Table 1.
Study characteristics
Author, Journal, Year | Study type | Study size (n =) | Definition of hypothermia | Time of temperature measurement | Normothermic at admission n (%) | Hypothermic at admission n (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Studies including trauma patients overall | ||||||
Aitken et al., Resuscitation, 2009 | Retrospective database analysis | 2,026 | < 35 °C | ED admission | 1,902 (93.9) | 124 (6.1) |
Arthurs et al., Am J Surg, 2006 | Retrospective single center | 2,848 | < 36 °C | ED admission | 2,331 (81.8) | 517 (18.2) |
Balvers et al., J Emerg Trauma Shock, 2016 | Retrospective multicenter | 953 | ≤ 35 °C | ICU admission | 599 (62.9) | 354 (37.1) |
Bukur et al., J Trauma Acute Care Surg, 2012 | Retrospective database analysis | 21,023 | ≤ 36.5 °C | ED admission | 11,642 (55.4) | 9,381 (44.6) |
Hsieh et al., Int J Env Res Pub He, 2018 | Retrospective single center | 13,769 | < 36 °C | ED admission | 13,368 (97.1) | 401 (2.9) |
Ireland et al., Resuscitation, 2011 | Prospective single center | 732 | < 35 °C | ED admission | 635 (86.7) | 97 (13.3) |
Luna et al., J Trauma, 1987 | Prospective single center | 94 | ≤ 36 °C | Field, ED, OR | 32 (34) | 62 (66) |
Martin et al., Shock, 2005 | Retrospective database analysis | 700,304 | < 35 °C | ED admission | 689,278 (98.4) | 11,026 (1.6) |
Mommsen et al., Injury, 2013 | Retrospective single center | 310 | < 35 °C | ED admission | 196 (63.2) | 114 (36.8) |
Wang et al., Crit Care Med, 2005 | Retrospective database analysis | 38,520 | ≤ 35 °C | ED admission | 36,599 (95) | 1,921 (5) |
Studies including patients with traumatic brain injury | ||||||
Bukur et al., J Surg Res, 2012 | Retrospective database analysis | 1,834 | ≤ 35 °C | ED admission | 1,790 (97.6) | 44 (2.4) |
Rubiano et al., Injury, 2013 | Retrospective database analysis | 9,094+ | ≤ 35 °C | ED admission | 7,431 (67.4) | 1,663 (32.6) |
Tohme et al., Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med, 2014 | Prospective multicenter cohort | 589 | ≤ 35 °C | ED admission | 443 (75.2) | 146 (24.8) |
Winkelmann et al., Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg, 2018 | Retrospective single center | 278 | < 35 °C | ED admission | 176 (63.3) | 102 (36.7) |
+Excluding 1,939 patients with no temperature recorded