Table 1.
Demographic and clinical features.
Study | Case | Sex | Age (Year) | Risk Factors | Symptoms | Localization | Complication | Surgical treatment | Donor site | Outcome | Follow Up (month) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mason et al.. 1958 | 1 | M | 9 | _ | P, Sw | PP III F | CABG | Iliac crest | Cured | 33 | |
Harto-Garofalidis et al. 1967 | 2 | M | 17 | _ | P, Sw | PP I F | _ | TRABG | Tibia | Cured | _ |
Chari et al. 1971 | 3 | F | 16 | _ | P, Sw | IV MTB | Limitation of ROM | TRABG | Tibia | Cured | 10 |
Burkhalter et al. 1978 | 4 | F | 22 | P, Sw | IV MTB | _ | TRABG | Iliac crest | Cured | 12 | |
5 | M | 8 | Trauma | P, Sw | IV MTB | Limitation of ROM | TRABG | Fibula | Cured | 18 | |
6 | M | 10 | P, Sw | III MTB Limitation | Limitation of ROM | 1° Curettage 2° TRABG | Fibula | Reoperation/Cured | 72 | ||
Fuhs et al. 1979 | 7 | M | 17 | Trauma | P, Sw | DP IV F | Limitation of ROM, Recurrence | Amputation | _ | Amputation | 12 |
8 | M | 20 | Trauma | P, Sw | I MTB | _ | TRABG | Iliac crest | Cured | _ | |
Chalmers et al. 1981 | 9 | M | 36 | _ | P, Sw | PP V F | Limitation of ROM | CABG | _ | Reoperation/Cured | _ |
10 | F | 13 | P, Sw | PP II F | Recurrence | CABG | _ | Cured | _ | ||
11 | M | 16 | _ | P, Sw | PP I F | _ | Curettage | _ | Cured | _ | |
Barbieri et al. 1984 | 12 | F | 35 | _ | P, Sw | IV MTB | _ | F trasposition | _ | Cured | 24 |
13 | F | 11 | _ | P, Sw | II MTB | Limitation of ROM | TRABG | _ | Cured | 48 | |
14 | F | 30 | _ | P, Sw | IV MTB | _ | CABG | _ | Cured | 6 | |
Lin et al. 1984 | 15 | M | 16 | _ | P, Sw | Hamate | _ | TE | _ | Cured | 15 |
Frassica et al. 1988 | 16 | F | 13 | Trauma | P, Sw | PP V F | _ | CABG | _ | Reoperation/Cured | 244 |
17 | M | 20 | _ | P, Sw | Trapezium | Recurrence | TE | _ | Cured | 176 | |
18 | F | 49 | _ | P | PP I F | _ | CABG | _ | Reoperation/Cured | 254 | |
19 | F | 36 | _ | P, Sw | V MTB | Recurrence | TRABG | _ | Cured | 132 | |
20 | M | 28 | _ | P, Sw | III MTB | _ | CABG | _ | Cured | 55 | |
21 | M | 55 | _ | P | DP V F | _ | CABG | _ | Cured | 59 | |
22 | M | 14 | _ | PF | I MTB | Recurrence | Curettage | _ | Reoperation/Amputation | 42 | |
23 | F | 14 | _ | P | IV MTB | _ | CABG | _ | Cured | 43 | |
24 | F | 28 | _ | P | I MTB | _ | CABG | _ | Cured | 32 | |
25 | F | 16 | _ | P | V MTB | Recurrence | 1° CABG 2° TRABG | _ | Reoperation/ Cured | 27 | |
Kotwal et al. 1988 | 26 | F | 5 | _ | P, Sw | III MTB | _ | TRABG | Fibula | Cured | 48 |
Kozlowski et al. 1988 | 27 | M | 8 | Previous surgery CABG | P, Sw | III MTB | _ | CABG | _ | _ | _ |
28 | M | 9 | Trauma | P, Sw | DP III F | _ | Curettage | _ | _ | _ | |
29 | F | 10 | _ | P, Sw | II MTB | _ | TRABG | _ | _ | _ | |
30 | M | 11 | Trauma | P, Sw | MP III F | _ | CABG | _ | _ | _ | |
31 | F | 13 | _ | P, Sw | II MTB | _ | CABG | _ | _ | _ | |
Milliez et al. 1988 | 32 | F | 10 | _ | P, Sw | MP III F | Recurrence | CABG | Iliac crest | Reoperation/Cured | 6 |
Dossing et al. 1990 | 33 | F | 40 | Trauma | P, Sw | MP I F | Recurrence | 1° CABG 2° TRABG | _ | Reoperation/Cured | 18 |
Mortensen et al. 1990 | 34 | M | 6 | _ | P, Sw | PP III F | _ | TRABG | Ulna | Cured | 72 |
Rao et al. 1993 | 35 | M | 31 | _ | P | I MTB | Recurrence | 1° CABG 2° TRABG | IV MTB | Reoperation/Cured | 44 |
36 | F | 11 | _ | Sw | MP II F | Recurrence | 1° CABG 2° TRABG | PP II F of the foot | Reoperation/Cured | 6 | |
Borrelli et al. 1994 | 37 | M | 10 | _ | Sw | III MTB | _ | TRABG | Fibula | Cured | 30 |
Mankin et al. 1995 | 38 | F | 40 | _ | P | Lunate | Limitation of ROM | TE, SCA | _ | Cured | 6 |
Platt et al. 1995 | 39 | F | 14 | Trauma | P | Capitate | _ | No | _ | Cured | 16 |
Apaydin et al. 1996 | 40 | M | 32 | _ | P, Sw | I MTB | _ | TRABG | Iliac crest | Cured | 18 |
Sakka et al. 1997 | 41 | M | 8 | Trauma | P, Sw | DP I F | _ | Curettage | _ | Cured | 36 |
Athanasian et al. 1999 | 42 | F | 14 | Trauma | P, Sw | PP III F | Recurrence | 1° CABG 2° Criosurgery | Iliac crest | Reoperation/Cured | 60 |
Sproule et al. 2002 | 43 | M | 8 | Trauma | P, Sw | PP I F | Limitation of ROM | CABG | _ | Cured | 12 |
Gundes et al. 2005 | 44 | M | 25 | _ | P, Sw | IV MTB | Limitation of ROM | TRABG | Fibula | Cured | 12 |
Havulinna et al. 2005 | 45 | M | 34 | _ | Sw | Sesamoid II F | _ | TE | _ | Cured | 24 |
Basarir et al. 2006 | 46 | M | 18 | _ | P, Sw | V MTB | _ | CABG | Iliac crest | Cured | 18 |
47 | F | 22 | _ | P, Sw | PP IV F | Recurrence | 1° CABG 2° TRABG | Iliac crest | Reoperation/Cured | 22 | |
48 | M | 16 | Trauma | P, Sw | IV MTB | _ | TRABG | Iliac crest | Cured | 14 | |
49 | F | 52 | Trauma | P, Sw | II MTB | Recurrence | 1° CABG 2° TRABG | Iliac crest | Reoperation/Cured | 125 | |
Sakamoto et al. 2006 | 50 | M | 15 | _ | P | Capitate | _ | Curettage | _ | Cured | 48 |
Sahu et al. 2008 | 51 | F | 12 | _ | Sw | I MTB | _ | TE | _ | Cured | 24 |
Ozyurek et al. 2009 | 52 | M | 21 | _ | P, Sw | V MTB | _ | TRABG | Iliac crest | Cured | 36 |
Jafari et al. 2011 | 53 | M | 16 | _ | Sw | I MTB | Limitation of ROM | TRABG | Fibula | Cured | _ |
54 | F | 6 | _ | Sw | III MTB | _ | TRABG | Fibula | Cured | _ | |
55 | M | 17 | _ | Sw | I MTB | _ | TRABG | Fibula | Cured | _ | |
56 | M | 27 | _ | Sw | PP V F | Graft resorption | TRABG | Iliac crest | Cured | _ | |
57 | F | 15 | _ | Sw | III MTB | _ | TRABG | Iliac crest | Cured | _ | |
58 | F | 10 | _ | Sw | II MTB | _ | TRABG | Fibula | Cured | _ | |
59 | M | 9 | _ | Sw | V MTB | _ | TRABG | Fibula | Cured | _ | |
60 | F | 23 | _ | Sw | II MTB | Recurrence | TRABG | Iliac crest | Reoperation/Cured | 18 | |
61 | F | 15 | _ | Sw | V MTB | Limitation of ROM | TRABG | Fibula | Cured | _ | |
62 | F | 16 | _ | Sw | III MTB | Limitation of ROM | TRABG | Fibula | Cured | _ | |
63 | M | 17 | _ | Sw | PP II F | _ | TRABG | Iliac crest | Cured | _ | |
64 | F | 20 | _ | Sw | PP IV F | _ | TRABG | Iliac crest | Cured | _ | |
65 | M | 20 | _ | P | Capitate | _ | CABG | Iliac crest | Cured | 24 | |
66 | M | 15 | Trauma | P, Sw | III MTB | _ | TRABG | Radius | Cured | 144 | |
67 | F | 23 | _ | P | Lunate | _ | TE | _ | Cured | 72 | |
68 | M | 6 | _ | Sw | III MTB | _ | TRABG | Fibula | Cured | 24 | |
69 | M | 11 | _ | Sw | MP III F | Asimmetry, PPC | CC | _ | Cured | 36 | |
70 | F | 12 | _ | Sw | IV MTB | PPC | CC | _ | Cured | 36 | |
71 | M | 6 | _ | Sw | PP IV F | Recurrence, PPC, Limitation of ROM | 1°CABG 2°CC | _ | Reoperation/Cured | 36 | |
72 | F | 20 | _ | Sw | PP III F | _ | CC | _ | Cured | 36 | |
73 | M | 28 | _ | Sw | MP V F | _ | CC | _ | Cured | 36 | |
74 | F | 22 | _ | Sw | PP IV F | _ | CC | _ | Cured | 36 | |
75 | M | 29 | _ | P, Sw | V MTB | _ | TRABG | VI MTB | Cured | 85 | |
76 | F | 14 | _ | P, Sw | III MTB | _ | TRABG | VI MTB | Cured | 84 | |
77 | F | 15 | _ | P, Sw | III MTB | _ | TRABG | IV MTB | Cured | 84 | |
78 | M | 23 | _ | P, Sw | III MTB | _ | TRABG | III MTB | Cured | 90 | |
79 | M | 19 | _ | P | Pisiform | _ | TE | _ | Cured | _ | |
80 | F | 12 | _ | P, Sw | III MTB | _ | CABG | Iliac crest | Cured | 6’ | |
81 | M | 21 | _ | P, Sw | IV MTB | Limitation of ROM | TR Bone Allograft | IV MTB | Cured | 96 | |
82 | M | 2 | _ | P, Sw | PP III F | _ | CABG | _ | Cured | 60 | |
83 | F | 12 | _ | P, Sw | IV MTB | Limitation of ROM | 1° Curettage 2° TRABG | Iliac crest | Reoperation/Cured | 120 |
CABG: Curettage and autologous bone graft; CC: Curettage and cauterization; Dp: distal phalanx; F: finger; MCB: metacarpal bone;MP: middle phalanx; MTB Metatarsal bone; P: pain; PF: pathologic fracture; PP: proximal phalanx; PPC: premature physeal closure; ROM: Range of Motion; SCA: scapho-capitate arthrodesis; Sw: swelling. TE: tumor excision; TRABG: Tumor resection, curettage and autologous bone graft.