebrates

Oriental river prawn (n = 50), Chinese mitten crab (n = 16), crucian carp (n = 16), mud carp (n = 5–60), catfish (n = 2), snakehead (n = 5)

2014 GC‐ECNI‐MS

μg/kg fat

1,700–95,000

Highest mean:

Chinese mitten crab: 44,000

Lowest mean:

Large mud carp: 2,100

Gao et al. (2018) China

Duplicate Diet study

Part I: fast food outlets (n = 15)

Part II: collected by 6 participants who provided duplicate portions of what they consumed for their three meals per day (n = 18)

Milk powder (n = 6)

2016 GC‐TOF‐HRMS

μg/kg dw

Mean (range)

Duplicate diet samples: 113 (24.4–546)

Milk power samples:

18.3 (16.2–20.5)

μg/kg dw

Mean (range)

Duplicate diet samples: 55 (17.3–384)

Milk power samples: 8.87 (17.0–384)

Chen et al. (2018) China (collected from an e‐waste recycling industrial park and its surrounding villages) Locally produced staple foods (n = 92): 9 food categories: fish, shellfish, shrimp, meat, poultry, egg, vegetable, cereal, culinary oil 2016–2017 GC‐ECNI‐MS

μg/kg fat

Fish: 94.3–487

Shellfish: 37.1–66.9

Shrimp: 76.5–118

Meat (pork): 37.2–58.6

Poultry: 25.3–88.3

Eggs: 1.62–6.84

Vegetables: 132–605b

Cereals: 37.2–88.6

Culinary oil: 0.892–1.32

μg/kg fat

Fish: 116–563

Shellfish: 35.5–59.9

Shrimp: 76.5–118

Meat (pork): 48.3–69.3

Poultry: 31.9–111

Eggs: 207–10.6

Vegetables: 245–747b

Cereals: 55.4–108

Culinary oil: 1.22–1.76

Gao et al. (2019) China Food samples (n = 122): meat (n = 22), offals (n = 10), fish (n = 10), vegetables (n = 27), fruit (n = 15), seafood (n = 21), oil (n = 6), flour (n = 5), rice (n = 6) 2014–2016 GC‐ECNI‐LRMS

μg/kg ww

Overall range: 0.67–5,100

Mean

Meat: 117

Seafood: 60.5

Fish: 46

Offals: 27.8

Fruit: 16.4

Vegetables: 11.7

Oils: 15.7–5,100

n.a.: not analysed; n.r.: not reported; GC: gas chromatography; ECNI: electron capture negative ionisation; MS: mass spectrometry; HRMS: high‐resolution MS; TOF‐MS: time‐of‐flight MS.

a

Not clear whether the results were expressed on a wet, fat or dry basis.

b

The CONTAM Panel noted that it is uncommon to express levels in vegetables on fat weight basis.