Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 21;10:1400. doi: 10.3389/fonc.2020.01400

Table 1.

Characteristics of included studies.

Reference Study type Study region Ethnicity Sample size Treatment Evaluated cells Cutoff value for PD-L1 Positive PD-L1 (%) Median follow-up (months) Survival
Skala et al. (24) RC USA Caucasus 149 RNU: all; AC: 17 (11.4%); NC: 18 (12.1%); immunotherapy: N.R. Tumor cells (PD-L1) ≥5% 23.5 24.8 CSS
Krabbe et al. (15) RC USA Caucasus 423 (high-grade UTUC) RNU: all; AC, NC, immunotherapy: none Tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (PD-1) and tumor cells (PD-L1) ≥1% 26.2 37.0 OS, CSS, RFS
Zhang et al. (13) RC China Asian 162 RNU: all; AC, NC: N.R. immunotherapy: none PD-L1 in tumor cells and TIMCs ≥5% 12.3 79.0 CSS
Miyama et al. (16) RC Japan Asian 271 RNU: all; AC, NC: N.R. immunotherapy: N.R. Circulating platelets and tumor cells (PD-L1) ≥5% 11.0 52.0 OS, MFS
Arriola et al. (23) RC USA Caucasus 72 RNU: all; AC, immunotherapy: N.R.; NC: none Tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (PD-1) and tumor cells (PD-L1) ≥1% 37.5 98.7 OS, CSS
Wang et al. (25) RC China Asian 88 RNU: all; AC: 8 (9.1%); NC, immunotherapy: N.R. Tumor cells (PD-L1/2) ≥1% 23.9 23.0 OS, CSS
Nukui et al. (17) RC Japan Asian 79 RNU: all; AC: 41 (51.9%); NC, immunotherapy: N.R. Tumor cells and TILs (PD-L1) ≥5% 39.2 45.0 OS, CSS
Kim et al. (14) RC Korea Asian 162 (non-metastatic UTUC) RNU: all; AC: 72 (44.4%); NC: none; immunotherapy: N.R. Tumor cells (PD-L1) ≥5% 3.086 53.4 OS, CSS

RC, retrospective cohort study; RNU, radical nephroureterectomy; AC, adjuvant chemotherapy; NC, neoadjuvant chemotherapy; OS, overall survival; CSS, cancer-specific survival; IHC, immunohistochemistry staining; MFS, metastasis-free survival; RFS, recurrence-free survival; N.R., not reported.