Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 1;15(9):e0238291. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0238291

Table 2. Lifetime health consequences in a cohort of 100,000 women (aged 30 years) among various screening scenarios.

Screening strategy Cancer cases* Deaths* Cancer cases averted# Deaths averted# Life years gained* QALY gained*
No organized screening 2090 (1104–3576) 1650 (873–2824) - - - -
Visual inspection with acetic acid 3 Years 896 (462–1639) 530 (278–986) 1167 (56) 1099 (67) 7614 (4237–13,446) 8789 (4825–15,462)
5 Years 1210 (622–2140) 771 (407–1400) 851 (41) 860 (52) 5938 (3245–10,683) 6770 (3670–12,216)
10 Years 1590 (820–2740) 1123 (586–1953) 474 (23) 512 (31) 3815 (2116–6857) 4255 (2321–7626)
PAP smear 3 Years 998 (481–1842) 598 (291–1115) 1066 (51) 1031 (62) 7208 (3782–13,034) 8262 (4294–15,081)
5 Years 1312 (652–2372) 843 (415–1530) 757 (36) 790 (48) 5550 (2896–10,103) 6233 (3203–11,541)
10 Years 1664 (859–2934) 1182 (606–2094) 414 (20) 456 (28) 3517 (1880–6385) 3887 (2021–7189)
HPV DNA test 3 Years 772 (392–1443) 452 (233–864) 1280 (61) 1163 (70) 8107 (4488–14,243) 9437 (5212–16,697)
5 Years 1084 (523–1970) 682 966 (46) 932 (56) 6470 (3550–11,607) 7406 (4048–13,204)
10 Years 1516 1054 559 (27) 579 (35) 4257 (2418–7697) 4763 (2711–8663)

* Values in parenthesis represent 2.5th and 97.5th percentile,

# Figure in parenthesis indicate percentage decrease in cancer cases and deaths due to HPV 16/18 with various screening strategies as compared to the scenario of no screening; Pap: Papanicolaou test; QALY: Quality adjusted life year