Table 1.
Ecological risk factors associated with the spread and sustained circulation of three mosquito-borne viruses (i.e. RVFV, JEV and WNV) and three tick-borne viruses (TBEV, LIV and CCHFV) that were included for the development of hazard maps for arbovirus introduction and establishment
| Introduction risk factors | Establishment risk factors | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Abiotic | Host | Vector | ||
| Mosquito-borne viruses | ||||
| RVFV | na | Positive effect of TG from April to October | Abundance of ruminant livestock (i.e. sheep, goat, and cattle) | Culex and Aedes abundance |
| JEV | Abundance of birds with overlapping migratory flyways with conspecifics from JEV-endemic areas in Asia | Number of days with TX ≥ 25 °C | Abundance of ardeid bird species and domestic pigs | Culex abundance |
| WNV | Abundance of bird species that migrate from Africa and/or the Mediterranean area to the Netherlands in spring | Positive effect of TG from April to October | Abundance of wetland birds, crow, jackdaw, magpie, pigeon, and house sparrow | Culex abundance |
| Tick-borne viruses | ||||
| TBEV | na |
Slope of TG decrease from August to October Slope of TG increase from March to May Positive effect of UG from April to October |
Presence of deer and free-ranging livestock (i.e. cattle, sheep, goat, horse) | Suitable habitat for I. ricinus ticks |
| LIV | na |
Slope of TG decrease from August to October Slope of TG increase from March to May Positive effect of UG from April to October |
Abundance of sheep | Suitable habitat for I. ricinus ticks |
| CCHFV | Abundance of bird species that migrate from Africa and/or the Mediterranean area to the Netherlands in spring |
Negative effect of RH Positive effect of TG from April to October |
Abundance of livestock (i.e. cattle, horse, sheep, goat) | Suitable habitat for H. marginatum ticks |
Choice of the below listed factors was based upon the systematic review of Esser et al. [22]
Abbreviations: UG, 24 h average relative humidity; RH, 24 h sum of precipitation; TG, 24 h average temperature; TX, 24 h maximum temperature