Table 1.
Authors | Design | N Intervention | N Control | Coil Placement | Frequency | MT | Duration | Montage | # of sessions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(year) | Control | (mean age) | (mean age) | (Hz) | (%) | (min) | |||
Enticott et al.93 | - | 1(20) | – | mPFC | 5 | 1500 | 15 | Bilateral | 9 |
Niederhofer94 | - | 1(42) | – | SMA | 1 | 1200 | 60 | – | 5 |
Cristancho et al.95 | - | 1(15) | – | DLPC | 1 | 150–300 | Not reported | Unilateral | 36 (10 Right; 26 Left) |
Avirame et al.96 | - | 2 (27.5±2.5) | – | mPFC | 5 | 110 | 30 | Bilateral | 27; 29 |
Sokhadze et al.74 | No | 13 (15.6±5.8) | – | Left DLPC | 0.5 | 90 | Not reported | Unilateral | 6 |
Casanova et al.80 | No | 18 (13.1±2.2) | – | DLPC | 0.5 | 90 | 10–12 | Unilateral/Bilateral | 18 (6 left; 6 right;6 bilateral) |
Wang et al.81 | No | 33 (12.88±3.76) | – | DLPC | 0.5 | 90 | Not reported | Unilateral | 12 (6 left; 6 right) |
Sokhadze et al.82 | No | 32 (12.52±2.85) | – | DLPC | 0.5 | 90 | Not reported | Unilateral/Bilateral | 18 (6 left; 6 right; 6 bilateral) |
Abujadi et al.97 | No | 10 (9–17) | – | Right DLPC | 50 | 100 | 5 | Unilateral | 15 |
Sokhadze et al.40 | Waiting list | 8 (18.3±4.8) | 5 (18.3±4.8) | Left DLPC | 0.5 | 90 | Not reported | Unilateral | 6 |
Sokhadze et al.70 | Waiting list | 20 (13.5±2.5) | 20 (14.1±2.4) | DLPC | 1 | 90 | Not reported | Unilateral | 12 (6 left; 6 right_ |
Sokhadze et al.75 | Waiting list | 20 (14.7±3.3) | 22 (14.2±2.8) | DLPC | 1 | 90 | 60 | Unilateral/Bilateral | 18 (6 left; 6 right;6 bilateral) |
Sokhadze et al.98 | Waiting list | 27 (14.8±3.2) | 27 (14.1±2.6) | DLPC | 1 | 90 | Not reported | Unilateral/Bilateral | 18 (6 left; 6 right; 6 bilateral) |
Sokhadze et al.83 | Heal thy controls | 25 (13.6±3.22) | 21 (14.9±4.3) | DLPC | 1 | 90 | Not reported | Unilateral/Bilateral | 18 (6 left; 6 right; 6 bilateral) |
Sokhadze et al.99 | Waiting list | 25 (12.5±1.47) 30 (12.8±1.57) 31 (13.5±2.30) |
26 (13.3±1.78) | DLPC | 1 | 90 | Not reported | Unilateral/Bilateral | 6;12;18 |
Baruth et al.100 | Waiting list | 16 (13.9±5.3) | 9 (13.5±2) | DLPC | 1 | 90 | Not reported | Unilateral | 12 (6 left; 6 right) |
Casanova et al.101 | Waiting list | 25 (12.9±3.1) | 20 (13.1±2.2) | DLPC | 1 | 90 | 10 | Unilateral | 12 (6 left; 6 right) |
Kang et al.102 | Waiting list | 16 (7.8±2.1) | 16 (7.2±1.6) | DLPC | 1 | 90 | Not reported | Unilateral/Bilateral | 18 |
Fecteau et al.103 | Sham | 10 (36.6±16) | 10 (36.6±16) | Left and right pars triangul aris; left and right pars opercul aris | 1 | 70 | 30 | Unilateral | 5 (1 per target; 1 sham) |
Enticott et al.104 | Sham | 11 (17.55±4.06) | 11 (17.55±4.06) | Left M1; SMA | 1 | 100 | 5 | Unilateral | 3 (1 per target; 1 sham) |
Enticott et al.105 | Sham | 15 (33.87±13.07) | 13 (30.54±9.83) | dmPFC | 5 | 100 | Not reported | Bilateral | 10 |
Panerai et al.106 | Sham | 9 (13.56±1.83) 6 (13.7±1.96) 6 (13.33±1.88) 6 (16.13±3.11) |
9 (13.56±1.83) 5 (13.24±2.95) 5 (14.17±4.24) 4 (13.75±5.18) |
PrMC | 1; 8 | 90 | 15(1Hz); 30 (8Hz) | Unilateral/Bilateral | Single and multisession |
Anninos et al.107 | Sham | 10 (8.3+2.1) | 10 (8.3+2.1) | Frontal cortex, vertex, bilateral temporal areas, bilateral parietal areas and occipital cortex | 8–13 | – | 2 | – | One crossover sesión with active or sham pT-TMS, then daily for one month |
Ni et al.108 | Sham | 19 (20.8+1.4) | 19 (20.8+1.4) | DLPC; pSTS | 50 | 80 for active and 60 for sham iT BS | 4 | Bilateral | 1 per target |
Desarkar et al.109 | Sham | 7 (16–35) | 7 (16–35) | DLPC | 20 | 90 | 30–45 | Bilateral | 1 |
Gòmez et al.110 | No | 24 (12.2) | – | Left DLPC | 1 | 90 | 20 | Unilateral | 20 |