Table A2.
Type of Sensor | Group, Year | Description | Micro-Structuring Technique | Sensitivity (kPa−1), Range of Pressures (kPa) | LOD/Maximum Pressure Tested | Res./Rel. Times (ms) | Stability | Operating Voltage/Energy Consumption | Application |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
C | Z. Bao [24] 2010 | OFET, whose dielectric layer is PDMS with micro-pyramids (6 µm of width). | Photolit. | 0.55 (0–2) | 3 Pa/ 40 kPa |
<300/ <500 |
104 (L) 15,000 (B) |
- 20 V/- | |
C | Z. Bao [84] 2011 | Ecoflex, and elec. of SWCNTs on PDMS. | - | 2.23 × 10−4 (50–1000) |
50 kPa/ 1 MPa |
<125/ <125 |
4 (L) 4 (S) |
-/- | |
C | Z. Bao [30] 2013 | OTFT, whose dielectric layer is PDMS with triangular lines (7 µm of width, 7 µm of height). | Photolit. | 8.2 (0–8) 0.38 (8–50) |
~ 200 Pa/ 56 kPa |
<1/<10 | 15,000 (L) | - 100 V/1 mW | (♡) |
C | D. Zhu [276] 2015 | Flexible suspended gate OTFT. | - | 192 (0.1–5) | 0.3 Pa/ 5 kPa |
<10/<10 | 105 (L) | - 60 V/<1 mW | (♡) |
C | Y. Hong [75] 2015 | PMMA or PVP, and elec. of PDMS micro-structures (6 µm of height) coated with Ag NWs, and Ag on arylite. | UV/O3 treatment | 3.8 (0.045–0.5) 0.8 (0.5–2.5) 0.35 (2.5–4.5) |
45 Pa/ 10 kPa |
<150/ <150 |
1500 (L) 5000 (B) |
0.1 V/- | |
C | Z. Bao [165] 2015 | PDMS pyramids (6 µm of width, 3 µm of height), PDMS microhairs (30 µm of diameter, AR of 3, 6, and 10), and elec. of PEN and Au. | Photolit. | 0.55–0.58 (0–1) | ~ 100 Pa/ 10 kPa |
-/<30 | 3000 (L) | 1 V/- | (♡) |
C | S. P. Lacour [36] 2015 | Porous silicone foam with Au elec. | Foam | 1 × 10−2–1 × 10−3 (5–405) |
2 kPa/ 405 kPa |
7/14 | 250,000 (L) | -/- | |
C | S.-D. Lee [72] 2016 | Porous PDMS between glass or PET, and ITO elec. | Water mixing and heat | 1.18 (0–0.02) | 20 Pa/ 5 kPa |
150/150 | - | -/- | |
C | P. Zhu [82] 2017 | PVDF dielectric layer, PDMS waves (2.6 µm of width, 800 nm of height), with Ag NWs as elec. | Stretching and plasma treatment | 2.94 ± 0.25 (0–2) 0.75 ± 0.06 (2–6.7) |
3 Pa/ 6.7 kPa |
<50/<50 | 103 (L) 103 (B) |
-/- | () |
C | C. F. Guo [43] 2018 | Ionic gel [P(VDF-HFP) and IL] micro-cones (25 µm of height), with elec. of Ag NWs on PI. | Leaf as mold | 54.31 (0–0.5) 30.11 (0.5–10) 8.42 (10–40) 1.03 (40–115) |
0.1 Pa/ 115 kPa |
29/37 | 5400 (L) | -/- | () |
C | C. F. Guo [173] 2018 | PDMS micro-towers (6.5 µm of diameter, 14 µm of height) covered with Ag NWs, and Ag NWs on PI. | Lotus leave as mold | 1.194 (0–2) 0.077 (2–13) |
0.8 Pa/ 13 kPa |
36/58 | 105 (L) | -/- | () |
C | Z. L. Wang [273] 2018 | Ecoflex, and Ag elec. | - | 0.0224 (0–16) 1.25 × 10−3 (16–360) |
7.3 Pa/ 360 kPa |
-/- | - | -/- | |
C | C. F. Guo [277] 2018 | Rose petal or leaf, or Acacia Mill leaf, with elec. of Ag NWs on PI. | Rose petals and plants leaves | 1.54 (0–1) 0.068 (1–40) 0.014 (40–115) |
0.6 Pa/ 115 kPa |
-/- | 5000 (L) 5000 (B) |
-/- | () |
C | V. Palaniappan [251] 2019 | PDMS micro-pyramids, with elec. of Ag on PET, in interlocked design. | Laser engraved mold | 2.2 × 10−3 (0.075–0.17) |
75 Pa/ 170 Pa |
-/- | - | -/- | (♡) |
C | G. Xing [199] 2019 | Polyurethane sponge covered with a composite of silicone rubber, MWCNTs, and graphene nanoplates. | Sponge | 0.062 (0–0.3) 0.033 (0.3–4.5) |
3 Pa/ 4.5 kPa |
45/83 | 2000 (L) | -/- | (♡ ) |
C | J. Y. Park [33] 2019 | Ionic gel [P(VDF-HFP) and IL] micro-structures (26 µm of size), with elec. of Ag NWs on PDMS. | Sandpaper as mold | 131.5 (0–1.5) 11.73 (5–28) |
1.12 Pa/ 32 kPa |
43/71 | 7000 (L) | 0.5 V/- | (♡) |
C | R.-W. Li [86] 2020 | Micro-needles (diameter between 166 µm and 422 µm, height between 275 µm and 856 µm) of PDMS and Ni-coated magnetic particles of Ag. | Self-assembly | 0.159 (0–1) 0.019 (1.5–11) 4.1 × 10−3 (12–145) |
1.9 Pa/ 145 kPa |
49/51 | 9200 (L) | -/- | () |
C | C. F. Guo [171] 2020 | Iontronic protrusions, and elec. of Au on PI. | Sandpaper as mold | 3302.9 (0–10) 671.7 (10–100) 229.9 (100–360) |
0.08 Pa/ 360 kPa |
9/18 | 5000 (L) 2000 (B) |
-/- | (♡) |
C | M. Zhang [278] 2020 | Parylene with elec. of Au-coated PDMS micro-pyramids (35 µm of width, 24.7 µm of height) and ITO on PET. | Photolit. | 70.6 (0–0.05) 3.3 (0.05–0.325) |
1 Pa/ 325 Pa |
-/- | 10,200 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
C | T. Lee [177] 2020 | PDMS hierarchical interlocked micro-structures, with elec. of ITO on PET. | Rose petals as mold | 0.055 (2–10) | -/10 kPa | 300/250 | - | 1 V/- | (♡) |
C or PR | S. Park [85] 2019 | Porous PDMS micro-pyramids (50 µm of width), with elec. of ITO on PET (for C sensor), or covered with PPy, with patterned elec. (for PR sensor). | Photolit. | 44.5 (0–0.1) (C) 449 (0–0.01) (PR) |
0.14 Pa/ 35 kPa (C) or 600 Pa (PR) |
50/100 (C) 9/30 (PR) |
5000 (L) (C) | 1 V/- (C, PR) | (♡) |
PE | J. A. Rogers [104] 2013 | Aligned fiber of P(VDF-TrFE). | Electrospin. | 0.79 V kPa−1 (0–0.012) 1.1 V kPa−1 (0.4–2) |
0.1 Pa/ 2 kPa |
-/- | 103 (B) | -/- | |
PE | J. A. Rogers [90] 2014 | Array of PZT squares connected to the gate elec. of a MOSFET. | - | 2 µA Pa−1 (0.002–0.01) |
0.005 Pa/ 10 Pa |
0.1/- | 103 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
PE | N.-E. Lee [106] 2015 | OFET array with P(VDF-TrFE) micro-pyramids (4 µm of width, 2.5 µm of height) as gate dielectric. | Photolit. | 1.016 (0.02–0.08) 0.028 (10–100) |
20 Pa/ 20 kPa |
20/- | 104 (B) | -/10 µW | (♡) |
PE | K. J. Lee [89] 2017 | PZT thin film on PET, with elec. of Au. | - | 0.018 (1–30) | 1 kPa/ 60 kPa |
60/- | 5 000 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
PE | Q.-L. Zhao [91] 2017 | PZT NWs on planar interdigitated Pt/Ti elec. | - | 0.14 V kPa−1 (15–70) |
15 kPa/ 70 kPa |
-/- | 105 (L) | -/- | - |
PE | D. Mandal [279] 2017 | Fish gelatin nanofibers. | Electrospin. | 0.8 V kPa−1 (0.3–10) |
2 Pa/ 25 kPa |
16/- | 108,000 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
PE | D. Mandal [272] 2017 | Electrospun PLLA nanofibers. | Electrospin. | 3 V kPa−1 | 18 Pa/ 300 kPa |
-/- | 375,000 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
PR | K.-Y. Suh [131] 2012 | Interlocked array of PU nanohairs (50 nm of diameter, 1 µm of height) coated with Pt. | Photolit. | - | 5 Pa/ 1.5 kPa |
50/- | 8000 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
PR | J.-J. Park [125] 2014 | PDMS micro-pyramids (8 µm of width, 4 µm of height) covered with PEDOT:PSS/PUD. | Photolit. | 4.88 (0.37–5.9) | 23 Pa/ 8 kPa |
200/200 | 800 (S) | 0.2 V/- | (♡) |
PR | X. Chen [126] 2014 | PDMS micro-pyramids (4.5 µm of width) covered with rGO and elec. of ITO on PET. | Photolit. | −5.5 (0–0.1) −0.01 (0.1–1.5) |
1.5 Pa/ 1.5 kPa |
0.2/- | 5000 (L) | 1 V/- | - |
PR | W. Cheng [38] 2014 | PDMS microdomains (18 µm of diameter, 16 µm of height) covered with Au. | Mimosa leaves as mold | 50.17 (0–0.07) 1.38 (0.2–1.5) 0.04 (2–10) |
10.4 Pa/ 10 kPa |
20/- | 104 (L) 5000 (B) |
0.1 V/- | |
PR | W. Cheng [217] 2014 | Interdigitated elec. on PDMS sheet with Au NWs coated tissue paper. | Fabric | 1.14 (0–5) | 13 Pa/ 5 kPa |
-/17 | 50,000 (L) 5000 (B) |
1.5 V/30 µW | (♡) |
PR | X. Chen [127] 2014 | Silicon micropillars (20 µm of diameter, 17 µm of height) covered with Au, and a PPy film on PDMS. | Photolit. | −1.8 (0–0.35) | 2 Pa/ 10 kPa |
<100/ <100 |
- | -/- | - |
PR | D.-H. Kim [42] 2014 | Porous MWCNTs@PDMS with elec. of conductive carbon fabric. | Reverse micelles | - | 250 Pa/ 260 kPa |
-/- | 16 (L) | 0.1 V/1 W | |
PR | Z. Bao [41] 2014 | ITO on PET and Cu foil as elec. and interconnected hollow-sphere structures of PPy hydrogel micro-structured into triangular lines (0.5 mm in height, 1 mm of width). | Photolit. | 56–133.1 (0–0.030) | 0.8 Pa/ 10 kPa |
50/50 | 8000 (L) | -/- | |
PR | D.-H. Kim [35] 2014 | Single crystalline silicon nanoribbon with linear or serpentine shapes. | - | 4.1 × 10−3 (0–200) | -/200 kPa | -/- | - | -/- | |
PR | H. Ko [133] 2014 | Interlocked array of MWCNTs@PDMS microdomes (4 µm of diameter, 3 µm of height). | Photolit. | −15.1 (0–0.5) | 0.23 Pa/ 59 kPa |
40/40 | 103 (L) | 10 V/- | () |
PR | H. Ko [132] 2014 | Interlocked array of MWCNTs@PDMS micropillars (5 µm of diameter, 6 µm of height) with Cu elec. | Photolit. | −22.8 (0–0.05) | 10 Pa/ 17 kPa |
110/130 | - | 10 V/- | |
PR | T. Zhang [179] 2014 | PDMS with micro-structures (11 µm of width, 3.2 µm of height) covered with SWCNTs. | Silk as mold | 1.8 (0–0.3) | 0.6 Pa/ 1 kPa |
10/- | 67,500 (L) | 2 V/- | (♡) |
PR | T.-L. Ren [280] 2015 | Carbon black@rubber micro-structures (17 µm of height) with Cu elec. | Abrasive grains as mold | 13.8 (0–14.5) | <1 kPa/ 14 kPa |
23/- | 400 (L) | -/- | - |
PR | J. S. Ha [31] 2015 | PDMS micropillars (50 µm of diameter, 48 µm of height) covered with Au, and PANI fibers on PET. | Photolit. | 2 (0–0.22) 0.87 (0.22–1) |
15 Pa/ 9 kPa |
50/- | 104 (L) | 1 V/- | (♡) |
PR | T.-L. Ren [274] 2015 | Two interlocked films of graphene micro-structures (20 µm of width, 11 µm of height). | DVD laser-scribing | 0.96 (0–50) 5 × 10−3 (50–113) |
-/113 kPa | 72/0.4 | 102 (L) | -/- | |
PR | R. Jelinek [193] 2015 | Au-coated amine-functionalized PU sponge with Cu elec. | Sponge | −0.31 (0–2) −0.02 (2–10) |
10 Pa/ 10 kPa |
8/- | 103 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
PR | K. Cho [139] 2016 | PDMS hierarchical micro-domes (59 µm of diameter) with interdigitated graphene elec. | Photolit. | 8.5 (0–12) | 1 Pa/ 12 kPa |
40/30 | 104 (L) | 1 V/- | (♡) |
PR | N. Zhao [32] 2016 | Nonwoven wood pulp/polyester textile with carbon black particles, and elec. of Au on PI. | Fabric | 0.585 (0–35) | -/35 kPa | 4/4 | 5800 (L) | 1 mV/3 nW | (♡) |
PR | T. Liu [275] 2016 | Graphitic structures in PI. | Direct laser writing | - | -/- | -/- | 104 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
PR | Y.-F. Chen [271] 2016 | Ag NWs@PDMS, and conductive threads as bottom elec. in a cloth substrate. | - | 1.04 × 104–9.3 × 105 (0–0.1) 2.72 × 106–6.57 × 106 (0.38–3) |
0.6 Pa/ 5 kPa |
4/16 | 5000 (L) | 0.1 V/- | () |
PR | H. Zhang [232] 2017 | PDMS sponge covered with CNTs, with elec. of ITO on PET. | Cube sugar as template | 0.03 (0–15) 4.8 × 10−3 (25–50) |
26 Pa/ 150 kPa |
300/100 | 2000 (L) | 2 V/- | (♡) |
PR | B. Yu [19] 2017 | PDMS micro-pyramids (10 µm of width, height) covered with MWCNTs, and elec. of Au/Ni on PET. | Photolit. | −9.95 (0–0.1) −1.5 × 10−2 (0.175–0.6) |
20 Pa/ 600 Pa |
<200/- | 20 (L) | 1 V/- | - |
PR | Y. Lin [129] 2017 | PDMS micro-pyramids (11 µm of width, 7.4 µm of height) covered with SWCNTs, and elec. of ITO on PET. | Photolit. | 2760 (0–0.4) 8656 (0.4–0.9) 1875 (0.9–1.2) |
7.3 Pa/ 1.2 kPa |
<4/- | 104 (L) | 30 V/26.4 nW | (♡) |
PR | N.-J. Cho [140] 2017 | MWCNTs@PDMS@Sunflower pollen microcapsules, film of PDMS with micro-cubes (150 µm of width), and Cu elec. | Nylon mesh as mold | 56.36 (0–1) 2.51 (2–10) |
1.6 Pa/ 10 kPa |
500/300 | 25,000 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
PR | S. Jeon [161] 2017 | PDMS micro-pyramids (20 µm of width) covered with PEDOT:PSS/PUD + Ag NPs. | Photolit. | 2.5 (0–0.25) | 3 Pa/5 kPa | 20/20 | 105 (L) | 0.5 mV/- | (♡) |
PR | M. Khine [183] 2017 | Interlocked design of PDMS films covered with wrinkled CNT film. | Heat and shrinking | 278.5 (0–0.002) 13.2 (0.002–0.025) |
0.5 Pa/ 12 kPa |
<20/- | 500 (L) | 1 V/- | (♡) |
PR | Z. Tang [189] 2017 | Wrinkled graphene films separated by a layer of porous anodic Al oxide. | Chemical synthesis | 6.92 (0.3–1.5) 0.14 (1.5–4.5) |
300 Pa/ 8 kPa |
-/- | 105 (L) | 1 V/- | - |
PR | G. Shen [239] 2017 | Film of PANI hollow nanospheres (≈ 414 µm of diameter), MWCNTs, and PVDF, sandwiched between elec. of Au on PDMS. | PS spheres as template | 31.6 (0–0.25) 10.61 (1–7) |
0.6 Pa/ 50 kPa |
100/150 | 15,000 (L) | 1 V/- | (♡) |
PR | N. Zhao [281] 2017 | Fibers of nylon covered with Cu and doped with carbon black particles and PVDF, with interdigitated elec. of Au on PI. | Nylon fibers | ≈ 1 (0–70) | -/60 kPa | 2/2 | 22,000 (L) | 1 V/- | (♡) |
PR | J. Sun [270] 2017 | PDMS mountain (220 µm of width, 30 µm of height) with secondary (35 µm of width, 12 µm of height) and tertiary ridges, and Ag elec. | Banana leave as mold | 10 (0–0.4) 3.3 (0.4–1) 0.33 (1–7) |
1 Pa/7 kPa | 36/30 | 104 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
PR | R. Igreja [22] 2018 | PDMS micro-cones (221 µm to 367 µm of diameter, 299 µm to 552 µm of height) covered with carbon coating. | Laser engraving | −2.52 (0–0.16) −0.2 (0.2–1.2) −0.01 (1.6–9) |
15 Pa/ 9 kPa |
20/- | - | 1 V/- | (♡) |
PR | T. Zhang [156] 2018 | Micro-pyramids (≈ 20 µm of width) of PDMS covered with SWCNTs with a substrate of PEN. | Photolit. | −3.26 (0–0.3) −0.025 (0.6–2.5) |
-/2.5 kPa | 200/100 | 5000 (L) | 10 V/- | (♡) |
PR | H. Ko [136] 2018 | MWCNTs@PDMS interlocked micro-domes, micro-pyramids, or micro-pillars (10 µm of diameter/width, 6 µm of height), with Cu elec. | Photolit. | 47 × 103 (0–1) 90 × 103 (1–10) 30 × 103 (10–26) (Micro-domes) |
0.09 Pa/ 26 kPa |
12/12 | 103 (L) | 0.1 V/- | (♡) |
PR | W. Yang [39] 2018 | Two micro-structured PDMS films covered with Ag NWs in an interlocked design. | Emery paper as mold | 9.8 × 104 (0–0.2) 3.5 × 103 (0.2–20) |
5 Pa/ 20 kPa |
<62.5/ <62.5 |
103 (L) | 0.1 V/1.5 nW | () |
PR | J. Yao [190] 2018 | ZnO NWs sea-urchin like aggregates, between elec. of ITO on PET. | Chemical synthesis | 75–121 (0–0.2) >15 (0.2–10) |
0.015 Pa/ 10 kPa |
7/9 | 2000 (L) | 5 V/- | (♡) |
PR | Y. Gao [205] 2018 | Carbonized melamine foam. | Foam | 100.29 (0.003–2) 21.22 (2–10) |
3 Pa/ 10 kPa |
-/- | 11,000 (L) | 0.1 V/ - | (♡) |
PR | S. J. Oh [191] 2018 | Conductive Ag nanocrystals on a PDMS film with triangular lines (1 mm of width, 0.5 mm of height), with spacers of insulating Ag nanocrystals. | Self-assembly | 2.72 × 104 (0–5) 4.70 × 103 (5–20) 1.09 × 102 (20–100) |
10 Pa/ 100 kPa |
200/50 | 200 (L) | 0.001 V/ <100 nW |
(♡) |
PR | X. Peng [229] 2018 | Carbon aerogel with cellulose nanocrystals with elec. of Ni on PET. | Freeze-drying | 103.5 (0–0.01) 27.5 (0.01–18) |
1 Pa/ 18 kPa |
-/- | 50,000 (L) | 1 V/- | (♡) |
PR | Y. Fan [282] 2018 | Carbonized lignin@PDMS. | - | 57 (0–2) | 500 Pa/ 130 kPa |
60/40 | 105 (L) | 1 V/- | (♡) |
PR | S. Shiratori [143] 2018 | Two PDMS films micro-structured into fish-scales (0.62 µm of height), covered with PEDOT:PSS and graphene nanosheets, facing each other. | Surface tension | −70.86 (0–1) −1.15 (2–5) |
100 Pa/ 5 kPa |
82.6/- | - | -/- | (♡) |
PR | Y.-J. Yang [181] 2018 | MWCNTs@PDMS interlocked micro-domes (3 µm of diameter), with Au elec. | Nylon membrane filter as mold | −6.08 (0–0.15) | -/8.5 kPa | -/- | 104 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
PR | F. Xuan [37] 2018 | Triangular lines of PDMS (10 µm to 14 µm of width, 28 µm to 39 µm of height) covered with CNTs as bottom elec., and smooth PDMS covered with CNTs as top elec. | Laser engraving | −0.11 (0.005–2) −1.28 × 10−3 (10–50) |
5 Pa/ 50 kPa |
200/150 | 104 (L) | 1 V/- | (♡) |
PR | L. Li [283] 2018 | Pyramid-like structures (4 µm of height) of MWCNTs@PDMS, with an elec. of Au and other of ITO on PET. | Silicon as mold | 474 (0–0.4) 14.7 (0.4–1.4) 8.4 (5–110) |
0.6 Pa/ 110 kPa |
0.002/ 0.074 |
103 (L) | 1 V–5 V/- | (♡) |
PR | N. Liu [284] 2018 | NWs of PVA sandwiched between interdigitated elec. of Ag/Ni and a wrinkled rGO film. | - | 4.52 (0–3) 28.34 (3–10) |
2.24 Pa/ 14 kPa |
87–155/- | 6000 (L) | 0.1 V/- | (♡) |
PR | L. Li [285] 2018 | Micro-pyramids of PDMS covered with PPy, with co-planar Au elec. | Photolit. | 1907.2 (0–0.1) 461.5 (0.1–1) 230.1 (1–1.9) |
0.08 Pa/ 1.9 kPa |
0.05/6.2 | 15,000 (L) | 1 V/- | (♡) |
PR | J. Li [195] 2018 | Sea sponges with polydopamine, rGO, and Ag NWs. | Sponge | 0.016 (0–40) | 0.28 Pa/ 40 kPa |
-/54 | 7000 (L) | -/- | () |
PR | T.-L. Ren [168] 2018 | Micro-structures of PDMS coated with rGO, in interlocked geometry. | Sandpaper as mold | 25.1 (0–2.6) 0.45 (10–40) |
16 Pa/ 40 kPa |
120/80 | 3000 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
PR | R. Igreja [247] 2019 | PDMS semi-spheres (320 µm to 340 µm of diameter, 105 µm to 155 µm of height) coated with carbon coating. | Laser engraving | −0.18 (0–0.4) −6.4 × 10−3 (1.2–100) |
79 Pa/ 100 kPa |
-/28 | 27,500 (L) | 5 V–10 V/- | |
PR | W. Lu [182] 2019 | Micro-structured PDMS covered with graphene, with interdigitated elec. of Ni/Au. | Silk as mold | 1875.5 (0–20) 853.2 (20–40) |
1.8 Pa/ 40 kPa |
2/3 | 15,000 (L) | 1 V/- | (♡) |
PR | X. Wang [286] 2019 | PDMS with graphene protrusions. | Laser scribing | 480 (0–0.1) 34 (0.1–0.4) 0.9 (0.4–1) |
28 Pa/ 1 kPa |
0.002/ 0.002 |
4000 (L) | 5 V/160 µW | (♡) |
PR | D. Zeng [130] 2019 | PDMS micro-structures (250 µm, 60 µm, or 15 µm as average height) covered with rGO, with elec. of Au on PI. | Sandpaper as mold | 2.5 (0–1) 12 (1–50) 1051 (50–200)470 (200–400) |
10 Pa/ 400 kPa |
150/40 | 104 (L) | 1 V/- | (♡) |
PR | V. Roy [170] 2019 | Micro-structured foam (top and bottom sides) of PDMS and graphite, with elec. of ITO on PET. | Sandpaper as mold | 245 (0–120) 90 (120–150) |
5 Pa/ 150 kPa |
8/4 | 25,000 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
PR | Z. Peng [144] 2019 | Porous matrix of TPU@NaCl@carbon black particles, with elec. of TPU@Ag particles. | 3D printed mold | 5.54 (0–10) 0.123 (10–100) 4.8 × 10−3 (100–800) |
10 Pa/ 800 kPa |
20/30 | 104 (L) | 0.3 V/- | (♡) |
PR | C. Yang [287] 2019 | Au-coated PDMS conical frustum-like structures, with interdigitated elec. of SnSe2 nanoplates covered with Au. | Photolit. | 433.22 (0–2.4) 2.91 (5–40) |
0.82 Pa/ 40 kPa |
0.07/0.09 | 4000 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
PR | F. Xuan [250] 2019 | PDMS long or short micro-ridges (19.1 µm of width, 20.2 µm of height, 1 mm or 100.5 µm of length), or micro-domes (22.8 µm of diameter, 19.5 µm of height) covered with CNTs. | Laser engraving | −1.82 (0–2) −9.1 × 10−4 (10–80) |
1 Pa/ 80 kPa |
36/52 | 6000 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
PR | W. Huang [212] 2019 | Ag interdigitated elec. on cellulose paper, and porous tissue paper coated with Ag NWs. | Tissue paper | 1.5 (0.03–30) | 30 Pa/ 30 kPa |
90/90 | - | 0.1 V/10 nW | (♡) |
PR | Y. Tian [288] 2019 | PDMS micro-pillars (500 µm of diameter, 200 µm of height) covered with Ag NWs in interlocked array. | Photolit. | 20.08 (0.05–0.8) 3.81 (0.8–2.1) |
20 Pa/ 8 kPa |
-/- | 104 (L) | 1 V/- | () |
PR | C. Pang [164] 2019 | PDMS film with micro-pillars on top (30 µm of diameter, 15 µm or 30 µm of height) and hexagonal structures on bottom (200 µm of width, AR of 1.5), and elec. of graphene on PDMS. | Photolit. | 0.015 (0–8) 2 × 10−4 (8–20) |
20 Pa/ 370 kPa |
11/5 | 103 (L) | -/- | - |
PR | B. Zhou [252] 2019 | PDMS micro-domes (1000 µm of diameter) with hierarchical pillars (50 µm of diameter), covered with Ag NWs, in interlocked geometry. | Laser cutting and Photolit. | 374.5 (0–0.3) 3.86 (0.3–20) 0.63 (20–80) |
2.5 Pa/ 80 kPa |
-/- | 104 (L) | 1 V/- | (♡) |
PR | P. Liu [244] 2020 | NaOH modified tissue paper with silicon rubber, carbon black, and graphene nanoplates as active layer, silicon rubber micro-domes, and interdigitated elec. of Au on PI. | 3D printed mold and tissue paper | 37.5 (0–2) 2.75 (2–10) |
5 Pa/ 10 kPa |
50/30 | 3000 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
PR | T. Zhang [253] 2020 | PDMS semi-spheres (280 µm of diameter, 200 µm of height) with micro-structures covered with rGO, with interdigitated elec. of Ag NWs. | Laser engraving | 15.4 (0–200) | 16 Pa/ 300 kPa |
15/20 | 7500 (L) | 1 V/- | (♡) |
PR & PE | H. Ko [87] 2015 | Interlocked array of PDMS micropillars (10 µm of diameter, 10 µm of height) covered with ZnO NWs (coated with Pt or Ni). | Photolit. | −6.8 (0–0.3) −1 × 10−2 (0.3–4.6) −6.78 × 10−5 (4.6–13.1) |
0.6 Pa/ 13 kPa |
5/- | 103 (L) | 10 V/- | |
PR & PE | H. Ko [88] 2015 | Interlocked array of rGO@PVDF microdomes (10 µm of diameter, 4 µm of height). | Photolit. | - | 0.6 Pa/ 49.5 kPa |
-/- | 5000 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
PR & PE | J. Jang [99] 2016 | ZnO NRs covered with PVDF, and elec. of rGO. | Chemical synthesis | - | 4 Pa/20 Pa | 120/- | 103 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
TE | Z. L. Wang [150] 2013 | PDMS film with micro-pyramids (10 µm of width), with an elec. of Au and another elec. of Al with Ag NWs and NPs. | Photolit. | 0.31 (0–3) 0.01 (3–12) |
2.1 Pa/ 12 kPa |
<5/<5 | 30,000 (L) | -/- | |
TE | Z. L. Wang [153] 2016 | PET film, a micro-structured PDMS film, and Ag elec. | Dry etching | 0.06 (1–80) | 1 kPa/ 200 kPa |
70/- | 104 (L) | -/- | |
TE | L. Wang [269] 2016 | Rough PET (40 µm of dimension, 0.8 µm of depth) coated with Al, and elec. of Al on PTFE. | Chemical etching | - | - | 1/- | - | -/- | (♡) |
TE | Z. L. Wang [154] 2017 | PDMS film with micro-pyramids (80 µm of width), Ag elec., and SiO2 as insulator. | Photolit. | 6 × 10−3 (0–40) | 600 Pa/ 200 kPa |
50/- | - | -/- | |
TE | S.-W. Kim [289] 2017 | Transistor with an ion-gel gate dielectric. | - | 0.02 (0–10) | <1 kPa/ 57 kPa |
30/- | 1700 (L) | 0.5 V/180 µW | |
TE | Y. Zhang [290] 2017 | PDMS film with elec. of carbon fiber. | - | 0.055 nA kPa−1 (28.2–41.6) | 800 Pa/ 41.6 kPa |
68/- | 104 (L) | -/- | |
TE | Z. L. Wang [291] 2017 | PDMS or VHB, and hydrogel of polyacrylamide with LiCl as elec. | - | 0.013 (1.3–70) | 1.3 kPa/ 100 kPa |
-/- | 20,000 (L) 103 (S) |
-/- | |
TE | Z. L. Wang [20] 2018 | Silk, nylon, and an elec. of CNTs. | Fabric | 0.0479 (0–125) 0.0186 (125–350) 0.0033 (350–650) |
-/650 kPa | -/- | 104 (L) | -/- | |
TE | H. Ko [147] 2018 | P(VDF-TrFE) and PDMS films with interlocked semi-spheres (100 µm of diameter, 120 µm of height). | Photolit. | 0.55 V kPa−1 (0–19.8) 0.2 V kPa−1 (19.8–98) |
-/98 kPa | -/- | 104 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
TE | Z. L. Wang [40] 2018 | Ecoflex with triangular microprisms (1.24 mm of width, 1.64 mm of height), with an elec. of Ag flakes on ecoflex. | Laser grinding machine | 0.29 (0–5) 0.005 (5–25) |
63 Pa/ 320 kPa |
-/- | 103 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
TE | Z. L. Wang [265] 2018 | PTFE strips with NWs (110 nm of diameter, 0.8 µm of height), with interlaced woven structure on PET, and ITO elec. | Plasma dry etching | 45.7 V kPa−1 (0–0.71) 10.6 V kPa−1 (0.71–1.25) |
2.5 Pa/ 1.25 kPa |
5/- | 40,000 (L) | -/- | (♡) |
TE | J. Zhou [292] 2018 | EVA/Ag film with hollow micro-spheres (750 µm of diameter, 300 µm of height) in both surfaces, with an outer sheet of FEP/Ag. | Hot pressing | 18.98 V kPa−1 (0.5–1) 0.77 V kPa−1 (1.6–10) 0.25 V kPa−1 (10–40) |
500 Pa/ 40 kPa |
-/- | - | -/- | (♡) |
TE | Z. L. Wang [176] 2019 | Two PDMS films with micro-cones (25.4 µm of diameter, 25.7 µm of height) in interlocked geometry, one covered with Ag NWs and the other covered with PTFE bumps, and a back elec. | Leaf as mold | 127.22 V kPa−1 (5–50) |
5 kPa/ 50 kPa |
-/- | 5000 (L) | -/- | |
TE | X. Chou [293] 2020 | PDMS micro-frustum film (14 µm of width, 5 µm of height) covered with Cu with another PDMS micro-frustum film covered with P(VDF-TrFE) in interlocked geometry, and a spacer. | Photolit. | 56.7 mV kPa−1 (0–600) 15.6 mV kPa−1 (700–1000) |
-/1 MPa | 60/- | 80,000 (L) | -/- | (♡) |