Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Sep 14.
Published in final edited form as: Target Oncol. 2017 Jun;12(3):265–275. doi: 10.1007/s11523-017-0494-5

Table 1.

Summary of prognostic and predictive biomarkers in stage II and III CC

Variable Study Sample size Disease stage and characteristics 1° Endpoint HR CI 95% p value Type of analysis Ref
MSI vs MSS PETACC-3 1404 II and III OS 0.49 0.34–0.69 0.001 univariate [16]
RFS 0.47 0.31–0.72 <0.001 univariate
QUASAR 1913 II and III RFS 0.53 0.40–0.70 <0.001 univariate [17]
ACCENT 2723 III treated OS 0.79 0.65–0.97 0.023 univariate [18]
TTR 0.80 0.66–0.97 0.025 univariate
  307 II untreated TTR 0.27 0.10–0.75 0.012 univariate
OS 0.27 0.10–0.74 0.011 univariate
NSABP 1796 II and III OS 0.64 0.46–0.89 0.008 multivariate [19]
C-07/C-08
TTR 0.48 0.33–0.70 0.0001 multivariate
NO147 2580 III DFS 0.82 0.64–1.07 0.1403 multivariate [20]
III left DFS 1.71 0.99–2.95 0.0564 multivariate
III right DFS 0.71 0.53–0.94 0.0184 multivariate
CALGB89803   891 III left DFS 1.58 0.72–3.46 0.2817 multivariate
III right DFS 0.59 0.41–0.86 0.0039 multivariate
BRAF MUT vs WT PETACC-3 1423 II and III OS 1.78 1.26–2.53 0.0009 univariate [21]
RFS 1.30 0.94–1.81 0.1174 univariate
SAR 2.48 1.74–3.53 <0.0001 univariate
  697 II and III, MSS/left OS 6.41 3.57–11.52 <0.0001 univariate
RFS 3.57 2.02–6.31 0.0005 univariate
1054 II and III, MSS OS 2.82 1.58–4.30 <0.0001 univariate
QUASAR 1584 II and III RR 0.84 0.57–1.23 0.4 univariate [17]
NSABP 2226 II and III OS 1.46 1.20–1.79 0.0002 univariate [19]
C-07/C-08
TTR 1.02 0.82–1.28 0.86 univariate
SAR 2.31 1.83–2.95 <0.0001 univariate
  201 II and III, MSI OS 1.76 0.88–3.49 0.11 multivariate
1534 II and III, MSS OS 1.58 1.23–2.04 0.0004 multivariate
CALGB89803   506 III OS 1.66 1.05–2.63 0.015 univariate [22]
  428 III, MSS OS 1.61 0.96–2.69 NA multivariate
NO147 2515 III DFS 1.34 1.11–1.63 0.0028 univariate [20]
2176 III, MSS DFS 1.32 1.01–1.73 0.0437 multivariate
  304 III, MSI DFS 1.58 0.88–2.82 0.1220 multivariate
Meta-analysis of 7 RCT 8721 II and III OS 1.42 1.25–1.60 <0.0001 univariate [23]
DFS 1.26 1.07–1.48 0.006 univariate
KRAS MUT vs WT PETACC-3 1423 II and III OS 1.09 0.86–1.37 0.4826 univariate [21]
RFS 1.04 0.85–1.27 0.7245 univariate
SAR 1.04 0.82–1.32 0.7222 univariate
NSABP 2081 II and III OS 1.09 0.92–1.29 0.33 univariate [19]
C-07/C-08
TTR 1.12 0.94–1.32 0.21 univariate
SAR 1.11 0.92–1.34 0.30 univariate
QUASAR 1583 II and III RR 1.40 1.12–1.74 0.002 univariate [17]
Prospective cohort 1075 I-IV BRAF WT, KRAS codon 12 mut vs wt CCSM 1.30 1.02–1.67 0.037 multivariate [24]
OS 1.24 1.02–1.51 0.029 multivariate
I-IV BRAF WT, KRAS codon 13 mut vs wt CCSM 0.86 0.58–1.27 NS multivariate
OS 0.96 0.71–1.30 NS multivariate
NO147 2478 III BRAF WT, KRAS codon 12 mut vs wt DFS 1.52 1.28–1.80 <0.0001 multivariate [25]
III BRAF WT, KRAS codon 13 mut vs wt DFS 1.36   1.0–1.77 0.0248 multivariate
PETACC-8 1629 III TTR 1.56   1.2–1.92 <0.001 multivariate [26]
1043 III BRAF WT, left, KRAS codon 12 mut vs wt TTR 1.96   1.5–2.56 <0.0001 multivariate
III BRAF WT, left, KRAS codon 13 mut v wt TTR 1.59   1.0–2.56 0.051 multivariate
ERBB2 alterations vs WT PETACC-8 1800 III TTR 1.55 1.02–2.36 0.04 univariate [27]
OS 1.57 0.99–2.5 0.05 univariate
CDX2 neg vs pos Independent and retrospective cohorts   466 II and III DFS 2.73 1.58–4.72 <0.001 multivariate [15]
  314 II and III DFS 2.42 1.36–4.29 0.003 multivariate
SMAD4 loss vs no loss PETACC-3 1381 II and III OS 1.58 1.23–2.01 <0.001 multivariate [28]
RFS 1.47 1.19–1.81 <0.001 multivariate
Low IM vs High IM Prospective cohort   690 I, II and III TTR 0.35 0.23–0.52 <0.0001 univariate [29]
  630 I, II and III TTR 0.54 0.34–0.84 0.006 univariate

MSI: Microsatellite Instability, MSS: Microsatellite Stable, OS: Overall Survival, RFS: Relapse Free Survival, TTR: Time To Relapse, HR: Hazard Ratio, CI: Confidence Interval, mut: mutation, WT: Wild Type, SAR: Survival After Recurrence, DFS: Disease Free Survival, RR: Response Rate, CCSM: Colorectal Cancer-Specific Mortality, and IM: Immunoscore