Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 11;15(9):e0239040. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0239040

Table 1. Summary of studies examining the associations between chronic health conditions and cognitive performance in individuals with DS.

Author(s), Year; CHC Category Study Type (location) Age range (years): n Population Neurocognitive measure(s) Neurocognitive Scoring/Domains Neurocognitive Results
Andreou et al., 2002 Sleep disorder Prospective cohort (Greece) 17–25: 12 DS+SDB Raven Progressive Matrices (RPM) Raw: Visual-Spatial, Reasoning
 1) Sum of correct items
SDB negatively correlated with visual-spatial scores, particularly in adults with DS+ untreated SDB.
Chen et al., 2013 Sleep disorder Prospective cohort (U.S.) 14–31: 29 DS+parent- rated OSA 1) Choice Reaction Time test
2) Verbal Fluency test
3) Knock-Tap Test
Raw: Executive Function
 1) mean reaction time
 2) sum of words generated
 3) sum of correct responses
The severity of parent-rated OSA in DS moderately correlated with executive function performance. More severe symptoms predicted poorer performance.
Breslin et al., 2014 Sleep disorder Prospective cohort (U.S.) 7–12: 38 DS±OSA Cambridge Neuropsych. Test Automated Battery (CANTAB):
1) Intra-Extra Dimensional Set Shifting
2) Paired-Associative Learning Task
3) Simple Reaction Time Task
Kaufman Brief Intelligence Test (KBIT-II)
Raw: Executive Function
 1) Stages completed
 2) Mean errors
 3) Median reaction time
SS: Full, Verbal, Non-verbal IQ
DS+OSA completed fewer stages for the set shifting task of cognitive flexibility. Reaction time and mean errors did not differ between groups.
DS+OSA had lower verbal IQ. No differences in full-scale or non-verbal IQ.
Brooks et al., 2015 Sleep disorder Prospective cohort (U.S.) 6–14: 25 DS±OSA Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scales, 4th Edition (SB-4)
Beery-Buktenica Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (Berry VMI)
Conners Hyperactivity Index *Parent rept
SS: Full IQ, Bead Memory, Vocabulary, Quantitative Pattern Analysis, Memory for Sentences, Comprehension
SS: Visual, Motor, and Visual-Motor Integration
SS: Attention
No differences in cognitive performance between DS children with and without OSA. Total sleep time and latency contributed to cognitive performance.
Of 10 DS+OSA, the 5 treated with adenotonsillectomy and/or CPAP showed improvements in parent-reported attention.
Joyce et al., 2017 Sleep disorder Case control (U.K.) 2–5: 44 DS+SDB: 22 TD+SDB: 22 Mullen Scales of Early Learning (MSEL) Sc: Gross motor, fine motor, visual reception, receptive language, expressive language
Raw: sum of total score
SDB in preschoolers with DS not associated with cognitive outcomes involving motor skills and language.
Joyce et al., 2019 Sleep disorder Prospective cohort (U.K.) 3–6: 80 DS±OSA Behavior Rating Inventory of Executive Function–Preschool Version (BRIEF-P) *Parent rept T score: Inhibit, shift, emotional control, working memory, inhibitory self-control index, flexibility index, emergent metacognition index, global executive composite, plan/organize OSA associated with poorer working memory, emotional control, and shifting (aspects of executive function).
Lee et al., 2019 Sleep disorder Prospective cohort
(Taiwan)
6–18: 30 DS±OSA Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence (WPPSI-R)
Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC-IV)
Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale (WAIS-III)
Developmental Neuropsychological Assessment (NEPSY) visuomotor precision
Sc: Vocabulary (this was the only subtest reported in the results)
SS: FSIQ
Sc: Fine motor skills
After adjustment for age and FSIQ, DS+OSA not associated with deficits in vocabulary or visuomotor precision.
In a subgroup of ages 6–12 years, OSA associated with lower WPPSI-R vocabulary. No associations with visuomotor precision.
Rihtman et al., 2010 Cardiovascular disorder Cross-sectional (Israel) 6–17: 60 DS±other congenital anomalies (36 CHD) Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scales (SB-4)
Beery-Buktenica Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (Berry VMI)
SS: Full IQ, Verbal, Abstract/Visual, Qualitative Reasoning, Short-Term Memory
SS: Visual, Motor, and Visual-Motor Integration
Presence or severity of congenital anomaly (i.e. CHD) not associated with cognitive performance.
Visootsak et al., 2011 Cardiovascular disorder Case control (U.S.) 0.5–2: 29 DS+CHD: 12 DS-CHD: 17 Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler Development (Bayley-III) SS: Cognitive, Language, and Motor. Infants with DS+CHD had lower motor composite scores, but no differences in cognitive or language composite scores.
Visootsak et al., 2013 Cardiovascular disorder Case control (U.S.) 2–3.5: 29 DS+CHD: 12 DS-CHD: 17 Mullen Scales of Early Learning (MSEL) Sc: Expressive Language, Receptive Language, Visual Reception, Fine Motor No differences in expressive, receptive language, or visual and fine motor.
Alsaied et al., 2016 Cardiovascular disorder Cross-sectional (U.S.) 0–2: 36 DS+CHD: 12 DS-CHD: 24
3–5: 38
DS+CHD: 7 DS-CHD: 31
6–18: 104
DS+CHD: 26 DS-CHD: 78
Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler Development (Bayley-III)
Peabody Developmental Motor Scales (PDMS-II)
Brief Rating Inventory of Executive Function (BRIEF) *Parent rept
Differential Ability Scales (DAS-II)
Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scales (SB-5)
SS: Language, Motor
Sc:" Receptive Language, Expressive Language, Fine Motor, Gross Motor
Raw: Visual Motor, Grasping
SS: Fine Motor
T score: Executive function, Initiate, Global executive composite, Behav. Regulation, Emotional control, Inhibit, Plan/Organize, Monitor, Working memory, Composite organization of materials
SS: Nonverbal IQ
SS: Full IQ, Knowledge, Qualitative Reasoning, Visual Spatial
Infants with DS+CHD had lower receptive, expressive, and language scores. No differences in fine/gross motor scores.
Preschoolers with DS+CHD did not differ in auditory or expressive language, visual motor, grasping, or fine motor scores.
Children with DS+CHD did not differ in executive function, nor in performance-based measures of nonverbal IQ, full IQ, knowledge, qualitative reasoning, and visual spatial skills.
Visootsak et al., 2016 Cardiovascular disorder Case-control (U.S.) 0.5–2: 57 DS+CHD: 20 DS-CHD: 37 Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler Development (Bayley-III) Raw Composite: Cognitive, Expressive Language, Receptive Language, Gross Motor, Fine Motor In adjusted analyses, DS+ASVD had lower gross motor and cognition/ expressive language scores.
Rosser et al., 2018 Cardiovascular disorder (among other CHC) Cross-sectional (U.S.) 6–25: 226 DS+CHD:122 DS-CHD: 104 Arizona State Cognitive Battery: CANTAB, reaction time, paired-associate learning, spatial span, intra/extradimensional set-shifting
Virtual computer-generated arena
Modified dots task
Finger sequencing task
Developmental Neuropsychological Assessment (NEPSY) visuomotor precision
Kaufman Brief Intelligence Test (KBIT-II)
Scales of Independent Behavior-Revised (SIB-R)*Parent rept
Behavior Rating Inventory of Executive Function-School Age (BRIEF)* Parent rept
Nisonger Child Behavior Rating Form (NCBRF) *Parent rept
Z scores: Associative learning, reaction time, memory span, set-shifting
Raw: Spatial learning
Raw: Inhibitory control, working memory
Raw: Sensorimotor function
Sc: Fine motor skills
SS: Full, Verbal, Non-verbal IQ
Sc: Motor, social and communication, personal living, community living skills
T score: Executive function, Initiate, Global executive composite, Behav. Regulation, Emotional control, Inhibit, Plan/Organize, Monitor, Working memory, Composite organization of materials
Sc: Compliant/calm, adaptive social, conduct problems, insecure/anxious, hyperactive, self-injury/stereotypic, self-isolated/ritualistic, overly sensitive
CHD requiring surgery in the first years of life was not associated with poorer cognitive ability for both performance-based and proxy-reported assessments, after adjusting for gender, race/ethnicity, socioeconomic status.
Wasant et al., 2008 Cardiovascular & thyroid disorders (among other CHC) Cross-sectional (Thailand) 3–6: 100 Capute Scales of Cognitive Adaptive Test/Clinical Linguistic and auditory Milestones Scales (CAT/CLAMS) SS: Developmental Quotient (DQ) CHD, but not thyroid disorders, was associated with lower DQ. Family income and age at the first speech-training program were the only independent predictors of DQ.
Tapp et al., 2005 Seizure disorder Prospective cohort (U.S.) 1–3: 29 DS+IS: 8 DS-seizures: 21 Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler Development (Bayley-III) Sc: Receptive Language, Expressive Language, Fine Motor, Gross Motor
SS: Cognitive
DS+IS scored lower across all cognition domains. IS treatment delays did not contribute to neurodevelopmental outcomes.

DS = Down syndrome, TD = typically developing without Down syndrome, SDB = sleep disordered breathing, WS = William’s syndrome, ID = Intellectual disability, CHC = Chronic health condition, CHD = Congenital heart disease, ASVD = Atrioventricular septal defect, ASD = Atrial septal defect, OSA = Obstructive sleep apnea, IS = infantile spasms, SQ = sleep quality, IQ = intelligence quotient, DQ = developmental quotient, MA = mental age, SS = standard composite score, SD = 15. Sc = Scaled scores based on age-normed T scores.