Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 20;9(1):1803530. doi: 10.1080/2162402X.2020.1803530

Figure 5.

Figure 5.

Immunogenicity of cancer stem-like cells results from lower CD47 expression and increased macrophage phagocytosis. (a) CD47 expression levels quantified by quantitative PCR demonstrated 3-fold lower expression of CD47 on SCA-1+ ID8 cells (p < .01, bulk vs SCA-1+ ID8, left). Histogram in flow cytometry showed lower CD47 protein level on SCA-1+ ID8 cells (right, ns: no staining). Similarly, expression of CD47 is lower on CD133+ HM-1 cells comparing to the expression on bulk population (p < .001, value in folds). Histogram in flow cytometry also showed lower CD47 protein level on CD133+ HM-1 cells (right, ns: no staining). (b) CFSE-pulsed bulk and SCA-1+ ID8 cells were incubated with syngeneic primary CD11c+ cells for 1 hour. Increased phagocytosis (indicated by CD11c+ gated CFSE-stained cells) was observed on both live (p < .01) and irradiated (IR) (p < .05) SCA-1+ ID8 cells (bar data). (c) Analysis on RAW 264.7 cell revealed better phagocytosis on SCA-1+ ID8 cells than on bulk ID8 cells. SCA-1+ ID8 cells were stably transfected with either pcDNA3.1 empty vector (SCA-1+ ID8 vehicle) or pcDNA3.1-CD47 (SCA-1+ ID8 CD47). Suppression of CD47 on bulk ID8 cells by anti-CD47 antibody markedly enhances the phagocytic activities, while forced expression of CD47 on SCA-1+ ID8 cells (SCA-1+ ID8 CD47) hampered the phagocytosis. (d) Cross-presentation of phagocytic antigens to a SCA-1+ ID8-specific T lymphocyte line developed from SCA-1+ ID8 immunized mice showed the same pattern. To a lesser degree, anti-CD47 in bulk ID8 cells increased the number of activated CD8+ T cells, while forced expression of CD47 decreased the number activated T cells. (e) Image study showed that tumor rejection of SCA-1+ ID8 cells was abrogated by forced expression of CD47. Both SCA-1+ ID8 (vehicle) and SCA-1+ ID8 CD47 (started from 10000 cells) grew on 6th day image but the former was mostly cleared on 10th day while the latter retained their growth longer. (f) Representative analysis of peritoneal lavaged cells showed highest percentage of CD3+CD8+ cells in mice with SCA-1+ ID8 vehicle cells (day 20). Mice with SCA-1+ID8 CD47 cells had less CD3+CD8+ and F4/80 cells (p < .01). However, these mice exhibited significantly higher percentage of CD45+CD68+ cells in peritoneal lavage than mice with SCA-1+ID8 vehicle did (p < .001). (g) Significantly less activated CD8+IFN-γ+ splenocytes were seen from mice immunized with SCA-1+ ID8 CD47 cells compared to those from mice immunized with SCA-1+ ID8 vehicle (p < .001). *p < .01, **p < .001, NS: not significant.