Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Sep 3.
Published in final edited form as: J Neurosurg. 2018 Dec 1;129(6):1397–1406. doi: 10.3171/2017.7.JNS171286

TABLE 5.

Univariate and multivariate analyses of selected outcomes

Univariate
Multivariate
Variable HR (95% CI) p Value HR (95% CI) p Value
Local failure

Treatment group

 No ipilimumab Ref Ref Ref Ref

 Concurrent ipilimumab 0.342 (0.123–0.828) 0.02 0.360 (0.129–0.873) 0.02

 Nonconcurrent ipilimumab 0.846 (0.471–1.569) 0.59 0.861 (0.478–1.600) 0.63

Ipilimumab dose

 3 mg/kg Ref Ref

 10 mg/kg 1.795 (0.793–3.703) 0.15

Tumor vol

 <1 cm3 Ref Ref Ref Ref

 >1 cm3 2.098 (1.077–3.826) 0.03 2.020 (1.034–3.695) 0.04

Edema vol

 <2.5 cm3 Ref Ref

 >2.5 cm3 1.401 (0.733–2.525) 0.29

Edema index

 <10 Ref Ref

 >10 0.855 (0.208–2.330) 0.79

Lesion location

 Cerebral hemispheres 1.015 (0.444–2.926) 0.98

 Other Ref Ref

SRS dose, Gy 1.11 (0.872–1.455) 0.42

Tumor response at 1.5 mos 0.234 (0.114–0.457) <0.001 0.498 (0.220–1.082) 0.08*

Edema response at 1.5 mos 0.300 (0.145–0.584) <0.001 0.522 (0.242–1.076) 0.08*

Tumor response at 3 mos 0.086 (0.034–0.193) <0.001 0.131 (0.047–0.335) <0.001*

Edema response at 3 mos 0.088 (0.032–0.204) <0.001 0.125 (0.044–0.309) <0.001*

  Any lesion hemorrhage

Treatment group

 No ipilimumab 0.570 (0.274–1.150) 0.12 0.469 (0.212–1.013) 0.05

 Concurrent ipilimumab Ref Ref Ref Ref

 Nonconcurrent ipilimumab 0.480 (0.264–0.888) 0.02 0.395 (0.208–0.763) 0.006

Ipilimumab dose

 3 mg/kg Ref Ref

 10 mg/kg 0.917 (0.345–2.046) 0.85

Tumor vol

 <1 cm3 Ref Ref

 >1 cm3 1.528 (0.727–2.906) 0.25

Edema vol

 <2.5 cm3 Ref Ref

 >2.5 cm3 0.849 (0.404–1.611) 0.63

Edema index

 <10 Ref Ref

 >10 1.388 (0.482–3.158) 0.50

Lesion location

 Cerebral hemispheres 6.868 (1.512–121.405) 0.007 6.307 (1.376–111.784) 0.01

 Other Ref Ref Ref Ref

SRS dose, Gy 1.095 (0.876–1.423) 0.45

Tumor response at 1.5 mos 0.558 (0.318–0.985) 0.04 1.063 (0.550–2.076) 0.86

Edema response at 1.5 mos 0.635 (0.362–1.118) 0.11 1.093 (0.577–2.089) 0.79

Any lesion hemorrhage

  Tumor response at 3 mos 0.292 (0.158–0.544) <0.001 0.225 (0.107–0.476) <0.001

  Edema response at 3 mos 0.301 (0.162–0.555) <0.001 0.262 (0.130–0.523) <0.001

Any TRICs

  Treatment group

   No ipilimumab Ref Ref

   Concurrent ipilimumab 1.283 (0.457–3.681) 0.63

   Nonconcurrent ipilimumab 1.145 (0.490–2.980) 0.76

  Ipilimumab dose

   3 mg/kg Ref Ref

   10 mg/kg 0.687 (0.162–2.011) 0.53

  Tumor vol

   <1 cm3 Ref Ref

   >1 cm3 1.160 (0.392–2.773) 0.77

  Edema vol

   <2.5 cm3 Ref Ref

   >2.5 cm3 1.065 (0.425–2.335) 0.88

  Edema index

   <10 Ref Ref

   >10 0.418 (0.023–1.947) 0.32

  Lesion location

   Cerebral hemispheres 3.767 (0.810–67.015) 0.10

   Other Ref Ref

SRS dose, Gy 0.933 (0.728–1.258) 0.62

Tumor response at 1.5 mos 0.138 (0.055–0.308) <0.001 0.144 (0.053–0.359) <0.001

Edema response at 1.5 mos 0.219 (0.091–0.476) <0.001 0.297 (0.116–0.703) 0.005

Tumor response at 3 mos 0.298 (0.131–0.675) 0.004 0.867 (0.346–2.120) 0.76

Edema response at 3 mos 0.248 (0.106–0.558) <0.001 0.443 (0.176–1.066) 0.07
*

Due to collinearity between model terms, these risk factors were analyzed separately.