Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 4;15(9):e0238716. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0238716

Table 5. The impact of different mulch types and winter crops on chemical properties of soil.

Mulch types 2016–17 2017–18
Wheat Egyptian clover Canola Wheat Egyptian clover Canola
Electric conductivity (dS m-1)
CIM-616* 5.357 abc 5.407 ab 5.340 bcd 5.307 abc 5.317 ab 5.247 bcd
GH-Mubarik* 5.367 abc 5.433 a 5.400 ab 5.300 abcd 5.357 a 5.323 ab
CIM-620** 5.267 d 5.343 bcd 5.303 cd 5.217 d 5.283 abcd 5.230 cd
N-414** 5.290 cd 5.333 bcd 5.290 cd 5.240 bcd 5.257 bcd 5.227 cd
LSD (p ≤ 0.05) 0.087 0.084
pH
CIM-616* 8.32 a 8.29 ab 8.24 ab 8.25 ab 8.23 abc 8.19 bc
GH-Mubarik* 8.32 a 8.29 ab 8.24 ab 8.26 a 8.24 abc 8.22 abc
CIM-620** 8.24 ab 8.27 ab 8.22 b 8.22 abc 8.22 abc 8.17 c
N-414** 8.27 ab 8.26 ab 8.29 ab 8.23 abc 8.24 ab 8.25 ab
LSD (p ≤ 0.05) 0.08 0.07
Available nitrogen (mg kg-1)
CIM-616* 0.080 ab 0.073 abcd 0.073 abcd 0.087 a 0.080 ab 0.073 bc
GH-Mubarik* 0.070 bcd 0.063 cd 0.063 cd 0.080 ab 0.067 c 0.063 c
CIM-620** 0.087 a 0.077 abc 0.073 abcd 0.087 a 0.080 ab 0.073 bc
N-414** 0.077 abc 0.067 bcd 0.060 d 0.087 a 0.070 bc 0.067 c
LSD (p ≤ 0.05) 0.016 0.013
Available phosphorous (mg kg-1)
CIM-616* 9.66 abc 9.70 a 9.62 abcd 9.85 a 9.75 bcd 9.70 cd
GH-Mubarik* 9.68 ab 9.69 ab 9.65 abc 9.70 cd 9.73 bcd 9.67 d
CIM-620** 9.61 bcd 9.65 abc 9.58 cde 9.70 cd 9.76 bc 9.67 d
N-414** 9.55 de 9.67 ab 9.53 e 9.86 a 9.75 bc 9.79 ab
LSD (p ≤ 0.05) 0.08 0.08
Available potassium (mg kg-1)
CIM-616* 199 abcd 203 a 201 abc 202 203 204
GH-Mubarik* 200 abc 201 abc 196 cde 202 204 201
CIM-620** 197 bcde 202 ab 194 e 202 202 202
N-414** 197 bcde 201 ab 195 de 203 201 200
LSD (p ≤ 0.05) 4.87 NS
Available zinc (mg kg-1)
CIM-616* 0.77 abc 0.81 a 0.71 d 0.79 abc 0.82 a 0.76 c
GH-Mubarik* 0.78 ab 0.81 a 0.73 cd 0.81 ab 0.82 a 0.77 bc
CIM-620** 0.77 abc 0.79 a 0.73 cd 0.79 abc 0.80 ab 0.76 c
N-414** 0.77 abc 0.81 a 0.74 bcd 0.79 abc 0.81 ab 0.78 bc
LSD (p ≤ 0.05) 0.05 0.04
Available iron (mg kg-1)
CIM-616* 3.89 b 4.05 a 3.88 bc 3.92 c 4.11 a 3.90 c
GH-Mubarik* 3.82 bcd 4.00 a 3.75 de 3.86 c 4.02 b 3.86 c
CIM-620** 3.79 cde 3.99 a 3.71 e 3.89 c 4.03 b 3.86 c
N-414** 3.82 bcd 4.03 a 3.76 de 3.94 c 4.08 ab 3.89 c
LSD (p ≤ 0.05) 0.09 0.08

* = Bt cultivars

** = non-Bt cultivars, Means followed by varying letters for an experimental year differ at significantly (p ≤0.05) from each other, NS = Non-significant