Skip to main content
. 2020 Aug 11;13(16):3541. doi: 10.3390/ma13163541

Table 1.

Advantages and drawbacks of water, ecological, and carbon footprints.

Carbon Footprint Ecological Footprint Water Footprint
Advantages
  • enables a comprehensive assessment of greenhouse gas emissions;

  • complies with economic and environmental reporting standards;

  • includes the emissions of all gases showing greenhouse potential;

  • the emission data obtained are comparable and available to most countries.

  • enables comparative analysis of human demand for renewable resources and expresses human needs related to the absorption of emissions and waste concerning the “supply” of nature;

  • enables aggregated assessment of various anthropogenic impacts on the ecosystem;

  • is easy to communicate and understand, and contains a strong message about the protection of natural goods;

  • identifies human impact on Earth’s ecosystem and biodiversity and measures its negative impact.

  • expresses the need for water resources on a micro (product, technology, enterprise) and macro (region, country, planet) scale;

  • extends traditional water intake measurements, shows the relationship between local consumption and the global distribution of freshwater;

  • integrates water use and pollution in the production chain.

Drawbacks
  • focuses on only one category of environmental impact, omits other equally critical environmental aspects;

  • cannot follow the full range of human needs for the environment;

  • additional impact assessment models are needed to analyze the impact of climate change at national and subnational levels.

  • does not cover all aspects of sustainable development or all environmental issues; especially those for which there is no renewable potential;

  • shows which factors can lead to degradation of natural capital (e.g., reduced land quality or reduced biodiversity) but does not forecast such degradation;

  • is geographically ambiguous.

  • it only tracks human demand for freshwater;

  • relies on local data, often not available or difficult to obtain;

  • calculations for gray water are based on assumptions and estimations; depending on local water purity standards; calculations for gray water may be different for the same products or technologies in different regions.