Skip to main content
. 2020 Sep 10;13:464. doi: 10.1186/s13071-020-04339-0

Table 1.

Ecological risk factors associated with the spread and sustained circulation of three mosquito-borne viruses (i.e. RVFV, JEV and WNV) and three tick-borne viruses (TBEV, LIV and CCHFV) that were included for the development of hazard maps for arbovirus introduction and establishment

Introduction risk factors Establishment risk factors
Abiotic Host Vector
Mosquito-borne viruses
 RVFV na Positive effect of TG from April to October Abundance of ruminant livestock (i.e. sheep, goat, and cattle) Culex and Aedes abundance
 JEV Abundance of birds with overlapping migratory flyways with conspecifics from JEV-endemic areas in Asia Number of days with TX ≥ 25 °C Abundance of ardeid bird species and domestic pigs Culex abundance
 WNV Abundance of bird species that migrate from Africa and/or the Mediterranean area to the Netherlands in spring Positive effect of TG from April to October Abundance of wetland birds, crow, jackdaw, magpie, pigeon, and house sparrow Culex abundance
Tick-borne viruses
 TBEV na

Slope of TG decrease from August to October

Slope of TG increase from March to May

Positive effect of UG from April to October

Presence of deer and free-ranging livestock (i.e. cattle, sheep, goat, horse) Suitable habitat for I. ricinus ticks
 LIV na

Slope of TG decrease from August to October

Slope of TG increase from March to May

Positive effect of UG from April to October

Abundance of sheep Suitable habitat for I. ricinus ticks
 CCHFV Abundance of bird species that migrate from Africa and/or the Mediterranean area to the Netherlands in spring

Negative effect of RH

Positive effect of TG from April to October

Abundance of livestock (i.e. cattle, horse, sheep, goat) Suitable habitat for H. marginatum ticks

Choice of the below listed factors was based upon the systematic review of Esser et al. [22]

Abbreviations: UG, 24 h average relative humidity; RH, 24 h sum of precipitation; TG, 24 h average temperature; TX, 24 h maximum temperature