Skip to main content
. 2020 Jul 27;13(1):1792682. doi: 10.1080/16549716.2020.1792682

Table 3.

Publications comparing MITS with CDA.

First Author Year Journal Specific Study Objective Population Studied Total MITS Conducted Results
West [38] 1957 American Journal of Medical Science Compare diagnosis made by MITS to CDA Adults 66
  • 77% of MITS cases were able to reach a diagnosis

  • In 48% of the cases there was agreement between MITS and CDA

Foroudi [42] 1995 Pathology Compare results of MITS with CDA Adults 21
  • Cause of death ascertained in 43% of MITS cases compared to 95% of CDA

Huston [43] 1996 Modern Pathology Demonstrate the value and limitations of postmortem needle sampling in correlating tissue diagnosis compared with CDA Adults 20
  • Cause of death was confirmed by MITS in 60% of the patients

  • MITS confirmed additional diagnosis identified by CDA in 75% of the cases

Cina [67] 1999 Military Medicine Evaluate the role of percutaneous core biopsy of the liver in determining pathology in unexpected deaths related to hepatomegaly Adults 28
  • 86% correlation between MITS and CDA

Breeze [73] 2008 Virchows Archive Determine the feasibility of percutaneous fetal organ biopsies: how frequently are adequate samples obtained; comparison of percutaneous biopsy with conventional block biopsy Stillbirths 30
  • 46% of samples collected via MITS were considered adequate

  • Adequate samples were obtained from lungs and liver

Garg [22] 2009 Fetal and Pediatric Pathology Compare the specimen adequacy
and histologic and laboratory findings on lung tissue collected using blind-needle biopsy MITS with those from CDA in a pediatric respiratory disease mortality study undertaken at a large public hospital in Kenya, assessing the contribution of molecular microbiologic testing
Neonates 25
  • Full agreement between CDA and MITS in 56% of cases

  • Partial agreement between CDA and MITS in 12% of cases

Van der Linden [74] 2014 PLoS One Compare the RNA quality of samples obtained via MITS to samples obtained via CDA with fresh frozen samples as a reference Adults 24
  • Samples obtained via MITS had higher quality RNA compared with those collected via CDA

Castillo [27] 2016 PLoS Medicine Compare cause of death in adults ascertained via MITS with cause of death after CDA Adults 112
  • 75.9% agreement in MITS and CDA in cause of death determination

  • Able to ascertain cause of death in 89% of MITS cases and 100% of CDA cases

Castillo [10] 2017 PLoS Medicine Compare cause of death in maternal cases ascertained via MITS with cause of death after CDA Adults 57
  • 68% agreement between MITS and CDA in cause of death

  • Able to ascertain cause of death in 84% of MITS cases compared with 98% of CDA

Bassat [31] 2017 PLoS Medicine Compare cause of death in children ascertained via MITS with cause of death after CDA Children 54
  • 89% concordance in cause of death between MITS and CDA

Menendez [32] 2017 PLoS Medicine Compare cause of death in stillbirths ascertained via MITS with cause of death after CDA Stillbirths and neonates 59
  • 68% agreement between CDA and MITS

  • Cause of death ascertained in 83% of MITS cases compared with 89% of CDA cases

Fernandes [75] 2019 Human Pathology Determine the degree to which clinical information improves the diagnostic accuracy of the CDA and MIA Adults 112
  • Cause of death was ascertained in 89% of MITS cases (all populations) that included clinical information compared with 80% of MITS cases without clinical data

Maternal deaths 57
Children 54
Neonates 41
Stillbirths 18