Conventional PCR |
(i) Sensitive and specific |
(i) High risk of contamination |
[28, 33–35] |
(ii) Widely employed nucleic acid-based detection format |
(ii) Prone to inhibitors |
(iii) Multiplex detection potential |
(iii) Time-consuming and labor-intensive |
|
(iv) Qualitative |
|
(v) Requires thermal cycler and gel documentation apparatus |
|
Conventional RT-PCR |
(i) Sensitive and specific |
(i) RNA handling might be difficult |
[10, 14, 36–40] |
(ii) Multiplex detection potential |
(ii) High risk of contamination |
|
(iii) Time-consuming and cumbersome |
|
(iv) Relatively expensive |
|
(v) Prone to inhibitors |
|
(vi) Mutation within PCR primer regions may occur in some RNA viruses which have high mutation rates, leading to reduced sensitivity |
|
Real-time PCR/RT-qPCR |
(i) Highly sensitive and specific |
(i) Requires expensive laboratory equipment and fluorescent probe |
[33, 34, 39–41] |
(ii) Lower cross-contamination risk due to closed tube operation |
(ii) Designing of TaqMan probes requires almost complete information of the target nucleic acid sequence |
(iii) Rapid and less labor-intensive |
(iii) Primer dimer artifact is a problem in case of SYBR green method |
(iv) Multiplex detection |
(iv) Prone to inhibitors |
(v) Genotyping |
|
(vi) Determination of the viral load (quantitative) |
|
|
TMA + NASBA |
(i) Sensitive and specific |
(i) RNA handling might be difficult |
[36, 42–45] |
(ii) Simple and rapid (fewer cycles are required) |
(ii) Requirement of three enzymes in case of NASBA |
(iii) Multiplexing potential |
(iii) Use of enzymes that are not thermostable |
(iv) Quantification, |
(iv) Nonspecific interactions of the primers may increase as the amplification process occurs at a lower temperature (41°C) |
(v) Genotyping |
|
(vi) Does not require thermal cycler as the reaction takes place isothermally at 41°C |
|
|
LAMP/LAMP-RT |
(i) Highly sensitive and specific |
(i) Requirement of six primers |
[35, 46–49] |
(ii) Easy to perform |
(ii) High risk of carryover contamination |
(iii) Does not require expensive thermal cycler |
(iii) Limitation for multiplexing |
(iv) Rapid (results in <1 h) |
(iv) Visual detection using naked eye alone is subjective since it depends on observer's perception of color |
(v) Quantitative |
|
(vi) Genotyping |
|
(vii) Simple detection systems (using naked eye) |
|
(viii) Relatively resistant to inhibitors present in the sample |
|