Table 1.
Reference | Study design | Time of exposure | Cell target | Outcome and platform | Main findings | Developmental significance |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Schrott et al. 2019* [72••] |
Cross-sectional study n = 24 male, adult subjects; 12 cannabis users and 12 controls |
Pre-conception |
Sperm of male adult subjects Human conceptal tissue (elective abortions) F0 generation |
DNA methylation Quantitative bisulfite pyrosequencing mRNA transcript expression |
• Methylation of DLGAP2 intron 7 was inversely correlated with DLGAP2 mRNA expression in human conceptal brain tissue (p-trend < 0.01). • The inverse relationship between DLGAP2 gene methylation and mRNA transcript expression was evident for both males and females, but this relationship was significant only in females (p-trend = 0.006). |
• DLGAP2 is involved in synapse organization, neuronal signaling, and strongly implicated in autism spectrum disorder (ASD). |
Gerra et al. 2018 [41••] |
Nested case-control study n = 136 subjects ages 18–60 years; 40 cannabis users and 96 controls |
Pre-conception |
Peripheral whole blood of adult subjects F0 generation |
DNA methylation Methylated DNA immunoprecipitation (MeDIP)-qPCR |
• DNA methylation higher in cannabis users compared to control subjects in exon 8 of DRD2 gene at + 66.7 kb from transcription start site (TSS) (p = 0.034) and CpG region at + 3 kb from TSS of NCAM1 gene (p = 0.0004). • No difference in cannabis users compared to control subjects in DNA methylation at ANKK1 − 0.25 kb, DRD2 − 0.4 kb and + 0.9 kb, NCAM1 + 0.4 kb, CBR1 + 22.31 kb. |
• DRD2 and NCAM1 play central role in dopaminergic pathway. • Increased methylation of DRD2 and NCAM1 may reflect lower mRNA expression. • Lower availability of DRD2 receptors could underly reward deficit condition. • NCAM1 implicated in developmental functions and nervous system maintenance. |
Murphy et al. 2018* [28••] |
Cross-sectional study n = 24 male, adult subjects; 12 cannabis users and 12 controls |
Pre-conception |
Sperm of male adult subjects F0 generation |
DNA methylation Reduced representation bisulfite sequencing (RRBS) |
• 6640 CpG sites differed (p < 0.05) between cannabis users and non-users. • Majority of CpGs (78.3%) had lower levels of methylation in user group. • DGLAP2 hypomethylated in user group. • Maximum # CpG sites differentially methylated for given gene was for Aryl Hydrocarbon Receptor Repressor (AHRR) (94 CpGs hypomethylated ≥ 10% among users). • PTG1R methylation inversely correlated with Δ9-THC level (R2 = 0.839, p = 1.97e-4). • Increased CSNK1E methylation associated with increased Δ9-THC (R2 = 0.686, p = 0.003). |
• DNA methylation changes of non-imprinted genes in gametes can resist post-fertilization reprogramming and persist in somatic cells of the offspring, including the brain. • DGLAP2 gene encodes membrane associated protein involved in synapse organization and signaling in neuronal cells and is linked to schizophrenia. • PTG1R, which encodes the Prostaglandin I2 Receptor (a powerful vasodilator), associated with reduced sperm fecundity. • CSNK1E, which encodes the Casein Kinase 1 Epsilon, phosphorylates circadian clock protein PER2 and is implicated in sensitivity to opioids. |
Fransquet et al. 2017 [62•] |
Nested case-control study n = 804 maternal subjects; 44 cannabis users anytime during pregnancy and 760 non-user controls |
Prenatal |
Buccal cells of neonates of maternal subjects F1 generation |
DNA methylation SEQUENOM MassARRAY |
• Gestational cannabis use associated with increased methylation at one CpG site tested in DRD4 (CpG.21.22.2) (β + 1.48, 95% CI: 0.02–2.93, p = 0.047). • At CpG.32, weak evidence that gestational cannabis is associated with increased methylation when adjusting for other substance use (β + .67, 95% CI: − 0.12-1.46, p = 0.09). • No associations remained significant after correction for multiple testing using a Bonferroni corrected significance level of 0.0026 given the 19 CpG units examined. |
• DRD4 plays key role in dopamine signaling and is associated with drug use. • Increased DRD4 methylation in saliva has been associated with increased severity of ADHD symptoms in children. • Tissue specificity (using buccal cells instead of brain tissue) could have contributed to the null findings. |
DiNieri et al. 2011* [55] |
Case-control study n = 25 no maternal cannabis use and n = 24 maternal cannabis use |
Prenatal |
Fetal brain specimens (18–22 weeks of gestation) (elective abortions) F1 generation |
Gene expression (mRNA) |
• Decreased DRD2 mRNA expression in NAc in brain specimens with maternal cannabis exposure (p = 0.003). • DRD2 mRNA levels negatively correlated with maternal report of cannabis use (r = − 0.42, p = 0.005). • DRD2 mRNA expression was not altered in putamen with cannabis exposure (p = 0.736). • DRD1 mRNA levels were not altered in the NAc with cannabis exposure (p = 0.330). • PDYN mRNA expression was not altered with cannabis exposure (p = 0.155). • PENK mRNA expression was not altered with cannabis exposure. |
• DRD2 dysregulation implicated in addiction risk. • Cannabis could increase vulnerability to addiction and other psychiatric disorders by disrupting DRD2 gene expression. |