Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 1;10:14353. doi: 10.1038/s41598-020-71268-4

Table 2.

The effects of shading intensities on the yield, yield components, biomass, and HI of wheat in different shading durations in 2016–2017 and 2017–2018.

Cultivar Shading treatment 2016–2017 2017–2018
Duration Intensity Grain yield (g m−2) Grain number (10−3 m−2) Grain weight (mg grain−1) Biomass (g m−2) HI (%) Grain yield (g m−2) Grain number (10−3 m−2) Grain weight (mg grain−1) Biomass (g m−2) HI (%)
Henong825 D1 CK 1,039.1a 25.1a 41.4a 2,230.4a 46.6a 951.4a 27.9a 34.1a 1994.4a 47.7a
S1 1,082.1a 26.2a 41.3a 2,339.0a 46.3a 970.1a 28.7a 33.8a 2034.1a 47.7a
S2 1,040.8a 25.2a 41.3a 2,222.9a 46.8a 966.7a 28.6a 33.8a 2027.8a 47.7a
D3 CK 1,039.1a 25.1a 41.4a 2,230.4a 46.6a 951.4a 27.9a 34.1a 1994.4a 47.7a
S1 1,034.9a 24.7a 41.9a 2,247.3a 46.1a 931.6a 27.4a 34.0a 1990.9a 46.8a
S2 928.2b 22.1b 42.0a 1986.7b 46.8a 810.5b 23.7b 34.2a 1721.1b 47.1a
D5 CK 1,039.1a 25.1a 41.4a 2,230.4a 46.6a 951.4a 27.9a 34.1a 1994.4a 47.7a
S1 948.5b 22.8b 41.6a 2050.4b 46.3a 835.5b 24.5b 34.1a 1806.1b 46.3a
S2 867.6c 21.8b 39.8b 1912.3c 45.3b 782.1c 23.7b 33.0b 1753.0c 44.6b
D7 CK 1,039.1a 25.1a 41.4a 2,230.4a 46.6a 951.4a 27.9a 34.1a 1994.4a 47.7a
S1 886.2b 21.2b 41.8a 1933.6b 45.9a 801.5b 23.3b 34.4a 1721.1b 46.6a
S2 664.3c 17.3c 38.4b 1508.6c 44.0b 577.8c 18.0c 32.1b 1593.6c 36.3b
Kenong9204 D1 CK 977.6a 23.5a 41.6a 2007.9a 48.7a 858.8a 22.7a 37.8a 1784.8a 48.1a
S1 819.3b 19.6b 41.8a 1742.3b 47.0b 758.0b 20.0b 37.9a 1604.2b 47.3a
S2 772.3c 18.3c 42.2a 1721.1b 44.9c 672.0c 17.5c 38.4a 1,476.7c 45.5b
D3 CK 977.6a 23.5a 41.6a 2007.9a 48.7a 858.8a 22.7a 37.8a 1784.8a 48.1a
S1 690.4b 16.4b 42.1a 1,540.5b 44.8b 636.3b 16.7b 38.1a 1,444.9b 44.0b
S2 497.2c 12.4c 40.1b 1519.2c 32.7c 414.4c 11.2c 37.0b 1,168.6c 35.5c
D5 CK 977.6a 23.5a 41.6a 2007.9a 48.7a 858.8a 22.7a 37.8a 1784.8a 48.1a
S1 633.7b 14.5b 43.7a 1,402.4b 45.2b 550.2b 14.0b 39.3a 1,232.4b 44.6b
S2 172.7c 5.5c 31.4b 1,179.3c 14.6c 346.1c 11.2c 30.9b 1,168.6c 29.6c
D7 CK 977.6a 23.5a 41.6a 2007.9a 48.7a 858.8a 22.7a 37.8a 1784.8a 48.1a
S1 521.3b 12.5b 41.7a 1,306.8b 39.9b 448.4b 11.8b 38.0a 1,083.6b 41.4b
S2 98.7c 3.5c 28.2b 1,104.9c 8.9c 267.3c 9.0c 29.7b 1,030.5c 25.9c
ANOVA Cultivars (Cul) ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** **
Duration (D) ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** **
Intensity (In) ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** **
Cul × D ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** **
Cul × In ** ** ** ** ** ** * ** NS **
D × In ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** **
Cul × D × In ** ** ** ** ** ** ** ** NS **

Different letters indicate significant differences (P < 0.05) among the treatments in each duration.

NS not significant.

*Significant at P < 0.05 level; **significant at P < 0.01 level. CK, control with 100% of natural light; S1, 40% of natural light; S2, 10% of natural light; D1, 1 day; D3, 3 days; D5, 5 days; D7, 7 days.