Table 2.
Synthesis of determinants of caregiver burden: comparison between Adelman et al. (2014) [21] and the current review
| Adelman et al. (2014)a [21] | Current review | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hypothesis ASMb (support found, no support found) | Categorisation | Risk Factors | Determinants | Categorisation (ASM)b | Hypothesis ASMb (support found, no support found) |
| H1 (direct relation) | Demographics | Female sex | Female sex | Background characteristic | H1 (direct relation) |
| Low education | – | ||||
| Cohabitation with care recipient | Cohabitation/Living distance | Miscellaneous factor | Inconclusive | ||
| H1 (direct relation) | Psychosocial | Coping strategies | Coping strategies | Moderators |
H1 (direct relation) H5 partially supported: no moderation of coping strategies |
| – | Social Support | H5 partially supported: moderation of social support | |||
| Depression and depressive symptoms |
Global (self-esteem) Situational (loss of self, competence) |
Intrapsychic stressors |
H1 (direct relation) H4 (mediation) not supported |
||
| Perceived patient distress | – | ||||
| H1 (direct relation) | Caregiving context | Social isolation and decreased social activity |
Role conflict (Restriction of social life) |
Role stressors |
H1 (direct relation) H3 (mediator between duration of caregiving and caregiver burden) |
| Inability to continue regular employment | Role overload | ||||
| Financial stress | – | ||||
| Lack of choice | – | ||||
| Caregiving time and effort | Duration of caregiving | General stressors |
H1 (direct relation) H3 (mediated by role stressors) |
||
| – | Specific Illness | ||||
| – | Dependency levels, both physically as mentally | ||||
| – | Care demands | ||||
| – | Problematic behavior | ||||
aRefers to risk factors of caregiver burden in Table 1 “The Epidemiology of Caregiver Burden” p1054 Adelman et al. (2014) [21]
bThe Adapted Stress Model (ASM) is based on stress theories, notably the transactional model of stress and coping (Lazarus, 1984) [28] and the stress process model (Pearlin, 1990) [29], as well as role theory (Biddle, 1986) [30]