Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Sep 8.
Published in final edited form as: Lithos. 2015 Dec 7;244:74–93. doi: 10.1016/j.lithos.2015.11.028

Table A1-C -.

Assessment of the accuracy and precision of the bulk-rock trace element data generated during this study.

Reference materials
AGV-2 GeoReM preferred value Deviation from GeoReM value* BHVO-2 GeoReM preferred value Deviation from GeoReM value* OKUM-1 OKUM-2 Ext. Precision (2-sigma) IAG preliminary certified value Deviation of OKUM averag from IAG valu
Ba (ppm) 1134.4 1130 0.4% 132.2 131 1% 6.2 6.1 2% 6.38 −4%
Be 2.03 2.3 −12% 1.09 1 9% 0.11 0.09 28% 0.066 52%
Bi 0.08 0.04 to 0.07 14% to 100% 0.03 0.01–0.03 0% to 200% 0.01 0.13 242% n.d.
Cd 0.102 0.063 to 0.25 −59% to 62% 0.118 0.06 97% 0.062 0.057 12% n.d.
Ce 69.44 68.6 1% 37 37.5 −1% 1.28 1.17 13% 1.271 −4%
Co 15.87 16 −1% 46.54 45 3% 90.93 90.63 0% 89 2%
Cr 17 16 6% 302 280 8% 2524 2499 1% 2461 2%
Cs 1.13 1.2 −6% 0.096 0.1 −4% 0.183 0.181 2% 0.184 −1%
Cu 52.3 53 −1% 134.3 127 6% 49.1 46 9% 43 11%
Dy 3.56 3.47 3% 5.532 5.31 4% 1.549 1.571 2% 1.609 −3%
Er 1.863 1.81 3% 2.586 2.54 2% 1.018 1.046 4% 1.042 −1%
Eu 1.5038 1.53 −2% 2.0826 2.07 1% 0.2868 0.2961 5% 0.303 −4%
Ga 19.7 20 −2% 21.12 22 −4% 8.75 8.62 2% 8.81 −1%
Gd 4.595 4.52 2% 6.514 6.24 4% 1.237 1.204 4% 1.141 7%
Hf 5.13 5 3% 4.44 4.36 2% 0.57 0.6 7% 0.548 7%
Ho 0.6674 0.65 3% 0.9755 0.98 0% 0.3369 0.3361 0% 0.355 −5%
In 0.0452 0.0452 to 0.05 −10% to 0% 0.0858 0.082–0.19 −55% to 5% 0.034 0.0355 6% n.d.
La 38.29 37.9 1% 15.42 15.2 1% 0.46 0.42 13% 0.415 6%
Li 9.1 11 −17% 4.5 4.8 −6% 4.2 4.3 3% 4.38 −3%
Lu 0.2487 0.247 1% 0.2735 0.274 0% 0.1472 0.146 1% 0.149 −2%
Mo 2.24 1.83–2.26 −1% to 22% 4.29 4 7% 0.37 0.27 44% n.d.
Nb 13.279 14.5 −8% 17.398 18.1 −4% 0.332 0.342 4% 0.346 −3%
Nd 31.08 30.5 2% 24.74 24.5 1% 1.52 1.41 11% 1.49 −2%
Ni 19.2 20 −4% 122.6 119 3% 896.7 902.1 1% 884 2%
Pb 12.9 13.2 −2% 1.5 1.6 −6% 0.3 0.2 57% 0.265 −6%
Pr 8.186 7.84 4% 5.365 5.35 0% 0.258 0.25 4% 0.239 6%
Rb 64.2 66.3 −3% 9.07 9.11 0% 0.88 0.9 3% 0.96 −7%
Sb 0.45 0.385–0.6 −25% to 17% 0.11 0.13 −15% 0.08 0.09 17% 0.077 10%
Sc 12.8 13 −2% 32.9 32 3% 29.2 29 1% 28 4%
Sm 5.656 5.49 3% 6.169 6.07 2% 0.7 0.705 1% 0.712 −1%
Sn 1.8 2.3 −22% 2.61 1.7 54% 0.17 0.23 42% 0.25 −20%
Sr 640.4 661 −3% 388.1 369 5% 15.7 15.6 1% 16.1 −3%
Ta 0.821 0.87 −6% 1.115 1.14 −2% 0.02 0.019 7% 0.026 −25%
Tb 0.6078 0.64 −5% 0.9318 0.92 1% 0.22 0.2222 1% 0.225 −2%
Th 6.277 6.1 3% 1.175 1.22 −4% 0.028 0.029 5% 0.031 −8%
Ti 5912 6295 −6% 16238 16300 0% 2124 2133 1% 2284 −7%
Tl 0.265 0.27 −2% 0.019 0.011–0.08 −76% to 73% 0.014 0.015 10% 0.015 −3%
Tm 0.2537 0.26 −2% 0.3364 0.33 2% 0.145 0.148 3% 0.154 −5%
U 1.895 1.86 2% 0.42 0.403 4% 0.012 0.013 11% 0.014 −11%
V 118.4 122 −3% 319.9 317 1% 173.3 170.2 3% 167 3%
W 0.51 0.439–0.56 −9% to 16% 0.22 0.21 5% 0.09 0.06 57% n.d.
Y 19.16 19 1% 25.83 26 −1% 9.17 9.33 2% 9.27 0%
Yb 1.635 1.62 1% 2.009 2 0% 0.973 0.989 2% 1.02 −4%
Zn 84 86 −2% 98 103 −5% 63 63 0% 61.2 3%
Zr 230 230 0% 170 172 −1% 18 19 8% 17.4 6%
Pipe samples
GV1282 GV1282 - duplicate Ext. Precision (2-sigma) VM1317 VM1317 - duplicate Ext. Precision (2-sigma) BO1242 BO1242 - duplicate Ext. Precision (2-sigma) BO1260 BO1260 - duplicate Ext. Precision (2-sigma)
Ba (ppm) 1.8 1.7 8% 17.1 17.2 1% 179.5 176.4 2% 10201.2 10256.3 1%
Be 0.02 0.03 57% 0.17 0.14 27% 0.92 0.88 6% 0.37 0.34 12%
Bi 0.91 0.88 5% 0.29 0.28 5% 0.59 0.35 72% 0.05 0.02 121%
Cd 0.083 0.077 11% 0.156 0.159 3% 0.425 0.442 6% 0.059 0.053 15%
Ce 0.14 0.13 10% 2.15 2.11 3% 13.93 13.61 3% 62.11 61.74 1%
Co 616.86 603.99 3% 276.34 276.8 0% 115.31 112.32 4% 10.8 11.02 3%
Cr 134 130 4% 2079 2136 4% 938 906 5% 5 5 0%
Cs 0.009 0.009 0% 0.054 0.052 5% 0.356 0.35 2% 0.198 0.194 3%
Cu 387.4 381.5 2% 2217.8 2188.7 2% 1075.9 1042.7 4% 5.8 5.5 8%
Dy 0.007 0.009 35% 0.785 0.796 2% 2.25 2.186 4% 3.079 3.104 1%
Er 0.006 0.006 0% 0.465 0.448 5% 1.356 1.295 7% 1.459 1.44 2%
Eu 0.0074 0.009 28% 0.2397 0.2427 2% 0.9273 0.9108 3% 7.3876 7.5676 3%
Ga 1.55 1.53 2% 5.92 6.09 4% 11.93 11.22 9% 19.81 19.77 0%
Gd 0.01 0.012 26% 0.75 0.746 1% 2.281 2.198 5% 4.904 4.969 2%
Hf 0.02 0.02 0% 0.42 0.4 7% 1.45 1.45 0% 3.54 3.56 1%
Ho 0.0022 0.0018 28% 0.154 0.1566 2% 0.446 0.4513 2% 0.5753 0.5627 3%
In 0.0047 0.0049 6% 0.0395 0.0391 1% 0.0762 0.076 0% 0.0168 0.0173 4%
La 0.07 0.07 0% 0.83 0.82 2% 5.92 5.85 2% 29.67 28.96 3%
Li 0.3 0.3 0% 3.3 3.4 4% 2.9 2.8 5% 3.7 3.8 4%
Lu 0.0009 0.0007 35% 0.0599 0.0597 0% 0.1863 0.1921 4% 0.1446 0.1456 1%
Mo 0.2 0.21 7% 0.14 0.13 10% 0.6 0.61 2% 0.17 0.16 9%
Nb 0.035 0.04 19% 0.223 0.234 7% 3.116 3.017 5% 3.566 3.92 13%
Nd 0.07 0.07 0% 1.9 1.98 6% 9.12 8.94 3% 38.06 37.69 1%
Ni 50340 49562 2% 4142.9 4138.2 0% 2139.7 2079.5 4% 2.7 2.6 5%
Pb 2.8 2.8 0% 3.9 3.9 0% 5 4.7 9% 6.5 6.5 0%
Pr 0.016 0.014 19% 0.354 0.357 1% 2.016 1.932 6% 8.431 8.343 1%
Rb 0.07 0.07 0% 0.42 0.44 7% 6.5 6.16 8% 27.5 27.68 1%
Sb 0.02 0.02 0% 0.02 0.02 0% 0.06 0.07 22% 0.02 0.01 94%
Sc 0.3 0.4 40% 17.2 17.1 1% 25.5 24.3 7% 7.9 8 2%
Sm 0.02 0.014 50% 0.655 0.614 9% 2.135 2.111 2% 6.251 6.2 1%
Sn 0.02 0.02 0% 0.03 0.13 177% 0.97 0.93 6% 0.09 0.09 0%
Sr 0.7 0.7 0% 107.3 107.4 0% 198 193.2 3% 630.4 638.4 2%
Ta bdl. bdl. 0.016 0.016 0% 0.194 0.186 6% 0.112 0.123 13%
Tb 0.0017 0.002 23% 0.1213 0.1207 1% 0.35 0.3506 0% 0.5725 0.5685 1%
Th 0.009 0.01 15% 0.059 0.062 7% 0.614 0.596 4% 0.471 0.476 1%
Ti 174 167 6% 2121 2113 1% 4170 3997 6% 8971 8960 0%
Tl 0.058 0.055 8% 0.029 0.031 9% 0.053 0.051 5% 0.097 0.097 0%
Tm 0.001 0.001 0% 0.061 0.0638 6% 0.1954 0.1922 2% 0.1725 0.1742 1%
U 0.005 0.005 0% 0.019 0.018 8% 0.201 0.186 11% 0.324 0.334 4%
V 26 24.4 9% 180.6 182 1% 174.1 166.1 7% 120.6 121.4 1%
W 0.03 0.02 57% 0.87 0.88 2% 0.22 0.21 7% 0.02 0.02 0%
Y 0.04 0.04 0% 4.05 4.02 1% 12.38 11.94 5% 15.26 15.21 0%
Yb 0.006 0.005 26% 0.411 0.396 5% 1.286 1.224 7% 1.001 1.007 1%
Zn 7 8 19% 109 112 4% 169 161 7% 66 65 2%
Zr 1 1 0% 14 13 10% 65 64 2% 228 229 1%