Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 8;8:e9746. doi: 10.7717/peerj.9746

Table 2. The limitations of approaches for the generation of beta-cells.

Ex-vivo generation of beta-cells ESCs differentiation in vitro iPSCs differentiation in vitro Non-beta pancreatic cells transdifferentiation in vivo Non-beta pancreatic cells transdifferentiation in vitro Fibroblasts transdifferentiation in vitro References
Limited sources Yes Yes No Yes Yes No Huang & Chang (2014)
Risk of teratoma development No Yes Yes No No No Hentze et al. (2009)
Allograft rejection No Yes No No No No Hentze et al. (2009)
Lack of organization into islets No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Zhou et al. (2008)
Lack of reproducibility of the protocols No No No Yes Yes Yes Kim, Jeong & Choi (2020)
Off-target effects after manipulation with genome No No Yes/Noa Yes Yes/Noa Yes/Noa Clayton et al. (2016)
The necessity of deep invasion for cell product preparation Yes No No No Yes No Trivedi et al. (2008) and Matsumoto & Shimoda (2020)
The necessity of deep invasion for transplantation of final cell product Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Shapiro, Pokrywczynska & Ricordi (2017) and Matsumoto & Shimoda (2020)

Notes.

a

The presence of off-target effects will depend on the reprogramming methods (integrating or non-integrating).